ARTICLES Pope Benedict XVI on Tradition:  SUMMARY
Tradition as "a living dynamic reality".

By Fr. James Fannan, PIME

Introduction

Our Holy Father Benedict XVI has continued the efforts of recent Popes, especially since the time of Pope John XXIII, to deepen our understanding of those truths which touch upon the question of ecumenical dialogue. The Lutheran principle of sola scriptura (Scripture alone) as the sole authority in matters of faith remains at the heart of Protestant thought even today. It is necessary, therefore, that we Catholics have a clear idea of our own teaching if we hope to engage in fruitful dialogue.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church expresses succinctly the Catholic position on this question in these words: "sacred Tradition, Sacred Scripture and the Magisterium of the Church are so connected and associated that one of them cannot stand without the others. Working together, each in its own way, under the action of the one Holy Spirit, they contribute effectively to the salvation of souls" (No. 95). It is important to note immediately the role of the Holy Spirit in each of the three realities mentioned here: Tradition, Scripture, and the Magisterium.

Recently, the Holy Father dedicated three of his general audiences to clarifying Catholic teaching on one of these three realities, namely, Tradition. It is in the light of his teaching that this article has the subtitle "Tradition as a ‘living dynamic reality.’" This phrase might seem contradictory to some notions of Tradition, and perhaps that is why Pope Benedict felt it necessary to devote so much time to clarifying the topic. The notion that Tradition is a "living dynamic reality" is explicitly stated in the Pope’s Apostolic Exhortation Verbum Domini (The Word of the Lord) in the section entitled "Tradition and Scripture." In that section, footnote number 57 refers to section number 8 of the document Dei Verbum (God’s Word) of the Second Vatican Council. This section is key to understanding the Pope’s explanation of Apostolic Tradition. The Catechism itself, referring to the Council texts, states that: "The Tradition here in question comes from the apostles and hands on what they received from Jesus’ teaching and example and what they learned from the Holy Spirit. The first generation of Christians did not yet have a written New Testament, and the New Testament itself demonstrates the process of living Tradition" (No. 83). It is in the light of this statement that we can understand another statement of the same Catechism: "And [Holy] Tradition transmits in its entirety the Word of God that has been entrusted to the apostles by Christ the Lord and the Holy Spirit" (No. 81).

The Catechism further clarifies of the relationship between Scripture and Tradition in this way: "Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture then are bound closely together, and communicate one with the other, for both of them, flowing out from the same divine well-spring, come together in some fashion to form one thing and move towards the same goal." The Catechism then goes on to add this explanatory phrase about Scripture and Tradition: "Each of them makes present and fruitful in the Church the mystery of Christ, who promised to remain with his own ‘always, to the close of the age’" (No. 80). It is therefore this presence of Christ through his Spirit which lies at the heart of the Catholic insistence on the importance of Tradition as well as Scripture in our response of faith to the Word of God. Although the Sacred Scripture is described as the "speech of God as it is put down in writing under the breath of the Holy Spirit," the Catechism clearly insists that "Tradition transmits in its entirety the Word of God which has been entrusted to the apostles," and it goes on to add that "It transmits it to the successors of the apostles so that, enlightened by the Spirit of truth, they may faithfully preserve, expound, and spread it abroad by their preaching" (No. 81).

Not like a Box of Dead Things

Here, for the sake of clarity and to avoid misunderstanding, it is useful to note these words of the Pope at his general audience of May 3, 2006. Speaking of Tradition, he says "it is not a collection of things or words, like a box of dead things. Tradition is the river of new life that flows from the origins, from Christ down to us, and makes us participate in God’s history with humanity." To be especially noted is the phrase that it is not "like a box of dead things." It is precisely because of this that Tradition has that dynamic quality which was referred to in the title of this article. It is a quality that can seem for some at first glance to be a contradiction in terms.

In fact, in his audience of May 3, the Pope was reiterating what he had explained already in the previous week (April 26, 2006). What he says there gives a correct understanding of what tradition truly is. The Holy Father begins with the idea of ecclesial communion and points out that this is "inspired and sustained by the Holy Spirit" and "preserved and promoted by the apostolic ministry." This communion is the Church, which is not limited to just one historical period. Rather it extends to all generations. The Pope thus speaks of a "diachronic universality" (universality throughout time) in which "all epochs belong to us, and all the believers of the past and of the future form with us a single great communion." Thus, "Thanks to the Paraclete, it will always be possible for subsequent generations to have the same experience of the Risen One that was lived by the apostolic community at the origin of the Church, since it is passed on and actualized in the faith, worship and communion of the People of God on pilgrimage through time." Note how key is the role of the Spirit of the risen Lord in rendering ever present in all ages the Lord who promised never to abandon his Church. It is this presence that creates the "single great communion" which transcends time and gives us today an ever new yet continuous participation in the revelation of Christ.

Here there emerges clearly what we have seen above in the audience of May 3, 2006; namely, that when we speak of "Tradition" we are not speaking of "a collection of things or words, like a box of dead things." Rather, "Tradition is the river of new life that flows from the origins, from Christ down to us, and makes us participate in God’s history with humanity." What the Pope says here is obviously something that he realizes needs clarification if a fruitful ecumenical dialogue is to be pursued. It is necessary therefore that Catholics first of all have a very clear idea of what Tradition is. In fact, there is a historic basis for misunderstanding the true nature of Tradition. In his audience of March 10, 2010, Pope Benedict again addressed the topic of Tradition, quoting the words of Jesus about the Holy Spirit, "he will take what is mine and declare if to you" (Jn 16:15). He does this in reference to St. Bonaventure, who was an ardent follower of St. Francis of Assisi and who himself then went on to become the Minister General of the Franciscans in 1257. The Pope notes that at that time, it was common among theologians to believe that "the Fathers of the Church were the absolute summit of theology" and that "successive generations could only be their disciples." Bonaventure realized, however, that St. Francis of Assisi was proof that "the riches of Christ’s word are inexhaustible and that new light could also appear to the new generations." It is the "Oneness of Christ" that guarantees newness and renewal in all the periods of history. It is the Spirit of Christ who throughout time, "will take what is mine and declare it to you" (Jn 16:15).

Thanks to the Paraclete

The success of Luther’s theory of sola scriptura in gaining adherents shows that Bonaventure’s insight into the action of the Spirit was still not fully appreciated by the Catholics of past times, including many of Luther’s contemporaries. The Pope’s insistence on this theme would seem to indicate that even today he sees a need to clarify this concept among Catholics of our own time. In his audience of April 26, 2006, he very succinctly states: "the Church’s apostolic Tradition consists in this transmission of the goods of salvation which, through the power of the Spirit, makes the Christian community the permanent actualization of the original communion." Thus, as we have seen, "Thanks to the Paraclete, it will always be possible for subsequent generations to have the same experience of the Risen One that was lived by the apostolic community at the origin of the Church since it is passed on and actualized in the faith, worship and communion of the People of God, on pilgrimage through time." Thus the saving presence of the Lord is realized here and now by the Holy Spirit.

He also states that, "The Acts of the Apostles – in continuity with the pattern of Luke’s Gospel – show vividly the interpenetration between the Spirit, those sent out by Christ and the community that have gathered." The Pope then elaborates on his thought in this way,"This permanent actualization of the active presence of the Lord Jesus in his People, brought about by the Holy Spirit and expressed in the Church through the apostolic ministry and fraternal communion, is what, in a theological sense, is meant by the term Tradition: it is not merely the material transmission of what was given at the beginning to the Apostles, but the effective presence of the Crucified and Risen Lord Jesus who accompanies and guides in the Spirit the community he has gathered together." In a word, "Tradition is the permanent presence of the Savior who comes to meet us, to redeem us and to sanctify us in the Spirit, through the ministry of his Church to the glory of the Father." It is clear in this quote that the whole community, united under the Apostles’ successors continues to experience this guiding presence of the Spirit.

We can therefore understand that what we mean by "Tradition" goes beyond the famous quote of St. Paul that has often been used in Catholic circles to express the Catholic position against Sola Scriptura. St Paul wrote to the Thessalonians: "Hold fast to the traditions you received from us, either by our word or by letter"(2 Th 2:15). This could easily give the notion of something static and fixed. Instead of this limited notion, the Pope sees the role of tradition in the words of Christ, "I am with you always, to the close of the age" (Mt 28:20). The Holy Father would no doubt also see tradition in the words of Christ to his apostles: "As the Father has sent me, so I send you …. Receive the Holy Spirit" (Jn 20:21-22). What the Pope is saying was stated by the Council, but it was not said with the same clarity, which is why the Pope’s clarifications are so striking. In fact, in his audience of May 3, 2006 he specifically refers to what the Council said in Dei Verbum, No. 8 (on Divine Revelation): "What was handed on by the Apostles comprises everything that serves to make the People of God live their lives in holiness and increase their faith. In this way, the Church, in her doctrine, life and worship, perpetuates and transmits to every generation all that she herself is, all that she believes." Nevertheless, the richness of the Council teaching could easily escape the attention of most readers without the Pope’s clarifications. In particular and in a striking way, he stated at the end of that same general audience that, "The distance of the centuries is overcome and the Risen One offers himself alive and active for our sake, in the Church and in the world today …. In the living river of Tradition, Christ is not 2,000 years away but is really present among us and gives us the Truth, he gives us the light and makes us live and find the way towards the future."

Besides the Council and this series of general audiences, there is another important source for understanding the Pope’s thought on tradition. It goes back to the days when he was the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. When the Holy Father Pope John Paul II decided to make public the "third secret" of Fatima, a considerable effort was made to put the message in a proper theological context, so what the then Cardinal Ratzinger had to say at that time already reveals partly what he is very clearly saying now.

The Message of Fatima

In the document entitled, The Message of Fatima, there is a section entitled "Theological Commentary." It is here that the future Pope gives yet another important aspect of the Church’s teaching on Tradition. He does this first and foremost by putting it in the context of Dei Verbum, No. 8. There we read (please note in particular what I have italicized): "For there is a growth in the understanding of the realities and the words which have been handed down. This happens through the contemplation and study made by believers, who treasure these things in their hearts, (cf. Lk 2:19, 51), through the intimate understanding of the spiritual things that they experience, and through the preaching of those who have received through Episcopal succession the sure gift of truth"

In the same section, the Council further clarifies:

"This tradition which comes from the apostles develops in the Church with the help of the Holy Spirit …. For as the centuries succeed on another, the Church constantly moves forward toward the fullness of divine truth until the words of God reach their complete fulfillment in her …. Thus God, who spoke of old uninterruptedly converses with the Bride of the beloved Son; and the Holy Spirit, through whom the living voice of the Gospel resounds in the Church, and through her, in the world, leads into all truth those who believe and makes the word of Christ dwell abundantly in them (cf. Col 3:16)."

What is perhaps most striking is that the present Pope then went on to add the statement that "In this context it now becomes possible to understand rightly the concept of ‘private revelation’ which refers to all the visions and revelations which have taken place since the completion of the New Testament." He adds that Jesus was referring also to private revelations when he said: "I have yet many things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now. When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth; for he will not speak on his own authority … He will glorify me, for he will take what is mine and declare it to you" (Jn 16:12-14). The importance that the present Pope gave to private revelation would probably still be a surprise to many engaged in the work of writing theology because it clearly runs so contrary to the general choice of topics in contemporary theological journals.

The idea that private revelation should be viewed in the context of tradition has, however, in fact been the praxis of the Church, as is evident in the liturgical year. Thus, to name just a few, there is a feast of Our Lady of Lourdes, there is the solemn celebration of the Feast of the Sacred Heart, and most recently there has been the introduction of the Feast of Divine Mercy, which is part of the devotion which was spread by St. Faustina Kawalska. Nevertheless, within the contemporary Catholic Church, there is a very strong tendency to confine discussions and interest in private revelations in our own times to a kind of "ghetto" in publications that are aimed at limited group within the general public rather than more academic circles. In short, there is a lack of truly scholarly interest about private revelations in theological journals. From what we have seen, this attitude is not in harmony with the Magisterium and it therefore is a mistaken attitude.

Do not despise Prophetic Utterances

This reduction of the contents of private revelation to some sort of theological ghetto is clearly not the mind of the Church nor of our present Pope. This is also not the reality that we see in the history of the Church. Already in the early days of the Church, St. Paul had warned his readers not to "despise prophetic utterances" (2 Th 5:20). We also see that "prophets" were a recognized group within the Church itself (cf. 1 Cor 12:28, Acts 13:1-2). The fact that this is not limited to apostolic times is confirmed by the lives of various saints who were noted for this charism. In fact, this charism is common in Church history. Pope John Paul II named two saints as patronesses of Europe who were noted for private revelations and prophecy: St. Catherine of Siena and St. Bridget of Sweden. These two saints even wrote letters to the Popes with urgent messages from Christ about the practical work of guiding the Church.

It is therefore precisely in the realm of prophecy that the future Benedict XVI considers these writings referred to as private revelations, remarking that they, "explain the will of God for the present, and therefore show the right path to take for the future." Thus, he adds: "To interpret the signs of the times in the light of faith means to recognize the presence of Christ in every age. In the private revelations approved by the Church – and therefore also in Fatima – this is the point: they help us to understand the signs of the times and to respond to them rightly in faith." Earlier in the same section on private revelations, the future Pope, quoting the Catechism, had put it in this way: "’It is not their role to complete Christ’s definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history’ (No. 67)."

This reference to the "definitive Revelation" is a reminder of something the Pope had earlier said in this same section. He had mentioned a section of the Catechism which quoted a famous text of St. John of the Cross in which St. John states that God, "In giving us his Son … has no more to say" (No. 65). At first glance this might seem to exclude any such thing as private revelation, but he notes that the very next question adds this qualification: "…even if Revelation is already complete, it has not been made fully explicit; it remains for Christian faith gradually to grasp its full significance over the centuries" (No. 66). It is for this reason that the future Pope also quotes in his comment the passage of St. John’s Gospel on the Holy Spirit, where Christ says: "I have yet many things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now. When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth …. for he will take what is mine and declare it to you’ (Jn 16:12-14)."

Someone might be alarmed that the Pope’s stress on private revelations might open the doors to a mob of over-excited visionaries. However, the need for discernment by the Magisterium has traditionally been recognized in the Church throughout her history, and this is discussed in the document Lumen Gentium (On the Church) under the topic of charisms (N. 12). There it states the general principle that "the manifestation of the Spirit is given to everyone for profit" (1 Cor 12:7). But it goes on to state more precisely: "Whether these charisms be very remarkable or more simple…. Those who have charge over the Church should judge the genuineness and proper use of these gifts through their office not indeed to extinguish the Spirit, but to test all things and hold fast to what is good (cf. Th 5:12 and 19-21)." Moreover, for all those who are tempted to a "sola scriptura" view of Revelation, the Catechism reminds us that, "It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be include in the list of the sacred books" (No. 120).

Thus, the teaching of the Church on the importance of private revelations is really clear, but academic theology really seems quite unwilling to write serious articles that attempt to examine carefully the riches that God continues to bestow on his Church in this way. This lack of coherence with the Church’s teaching on the role of Tradition and private revelations can hardly be of benefit to theological thinking nor to the life of the Church. It is a deliberate choice, as it were, to see without one eye. It effectively ignores all we have seen above.

A glance at typical theological journals will reveal a truly amazing wealth of topics that are considered in the light of theology, but themes from private revelation are almost always ignored in such scholarly publications. Thus, at Fatima, Our Lady requested the consecration of Russia to her Immaculate Heart. She later asked Sister Lucy to promote specific practices connected with the six first Saturdays of the month. St. Margaret Mary Alacoque promoted practices connected with the nine first Fridays of the month and devotion to the Sacred Heart. We could go on to speak of other saints, revelations, and devotions that are too many to mention here. These topics, however, and others of this nature, are clearly not considered to be worthy of serious theological study if one judges by the topics treated in typical theological reviews. This is truly remarkable when one looks at some of the topics that are taken up and which at times can be quite far removed from the everyday life of the Church. Such an approach in such a universal and systematic way indicates a kind of practical chasm between the Church’s teaching on the value of Tradition and the value given to it in contemporary theological thinking. And this neglect has an important negative impact on the thinking of priests and many members of the laity as well. Not only do they remain ignorant of private revelations, they are inclined by this bad example to see them as of little importance in the life of the Church. Sadly this bad example is given by theologians who are often priests.

The example of the Popes of our century, however, shows that these devotions are seen by them as something beneficial to the salvation of souls, which is the mission of the Church. It is worth noting that even recently approved devotions, which are certainly rich fields for totally new theological investigation, such as the "Lady of All Nations," are also normally ignored in what would be called scholarly journals. In the light of the Church’s teaching about Tradition since apostolic times, one must certainly ask why this is true. It is not my wish to try and guess what the causes are for this anomaly. What I would like to do, however, is encourage serious theologians to do their work in a way that removes this chasm between the teaching of the Church on the importance of Tradition and the praxis of theologians in neglecting to study and comment on living Tradition as part of their role of serving today’s Church. To the readers of theology, I can only plead with them not be be put off by this strange aversion for private revelations. This area of private revelations is a fruitful area of study and offers benefits to anyone who is truly interested in knowing more about the ways of our saving Lord. As it is put so well in God’s holy word: "For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways, says the Lord. As high as the heavens are above the earth, so high are my ways about your ways and my thought above your thoughts" (Is 55:8-9). This is still true today.