By Fr. James Fannan, PIME
One of the classical virtues that is, I believe, a bit ignored in our own times is the virtue of simplicity. In fact, I would wonder in our own times how many people really know what the virtue of simplicity is. It would be worthwhile, therefore, to begin by clarifying the meaning of this virtue. The basic dictionary meaning of simplicity is “not complicated or elaborate.” I begin with this basic definition because in any discussion it is important to make clear what our terms mean if we want to avoid a kind of Babel in our conversations. I remember one of my teachers in philosophy saying something to the effect that most philosophers haven’t had a real disagreement in recent years because they really don’t understand each other. It was perhaps an exaggeration, but it brings out the point that is worth stressing here: it is important to have clear terminology if we want to have a real understanding and exchange of ideas.
Classic Christian philosophy at its heights, therefore, would always begin the discussion of a topic or thesis with the explanation of the various meaning of any important words that were used. This was precisely to avoid the danger of failing to have a real exchange of ideas. To use a simple example from our own times, when speaking in the context of “existentialism,” the word “exist” was given a new meaning that stressed the dynamic aspect of human freedom and its consequences.
However, if we were to use “exist” in this way in our ordinary conversation or in a letter to the editor or virtually anywhere outside the philosophy classroom, no one would understand it. For the rest of humanity, the meaning of “exist” is found as in the phrase. “Why do dinosaurs no longer exist?” Thus, if we want to share the insights of some existentialist author with others, it is more understandableoutside of the classroom to simply use the normal everyday words that can be understood by all.
Therefore, at this point, it would be a good idea to turn immediately to what is more precisely meant by the subject I want to address: simplicity in a Christian context (beyond the simple dictionary definition of the word). Here is a good, clear definition of the virtue from Fr. John Hardon’sModern Catholic Dictionary: “As a character trait, the quality of not being affected; therefore, unassuming and unpretentious. A simple person is honest, sincere, and straightforward. Simplicity is single-mindedness. As supernatural virtue, it seeks only to do the will of God without regard to self-sacrifice or self-advantage.” The first part of this definition is extremely useful as a guideline. Jesus condemned a certain mentality that is also a danger for priests or anyone in a position of leadership. He said, “You know that the rulers of the Gentles lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them” (Matt 20:25). Against such an attitude, he called on his apostles to imitate himself as one who came to serve rather than to be served. This passage is striking inits reference to the “Gentiles” (pagans). Jesus didn’t speak very often about the pagans, but it is interesting that he chose their leaders when he took up the topic of arrogant rulers. Since we live in non-Christian environment, it is important to be particularly aware of this danger of “lording it over” other people. A proud person often shows it by the way he talks and acts and can make himself look ridiculous. This pompous attitude is scorned in traditionally Christian countries so that even the truly proud try to hide this weakness for fear of being regarded as buffoons. As we know, however, in non-Christian culture there is less awareness of this vice and so there can be bad feelings that arise because someone thinks that he was not sufficiently honored at some function, and this is always something that has to be taken into account by the organizers, and there are many other examples of such situations. Hence, we, as the standard bearers of the Gospel, have to be doubly aware of this and avoid such superior attitudes in dealing with others so that we do not become a scandal that brings shame to the cross.
The definition we have seen of the virtue of simplicity also refers to being “unpretentious,” in other words, not trying to make ourselves seem special. In the modern world, there are those who want to stand out by a fancy car, an expensive wristwatch, a cell phone, etc. In the small world of seminary life, where these things might be unreachable, it can be in little things like wanting to dress in a stylish way, taking a somewhat Bollywood style as a model when we go for an outing somewhere. If left unchecked, this attitude can lead to really scandalous behavior when those around us see how attached we are to status symbols and how ready we are to waste money and ignore the urgent needs of others, particularly the poor.
The definition of simplicity from the Modern Catholic Dictionary is fleshed out by one of the classic experts in spiritual matters, St. Francis de Sales: “When a simple soul is to act, it considers only what it is suitable to do or to say, without losing time in thinking what others will do or say about it. And after doing what seemed right, it dismisses the subject; or if, perhaps, any thought of what others may say or do should arise, it instantly cuts short such reflections, for it has no other aim than to please God, and not creatures, except as the love of God requires it. Therefore, it cannot bear to be turned aside from its purpose of keeping close to God …”
Here he brings out the key underlying attitude of those who practice simplicity: it is an attitude in which one has “no other aim than to please God, and not creatures, except as love of God requires it. Therefore, it cannot bear to be turned aside from its purpose of keeping close to God . . .” In other words, the virtue underlying simplicity is none other than the great commandment of loving God with our whole heart, whole mind, and whole strength and loving our fellow human beings as well.
The second part of the definition we are using also refers to this notion of St. Francis de Sales in these words: “A simple person is honest, sincere, and straightforward. Simplicity is single-mindedness.” Looking at simplicity’s opposite, which is astuteness, St. Francis has harsh words:“astuteness is nothing but a mass of artifices, inventions, crafts, and deceit, by which we endeavor to mislead the minds of those with whom we are dealing, and make them believe that we have no knowledge or sentiment as to the matter in question, except what we manifest by our words.”
There is an expression “the inscrutable Orient” which reflects the fact that the non-Christian world can be quite expert in the art of concealing rather than saying what is really on one’s mind. It is at times bewildering for someone from West, and this is a problem that comes up often in the global world of business. The investor asks himself, “but does this person really mean what he is saying, is he sincere?” On the national level, this problem emerges in corruption in which the truth of the situation is concealed by beautiful words that attempt to hide reality from the voters and journalists. Perhaps this deception goes back to the idea of always saying “yes” to authority figures even in childhood in order to win their approval. To simply say “yes” all the time can lead to situations in which we fail to do as we have said and end up trying to cover it all ups with lies and excuses. To be sincere requires thinking before we say yes to anything.
The stress that St. Francis de Sales puts on truthfulness recalls a very simple statement made by St. Teresa of Avila: humility is truth. She was stressing that the truly humble person is simply recognizing the way things truly are. But it is also true that if we are humble, we will be aided in growing in the virtue of simplicity because the most common problem with exercising this virtue is lying. St. Francis speaks of astuteness, which is the vice that we fall into if we rely more and more on lies to achieve what is really our own self-interest. If someone wants to become truly simple, avoiding lies is clearly essential and a basic step in this spiritual battle.
We can thus see how the virtue of simplicity and humility are essentially related, and Pope Francis himself has stressed this same truth in connection with the life of religious. He brought up this topic in a talk to the International Union of Superiors General (on May 8, 2013). He touched on the fundamental attitudes we need as religious to accomplish our mission in the world. He said, for example, “for man, authority is often synonymous with possession, dominion, success. For God, authority is always synonymous with service, humility, love. It means to enter into Jesus’ logic, who bends down to wash the feet of the Apostles.” Here we see the fundamental “death to selfishness” attitude that is required to live the Gospel and to be able to practice the virtue of simplicity. Essentially we must renounce the selfishness that leads us to cover up the truth for our own self-serving ends. In the same talk, Pope Francis put it this way: as religious you must “continually engage in an ‘exodus’ from yourselves to center your existence on Christ and on his Gospel, on the will of God, divesting yourselves of your plans, to be able to say with Saint Paul: ‘It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me’ (Gal 2:20).” The Pope adds that, “This ‘exodus’ from oneself is to put oneself on a path of adoration and service. An exodus that leads us to a path of adoration of the Lord and service to Him in our brothers and sisters. To adore and to serve: two attitudes that cannot be separated, but which must always to together. To adore the Lord and to serve others, not holding anything for oneself: this is the ‘divestment’ of one who exercises authority.” These words of Pope Francis bring us back to the definition Fr. Hardon gives of the virtue of simplicity at the beginning of this article: “A simple person is honest, sincere, and straightforward. Simplicity is single-mindedness. As a supernatural virtue it seeks only to the will of God without regard to self-sacrifice or self-advantage.”
The kind of humility which is needed to be truthful and simple is also a subject touched on by Pope Francis in the same conference in which he speaks of this “exodus” that puts us on the path of adoration and service. He relates it to the virtue of poverty. He sees poverty as “the overcoming of all egoism in the logic of the Gospel.” It is learned “with the humble, the poor, the sick and all those who are on the existential peripheries of life. Theoretical poverty is of no use to us. Poverty is learned by touching the flesh of the poor Christ, in the humble, the poor, the sick, in children.”
This kind of attitude is light years away from the vice of astuteness that St. Francis De Sales condemned. The Pope too exclaimed in his conference: “We think of the harm inflicted on the People of God by men and women of the Church who are careerists, social climbers, who ‘use’ the people, the Church, brothers and sisters – those they should serve – as trampolines for their own personal interests and ambitions. But these to great harm to the Church.”
These striking comments of the Pope to a conference of religious superiors open up another aspect of simplicity. It touches on a topic that we find in modern psychology, though it is as old as human nature: the manipulative person. This may not immediately involve telling lies, but it is a manifestation of astuteness that has selfish aims as its guiding principle. The manipulative person knows how to play on other people’s personalities to achieve selfish ends. At times this may involve promoting oneself – these are the people the Pope refers to as “careerists, social climbers, who ‘use’ the people … as trampolines for their own personal interests and ambitions.” At other times it may involve negative comments about others and assuming an attitude of superiority. Clearly, manipulative people are those whom classical spirituality referred to as “astute.”
It is good to remember that Pope Francis has a vast experience, both as an archbishop and religious superior, in dealing with all kinds of abuses of the power of speech. In fact, he seems to have a real concern for the virtue of simplicity. This was brought out in a brief sermon in St. Marta’s church in the Vatican. On June 4, 2013, he returned to this area of spirituality in his reflections on the Pharisees who tried to trap Jesus on the topic of paying taxes to the Roman emperor. Their whole attitude was one of concealing their true intentions in their apparently respectful approach. Pope Francis gets down to the root of their astute behavior by saying that though they come “with soft words, with beautiful words, with overly sweet words … they do not love the truth.” In fact, he says, they love only themselves “and so they try to deceive … They have a lying heart, they cannot tell the truth.”
The Pope lays bare the roots of such manipulative behavior – and of course his concern is about this behavior in the contemporary Church itself. He states that the root of such behavior is hypocrisy, which, of course, is a way of speaking and acting that is designed to hide the truth and therefore can be labeled “astuteness.”. He states that, “hypocrisy is the very language of corruption … hypocrisy is not the language of truth … there is no truth without love. Love is the first truth. If there is no love, there is no truth.” Here we clearly see that for the virtue of simplicity to exist, it has to find its origin in love. We saw in our definition that simplicity “As a supernatural virtue seeks only to do the will of God without regard to self-sacrifice or self-advantage.” In short, it is based on the great commandment of total love of God. It is from this fundamental attitude that the other characteristics derive: “the quality of being unaffected; therefore unassuming and unpretentious … honest, sincere, and straightforward.”
St. Thomas says that the human heart is made for love, as the famous quote of St. Augustine stated: “You have made us for yourself, Oh Lord, and our hearts are restless until they rest in you.” However, as St. Thomas points out, when our hearts are restless, they find some other love as long as they fail to surrender to the only true love, which is God himself. In the light of this, we can better understand the words of Pope Francis in this same homily: “If there is no love, there is no truth. They want a truth enslaved to their interests. There is a love, of sorts: it is love of self, love for oneself.” He calls this attitude a “narcissist idolatry that leads them to betray others, that leads them to abuse of trust.”
People who are slaves of this narcissist attitude who are “careerists” and “social climbers” inevitably act in a habitually hypocritical way, pretending friendship and concern when in fact they are just seeking their own selfish interests. Such people are quite good at paying compliments at the right time and to the right person, e.g., “that was a wonderful talk, a beautiful Mass” etc., in the hopes of gaining some advantage or approval. On the other hand, negative comments are readily made to belittle anyone who is perceived as a rival or even simply to be of no importance. The Pope instead tells us to learn how to overcome all egoism in a spirit of poverty that is learned by contact with the “humble, the poor, the sick” and children. Of course, the success of hypocrisy is connected with what the Pope refers to as a “certain inner weakness” that is stimulated by “vanity” because most of us “like people to say good things about us.” He adds that since the corrupt know this weakness, they try to use it to their own advantage.
Pope Francis also stated some of his own guidelines in this area by asking, “What is our language? Do we speak the truth with love, or do we speak with that social language to be polite, even say nice things, which we do not feel? Let our language be evangelical, brothers and sisters … Let us ask the Lord today that our language be the language of the simple, the language of a child, the language of the children of God, the language of truth in love.”
There is another outstanding author in spiritual theology who was a saint and was very much in love with the virtue of simplicity: St. Vincent De Paul. He wrote: “It is my gospel,” and he went on to add: “Among those who make profession of following the maxims of Christ, simplicity ought to be held in great esteem; for, among the wise of this world, there is nothing more contemptible or despicable than this. Yet it is a virtue most worthy of love, because it leads us straight to the Kingdom of God, and, at the same time, wins for us the affection of men; since one who is regarded as upright, sincere, and an enemy to tricks and fraud, is loved by all, even by those who only seek from morning till night to cheat and deceive others.” We have an example of this admiration of what is truly good in the life of Blessed Mother Teresa who was loved even by those who would never dream of imitating her.
However, St. Vincent was a wise and perceptive thinker, so he added some necessary aspects to a fuller understanding of the true virtue: “Jesus, the Lord, expects us to have the simplicity of a dove. This means giving a straightforward opinion about things in the way we honestly see them, without needless reservations. It also means doing things without any double-dealing or manipulation, our intention being focused solely on God. Each of us, then, should take care to behave always in this spirit of simplicity, remembering that God likes to deal with the simple and that he conceals the secrets of heaven from the wise and prudent of this world and reveals them to little ones. But while Christ recommends the simplicity of dove, he tells us to have the prudence of a serpent as well. What he means is that we should speak and behave with discretion. We ought, therefore, to keep quiet about matters which should not be made known, especially if they are unsuitable or unlawful… In actual practice this virtue is about choosing the right way to do things.” Here again we see the supremacy of love, which Pope Francis stresses in his reflections on truthfulness.
Choosing the right way of acting in love, implies yet another virtue, which is called prudence by St. Vincent. This virtue is also described by Fr. Hardon in the phrase:Prudence is “Correct knowledge about things to be done or, more broadly, the knowledge of things that ought to be done and of things that ought to be avoided.” He adds the idea that, “It is the intellectual virtue whereby a human being recognizes in any matter at hand what is good and what is evil.” In fact, if we mistake the evil for the good, we are not exercising prudence—we are showing our lack of it.
Jesus himself indicated an example in which prudence should also govern, for example, our simplicity when he said: “Do not give dogs what is sacred; do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, they may trample them under their feet, and then turn and tear you to pieces” (Matt 7:6). In his earthly ministry, Jesus only went “up to Jerusalem” to confront the scribes and Pharisees when his “hour had come.” Earlier, most of the time he prudently kept his distance, not out of fear, but because he had a mission to accomplish before his death. We too need such prudence in dealing with the various situations which arise every day in other types of situations. It is love that reconciles prudence and truthfulness as found in the virtue of simplicity. The Bible, especially the Old Testament, speaks of this fusion of prudence and love as “Wisdom,” which is a gift of the Holy Spirit.
Wisdom, then, is needed whenever we try to put the Gospel into practice, but for a Christian, this is never just a human calculation, it is a supernatural gift of God that must be sought in prayer and exercised with love. We have to be aware that the Holy Spirit wants to guide us in our words and deeds, or as St. Francis of Assisi said, “make me a channel of your peace.” That is, make me an instrument that depends on God himself in its action. Thus, the correct way of practicing simplicity and all other virtues is to act prudently following the inspiration of the Spirit who shows us in every circumstance how to put into practice God’s law of love. This openness to the Spirit is not something that comes with little effort. As we have seen in the Pope’s remarks, the supreme rule is love and that requires our ‘exodus’ from selfishness. This is not achieved easily. Indeed it is a lifetime task that, however, requires us to take the first steps if we wish to go further. Nothing can be achieved without insistent prayer and a consistent effort to avoid the most obvious failings, such as lying, but every victory, however small, is another step toward true discipleship which shows itself in the virtue of simplicity.
Bibliography:
http://www.catholictradition.org/Classics/simplicity-confidence.htm
http://w2.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/cotidie/2013/index.html