By Fr. James Fannan, PIME
In the early days of the Easter season, the readings at Mass focus on the apparitions of Jesus after his resurrection, and an attentive listener might ask himself, “But just what happened exactly in those first hours after the resurrection of Jesus?” Just as the jury during a trial has to make use of the eyewitness testimony of various people to establish as far as possible the flow of events that took place in the past, we have a similar task to answer the question of what happened on Easter morning. Unfortunately, the witnesses are no longer here to interrogate, so we have to do the best we can with their accounts as we find them in the gospels. The first thing, perhaps, that stands out in these testimonies is the insistence that Mary Magdalene was the first to reach the empty tomb and the first to inform the Apostles, Peter and John, of the empty tomb: “On the first day of the week, Mary of Magdalene came to the tomb early in the morning while it was still dark, and saw the stone removed from the tomb. So she ran and went to Simon Peter and to the other disciple” (Jn 20:1-2). After running to the empty tomb and investigating the situation, we read that, “Then the disciples returned home” (Jn 20:10).
The First Apparition
Although the disciples then leave, Mary alone remains behind. It is only then that two angels appear inside the tomb which had already been examined by Peter and John. She is so upset that she is not aware of the fact that they are angels or puzzled by their sudden appearance in the tomb (Jn 2O:13). It is only then that she sees Jesus, who she thinks is a gardener, and then she recognizes him only at his word “Mary” (Jn 20:16). After telling her not to cling to him, Jesus gives her the mission of proclaiming his resurrection to the disciples. It is then that she obeys and returns again to the Apostles, this time to proclaim the resurrection as an eyewitness of the risen Lord (Jn 20:17-18). The fact that Mary Magdalene was the first to see Jesus is confirmed by the Gospel of Mark: “he appeared first to Mary Magdalene … she went and told his companions …. they did not believe” (Mk 16:9) This confirmation is particularly noteworthy because in the same chapter of St. Mark, one would have just read, “When the Sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, Mary, the Mother of James, and Salome brought spices so that they might go and anoint him. Very early when the sun had risen, on the first day of the week, they came to the tomb” (Mk 16: 1-2). Here we see Mary Magdalene accompanied by two other women, an idea that seems to be corrected in verse 9 of the same chapter. In fact, although the verses 9-20 of this chapter are canonical, they seem to be a later addition to the original gospel, and, at least in this detail, there is the clarification of an important point in verse 9 which St. John also had insisted on, namely, that Mary Magdalene is the first to arrive. Based on its style and language, modern scholars see this section as an addition to the original text of Mark, but this text of Mark thus has the important role of confirming and even stressing what we also find in John.
The Earthquake
How to explain then the fact that Mary Magdalene seems to have begun her journey with two other women and then ended up alone when she reached the tomb? Probably the answer lies in Matthew’s account. In all of these accounts, however, it is necessary to note that, like the gospels in general, they are summaries and not really careful attempts at exact chronologies as we would desire today in a news report. In any event, Matthew’s account states: “After the Sabbath, as the first day of the week was dawning, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb. And behold, there was a great earthquake; for an angel of the Lord descended from heaven, approached, rolled back the stone and sat upon it” (Mt 28: 1-2). The mention of a great earthquake here might not be very alarming to someone who is calmly reading the account, but it would have been very frightening to the people of Jerusalem who were actually experiencing it.
Most people have never experienced an earthquake, and even if they have, an earthquake is never seen as unimportant. In fact, this earthquake is described as a “great earthquake.” The earthquake on Good Friday had also been quite severe and terrifying in its consequences as we read in the same gospel at the moment of the death of Jesus (Mt 27:51-53). Thus, it is reasonable to think that although Mary Magdalene set out for the tomb with the other women Mark mentions, the others would most probably have been frightened by the earthquake and anxious to return to inquire into the situation of those they had left behind, leaving the visit to the tomb for later. Thus, their visit to the tomb was delayed by the earthquake, which would account for the expression “when the sun had risen” in describing their journey by St. Mark (Mk 16:2) as compared to “while it as still dark” in John’s gospel in relation to Mary Magdalene (Jn 20:1). Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that Mary Magdalene apparently continued on alone after the earthquake, being concerned with only one thing: finding Jesus. This would seem to be an explanation that makes sense regarding this discrepancy between the departure as a group and the arrival of Mary Magdalene by herself at the tomb, and it reminds us of her single-minded attitude of listening at the feet of Jesus while Martha attended to the household duties. Thus, while Mary Magdalene had proceeded alone, the others set off again after some delay, and it was no longer dark and when they reached the tomb, but by then Mary Magdalene had already gone running to inform the Apostles of the empty tomb.
This earthquake event, then, explains that in summarizing what took place; Mark simply goes on to recount the apparition to a group of woman who finally do arrive at the tomb but some time later. Both Mark and Matthew had mentioned Mary, the mother of younger James and of Joses (Joseph) as well as Salome as being present at the crucifixion. Here, the women appear again, as we have seen, as earlier companions of Mary Magdalene when they set out on Easter morning in resurrection account, Salome being the mother of James and John, the sons of Zebedee (Mt. 27:56 and Mark 15:40) who were two of the first Apostles of Jesus.
The Other Women
Luke, instead, disregards any precise chronology and simply summarizes the post resurrection appearances briefly, but he does remind us of the underlying complexity of the situation by adding that there were other women besides the three we have so far seen mentioned. He describes the whole group of witnesses in this way: “Mary Magdalene, Johanna, and Mary the mother of James; the others who accompanied them also told this to the apostles” (Lk 24:10). Thus, even though John and the Gospel of Mark make it quite clear that Mary Magdalene was alone when she reached the tomb, Mark had spoken only of two other women as being with Mary Magdalene when they set out: Salome and Mary, the mother of James the younger (Mk 15:40). Luke instead makes it clear there were other witnesses as well.
With the comments of Luke, however, we can see that what happened was really more complex than it seems in Mark and John. Luke mentions Joanna casually here, but he had already mentioned her as being one of the female disciples of Jesus: “Accompanying him were the Twelve and some women who had been cured of evils spirits and infirmities, Mary called Magdalene, from whom seven demons had gone out, Joanna, the wife of Herod’s steward Chuza, Susanna, and many other who provided tor them out of their resources” (Lk 8:3).Thus, it is reasonable to suppose that in addition to the women mentioned by John and Mark, there were other women who set out that day after the earthquake to visit the tomb since at least some of them had also remained present at the crucifixion because we read that “all his acquaintances stood at a distance, including the women who had followed him from Galilee” (Lk 23:49). Moreover, we see that these women also went all the way to the burial (Lk 23:55). Thus, since there is no reason to believe that they were all staying in the same house in Jerusalem, they would have been starting off at various times and taking various routes to visit the tomb; in fact, there is evidence in the gospels that indeed there were also others who also had resurrection apparitions. This, as we have seen, is confirmed by the summary of Luke who puts all the women together in his account as reporting to the Apostles without going into the details that we have already seen: “While they were puzzling over this, behold, two men in dazzling garments appeared to them. They were terrified and bowed their faces to the ground. They said to them, ‘Why do you seek the living one among the dead? He is not here but he has been raised’ … the women were Mary Magdalene, Johanna and Mary the mother of James; the others who accompanied them also told this to the apostles” (Lk 24:4-10).
Matthew gives a clue to a second apparition (besides the one to Mary Magdalene) by describing the presence of the guards who had become “like dead men”; thus, they were still present when that group of women finally arrived (while Magdalene had already left to go and get the Apostles). In Matthew’s account, these women see an angel who tells them “Do not be afraid! … go quickly and tell the disciples … and behold Jesus met them on their way and greeted them. They approached, embraced his feet, and did him homage. Then Jesus said to them, ‘Do not be afraid. Go, tell my brothers to go the Galilee, and there they will see me’” (Mt 28: 5-10). The fact that this group does not meet Mary Magdalene at all would be due to the fact that tombs were generally near the city, and Jesus was crucified in a place where those who were passing could read the inscription on the cross, so the tomb would have been near a gate of the city as well, which would lead to a maze of streets in Jerusalem (Jn 19:20). Besides this, Mary had gone specifically to the upper room to find Peter and John, but the women, as we have seen, would have been guests at various places due to their sojourn in Jerusalem for the festival of Passover. Hence, Mary Magdalene and the Apostles could return to the tomb by another route without actually meeting the group of women who had just been there.
The Third Group
Finally, there is clear evidence for yet a third group of women, for St. Mark speaks of some of the women who arrive apparently after the guards have already fled: “On entering the tomb, they saw a young man sitting on the right side … You seek Jesus of Nazareth … go and tell his disciples and Peter, ‘He is going before you to Galilee; there you will see him, as he told you.’ Then they went out and fled from the tomb, seized with trembling and bewilderment. They said nothing to anyone for they were afraid’ (Mk 16: 5-8). Although at the moment they said nothing, clearly when they learned that their vision was confirmed by the other women as true, they shared their unbelievable news with the rest of the community. This harmonizes with the fact that when Peter and John had arrived, the guards had already fled, unlike the second apparition that took place just after Mary Magdalene had left to find the Apostles. In this case, only after having returned with Peter and John, Mary Magdalene would have then seen the two angels in the tomb as she lingered after the Apostles’ departure since for her there was no other place to go. It was then that she saw Jesus in the garden and then rushed off to add her testimony to that of the other women who themselves likewise had encountered Jesus as they were returning to the city (Mt 28:10).
Thus, it would seem that besides Mary Magdalene, there were at least two other groups that went to the tomb that morning. This would harmonize well with the account we have of the crucifixion where St. Mark states, “There were also woman looking on from a distance. Among them were Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of the younger James and of Joses, and Salome. These women had followed him when he was in Galilee and ministered to him. There were also many other women who had come up with him to Jerusalem” (Mk 15:40-41). Given this situation, it is hardly amazing that there were several separate apparitions of Jesus, also due to the complication of the unsettling earthquake.
Nowadays, we do not find it puzzling that Jesus could appear at various places, defying the usual laws of nature – but no doubt for the Apostles, his appearance in various places would have raised doubts about his resurrection since it seems that he appeared to Mary Magdalene first, just outside the tomb and then next somewhere along the road leading back to the city to the group of women who had already left before Mary Magdalene had returned with Peter and John after the resurrection.
Thus, there were at least three separate visits of women to the tomb. First, there is Mary Magdalene who then goes to get the Apostles; she is followed rather closely by another group, who still see the unconscious guards and later would see Jesus himself as they are returning to the city. However, after their departure from the tomb, Mary Magdalene and the Apostles arrived at the tomb by another route. Thus, when the Apostles have left, Mary Magdalene was the first of the women to see Jesus just outside the tomb before he then appeared to the group of women still on the way back from the tomb. Finally, there is a group that sees the angel but are afraid at first to tell anyone at all until they hear that the other women have seen the same thing. All of this raises a question that the gospels do not answer. Why did Jesus not appear to the Apostles first? Or why did God not, at least, send them an angel? Clearly there is plenty of room for speculation. One other thing is clear, however: the first proclamation of the central gospel message – Jesus is risen from the dead – was entrusted to women rather than to the very Apostles chosen by Jesus. All of this leaves us with much food for thought beyond the scope of this brief article.
The Virgin Mary’s Sister and her Children
From the information we have in the Gospels, it seems to me that this is about as exact a picture as we can get as regards the chronology of events. However, due to the summary style of the synoptic writers, it is really impossible to be sure of the identity of all the women who were present at the two subsequent apparitions that seem to be indicated by the sacred writers. However, there is another point of interest about these first witnesses: anyone reading these passages would be struck by the sudden prominence given to Mary, the mother of the younger James (Mk 15:40). She obviously was a person of particular interest to the early Christian community. She is also described as the “other Mary” (Mt 27:61 and 28:1) and the Virgin Mary’s “sister” [i.e. sister-in-law] (Jn 19:25). Her prominence, here then is no doubt due to the fact that she is the mother of the Apostle James “the brother of the Lord” (Gal 1:19) who was the first bishop left in charge of Jerusalem while the others were designated for their world-wide mission. The Jews, in fact, called cousins “brothers,” and although the Greeks did have a term for cousin, the early Christian community in Judea would of course have followed the Jewish usage. In fact, even the Greek translation of the Old Testament also used the Greek word for brothers in translating from Hebrew rather than substituting it with the Greek word for cousin.
The fact that the mother of James is therefore the aunt of Jesus is confirmed by the fact that she is called Mary’s sister (Jn 19:25) at the scene of the cross (or sister-in-law as we would say). She is also called the “other Mary” (Mt 27:61 and 28:1) due to the confusion that could arise among friends when there is the mother of Jesus and a paternal aunt bearing the same name. This relationship to Jesus is confirmed by the fact that she is also the mother of a brother of James named Joseph (Mt 27:56). Of the four “brothers” that are mentioned as “brothers” of Jesus [James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas] (cf. Mt 13:55), in fact we see two “brothers” named here, and the third is none other than the Apostle Jude. This is why he is called in the Gospel “Jude of James” (which is sometimes wrongly translated as son of James). It is also why James is also called “the younger James” (Mk 15:40) to distinguish him from the older Apostle James (the son of Zebedee) in the group of the Apostles. In fact, in his letter, St. Jude specifically says that he is the brother of James in the introduction (Jude 1:1), and the only way such an identification would be meaningful would be in reference to someone as prominent as the Apostle James who was headquartered in Jerusalem. It is precisely because of this pivotal role in Jerusalem that James writes to the Jews in dispersion as somehow entrusted to his care.
All of this is confirmed by the list of the Apostles in which Jude (as Thaddeus) is sometimes named immediately after James due to their kinship (Mt 10:3 and Mk 3:18)). St. James’ own introduction to his epistle points to his special connection to Jesus because he substitutes the words “slave” (Jas 1:1) for the usual title of “brother of the Lord” by which he was known in the Christian community. In fact, Jude imitates James in likewise avoiding the usual title “brother” and preferring the word “slave of Jesus Christ.”Thus, the resurrection apparitions, besides confirming the resurrection of Jesus, also are the occasion of understanding better the identity of the Apostles James and Jude as cousins of Jesus. Here it should be mentioned that at times Mary, the mother of the younger James, is also referred to as “Mary of Clopas.” This, at times, is interpreted as “wife” of Clopas, but it can also be interpreted as “daughter” of Clopas and thus in no way does it contradict her maternal relationship to the Apostle James since he is the son of Alphaeus (who would be the brother of St. Joseph). As we have seen, in the list of the Apostles “Jude of James” is also sometimes interpreted as “son of James,” though, as we have already explained, there is no reason to suppose that he is fact anything other than the brother of James, or the brother of “the younger James.” Thus, with a little bit of detective work we can unravel not only the events of Easter morning but also provide a little bit of the family background of Jesus and Mary that the gospels never bother to specifically detail. In those days, the oral tradition in the Jewish Christian community would have made it unnecessary to go into such details which often leave modern readers puzzled, which of course indicates the value of tradition for finding the exact meaning of the scriptures.
“In fact, the second-century writer Hegesippus
Eusebius quotes Hegesippus "James, the brother of the Lord, succeeded to the government of the Church in conjunction with the apostles. He has been called the Just by all from the time of our Saviour to the present day; for there were many that bore the name of James...After the martyrdom of James and the conquest of Jerusalem which immediately followed, it is said that those of the apostles and disciples of the Lord that were still living came together from all directions with those that were related to the Lord according to the flesh (for the majority of them also were still alive) to take counsel as to who was worthy to succeed James. They all with one consent pronounced Symeon, the son of Clopas, of whom the Gospel also makes mention; to be worthy of the episcopal throne of that parish. He was a cousin, as they say, of the Saviour. For Hegesippus records that Clopas was a brother of Joseph."
It was Mentioned to that Clopas could be the father of Mary
Papias (c. 70-155) explicitly says “James and Judas and Joseph were sons of an aunt of the Lord's.”
Eusebius also gives witness, saying, "There are extant five books of Papias, which bear the title Expositions of Oracles of the Lord." (The Church History of Eusebius, Book III, cap. 39, 1)
Fragments of Papias from the Exposition of the Oracles of the Lord
Description:
This fragmentary work consists of abbreviated interpretations of Holy Scripture,
and also some additional information that Papias received from the Presbyters,
including an explanation of how Mark recorded Peter's eyewitness account.
Provenance:
St. Papias wrote this work near the end of his life, combining his commentary on
the Old and New Testament (called "logia", or "oracles") with oral traditions
that he had collected from the Presbyters themselves or that he had received
secondhand from disciples of the Presbyters. The Presbyters told Papias what the
Apostles (Peter, Andrew, etc.) had taught. Papias acknowledges in the
introduction to his work that he himself did not receive direct information from
the Apostles, but from the Presbyters who knew them. This work originally
consisted of five books, though all but a few fragments have been lost. Irenaeus
asserts the following: "Now testimony is borne to these things in writing by
Papias, an ancient man, who was a hearer of John, and a friend of Polycarp, in
the fourth of his books; for five books were composed by him."
by Papias of Hierapolis in Between 115 and 140 A.D. | translated by Anonymous
The presbyters, the disciples of the apostles,
X.
(1.) Mary the mother of the Lord; (2.) Mary the wife of Cleophas or Alphaeus, who was the mother of James the bishop and apostle, and of Simon and Thaddeus, and of one Joseph; (3.) Mary Salome, wife of Zebedee, mother of John the evangelist and James; (4.) Mary Magdalene. These four are found in the Gospel. James and Judas and Joseph were sons of an aunt of the Lord's. James also and John were sons of another aunt of the Lord's. Mary, mother of James the Less and Joseph, wife of Alphaeus was the sister of Mary the mother of the Lord, whom John names of Cleophas, either from her father or from the family of the clan, or for some other reason. Mary Salome is called Salome either from her husband or her village. Some affirm that she is the same as Mary of Cleophas, because she had two husbands.
Taken from "The Early Church Fathers and Other Works" originally published by Wm. B. Eerdmans Pub. Co. in English in Edinburgh, Scotland beginning in 1867. (ANF 1, Roberts and Donaldson). The digital version is by The Electronic Bible Society, P.O. Box 701356, Dallas, TX 75370, 214-407-WORD.