ARTICLES  Eunuchs for the Kingdom   SUMMARY
(Mt 19: 12)

By Fr. James Fannan, PIME

After shocking his apostles by his radical exclusion of divorce (Mt l9: 3-9), Jesus goes on to make another statement which might shock some readers when he speaks of those who "have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom" (Mt 19:12). It is clear from the context that Jesus is speaking in a symbolic manner, but what exactly is the meaning of the symbolism? The image of such a mutilation is so unpleasant to most modern minds, that it is quite easy to go on to discuss other matters. Indeed, the translation of the New American Bible of 1986 even changed the translation to "they have renounced marriage" and put the literal translation in a footnote.

However, if Jesus chose this image, it is definitely worth our consideration, no matter how unpleasant it might seem at first glance. Jesus was speaking first of all to his contemporaries, and so we have to try and understand it from their point of view. The first clue to a correct understanding regards the best known eunuch in the Bible, at least for the ordinary reader. We read of him in the Acts of the Apostles: "Now there was an Ethiopian eunuch, a court official of the Candace, that is, the queen of the Ethiopians, in charge of her entire treasury, who had come to Jerusalem to worship …."(Acts 8: 27). It is worth noting that he was a court official and of such a status as to be in charge of her entire treasury. This is not as strange as it might appear to many modern readers.

In the Middle East in ancient times, it was not unusual for eunuchs to have important offices in kingdoms, especially in Israel’s neighbors, Egypt and Syria. according to the original Hebrew text, both king Ahab and king Jehoram of Israel are mentioned as having eunuchs in their service (I Kings 22:9 and II Kings 8:6). Again in the original Hebrew, a eunuch is described as being one of the noteworthy captives and a military officer at the time of the fall of Jerusalem (Jer 52:25). It is quite obvious why eunuchs would be entrusted with offices dealing with royal harems, but at first glance it might not be so obvious why they had such offices as being military commanders or treasurers.

It is this clue that leads us to the point that Jesus making when he spoke of "eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom." Jesus was the king and he wanted the total loyalty that the eunuch brings to his lord. In fact, one of the great problems of the ancient world was persons of high status, especially military figures, who finally posed a threat to the king. Likewise there were courtiers who were willing to become involved in conspiracies for their own advancement. The eunuch, on the other hand, was incapable of creating a dynasty by having sons to put in key positions to strengthen his rule. The eunuch’s best hope for the future was his total loyalty to the king to whom he was already bound and on whom he depended totally. According to Josephus, Herod the Great had three eunuchs. One took care of his drink, another brought his food, and a third also managed the principal affairs of the government. This total fidelity is why they were given high positions of trust. Their future depended on the survival and success of their lord.

When the prophet Jeremiah was thrown into the well due to the weakness of King Zedekiah, it was the eunuch Ebed-Melech who had access to the king to inform him of what exactly was happening. He also had the confidence of the king to advise him boldly: "My lord king, these men have been at fault in all they have done to the prophet Jeremiah, casting him into the cistern. He will die of famine on the spot, for there is no more food in the city" (Jer 38:9). It was the same eunuch to whom the king gave the dangerous responsibility of rescuing the hated prophet from his enemies. In the Book of Esther, it was also a eunuch Harbona, one of the king’s attendants, who proposed the execution of Haman by hanging, thus ridding the Jews of their dangerous enemy (Est. 7: 9-10). The eunuchs thus appear in royal courts as men who are totally loyal to the interests of their lord, and this is why, in a spiritual way, Jesus desired the total loyalty involved in the choice of voluntary celibacy for service in his kingdom. In short, he desires an undivided heart.

The most well-known struggle in the Bible for the Jewish throne is, of course, that of David and Saul. Saul realized quickly that David’s military prowess posed a threat to his dynasty, so in a rage he says to his son Jonathon, "Why, as long as the son of Jesse lives upon the earth, you cannot make good your claim to the kingship! So send for him, and bring him to me, for he is doomed" (I Sm 20: 31). A concrete example of this danger is the case of King Elah of the northern kingdom of Israel who is murdered by the military commander Zimri, who then goes on to slaughter the whole extended family so he can reign in his place (I Kgs 16: 8-14).

Similarly, what Jesus was talking about in regard to eunuchs is in fact echoed by St. Paul in another way: "An unmarried man is anxious about the things of the Lord, how he may please the Lord. But a married man is anxious about the things of the world, how he may please his wife, and he is divided" (I Cor 7: 32-34). This same point was brought home to me recently by an article about the ministry of a former Protestant clergyman, Marcus Grodi. His ministry is Coming Home Network International. The purpose is to assist Protestant clergy who in their conscience have come to the difficult point of converting to the Catholic Church. Needless to say, such a decision puts their whole established order at risk: work, prestige, family, friends, colleagues, etc. He states that the most difficult struggle for most Protestant clergy inquirers is with their spouses who do not support their husbands’ willingness to jeopardize their family’s welfare. As I read those lines, I thought to myself about how many other clergymen there might be who know in their conscience that they should join the Catholic Church and yet do even dare discuss it with their wives due to the evident consequences and opposition that such a decision would almost certainly create. They are thus condemned to a lifetime of living a life that runs against their own profound personal convictions. This brings to mind another quote of Jesus which is relevant to the topic: "Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me, and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me …" (Mt. 10:37). Jesus wants total loyalty from his followers, and the "Eunuch for the Kingdom" falls precisely into this category of those who are opting for this total loyalty by renouncing family life.

Celibates may not fulfill all the potentialities which celibacy offers them, but the choice of celibacy does remove an obstacle to an undivided heart which the Scriptures make clear. Celibacy should be seen therefore not as a mysterious sacrifice which the Church requires; rather, it is a kind of down payment, just one of the many sacrifices required to serve the Lord day by day with an undivided heart.