by Fr. James Fannan, PIME
God’s Providence
The life of each person from conception to death is a mystery to every human being, but the Bible reminds us that it is not a mystery to God the Creator. Already in the Old Testament we read in the book of Psalms, "Your eyes have seen my actions; in your book they are all written; my days were limited before one of them existed" (Ps 139:16). The New Testament continues this theological tradition: for example we read in S. Paul, "For we are his handiwork, created in Christ Jesus for the good works that God has prepared in advance that we should live in them" (Eph 2:10). This mysterious collaboration of God and creation was eloquently expressed by Jesus himself: "I am the vine, you are the branches …. Without me you can do nothing" (Jn 15:5).
If the life of ever person is known from all eternity by God, it is hardly surprising that the life of Christ was already revealed in the Bible to prepare humanity to recognize and receive him. This comes out clearly in the reproach that Jesus gave to the famous pair of disciples on their way to Emmaus: "‘Oh, how foolish you are! How slow of heart to believe all that the prophets spoke! Was it not necessary that the Messiah should suffer these things and enter into his glory?’ Then beginning with Moses and all the prophets, he interpreted to them what referred to him in all the scriptures" (Lk 24:25-26). Sadly this reproach leaves us also in the dark as to all the passages to which Jesus was referring. We can get an idea of the kind of obscurer things that Jesus was talking about when we read the quotation in the Gospel of Matthew about the return of Jesus from Egypt: "Out of Egypt I called my son" (Mt 2:15). If this Gospel were not written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, how many today would realize that this quote from Hosea 11:1 had this Christological dimension? No doubt, there would be many other similar examples.
The life of the Church, the bride of Christ, is also described in the scriptures just as the life of Jesus the bridegroom. However, we are faced with a similar problem in ecclesiology as the one we have just seen in Christology when we look to the Bible to understand our journey through history towards the future. The most outstanding example is the "Book of Revelation" which speaks about "what must happen soon" (Rv 1:1). It then presents a panoramic vision of the life of the Church in her journey through history. However, in 2 Peter we are quickly discouraged from making any hasty oversimplification by the words, "But do not ignore this one fact, beloved, that with the Lord one day is like a thousand years and a thousand years like one day. The Lord does not delay his promise, as some regard ‘delay,’ but he is patient with you, not wishing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance" (2 Pt 3:9).
Our Present Crisis
Recent comments by Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI, however, do seem to shed light on one of the mysterious events which the Bible envisioned in the life of the Church. In 2003, in his Apostolic Exhortation Ecclesia in Europa (The Church in Europe), Pope John Paul II spoke of the Church being afflicted by a "silent apostasy" (N. 9). This is an extremely remarkable statement, but in the preceding section (N’s 7-9), the Pope lists the many symptoms that lead him to such a dramatic statement. He speaks of a "practical agnosticism and religious indifference" in Europe. Apostasy (loss of faith) is also indicated in his comments that, "living one’s faith in Jesus becomes increasingly difficult in a social and cultural setting in which that faith is constantly challenged and threatened" (N. 7).
Pope John Paul II eloquently sums up the consequences of this problem in paragraph 9: "At the root of this loss of hope is an attempt to promote a vision of man apart from God and apart from Christ. This sort of thinking has led to man being considered as the absolute center of reality, a view which makes him occupy – falsely – the place of God and which forgets that it is not man who creates God, but rather God who creates man." The Pope continues by stating that it is "no wonder that in this context a vast field has opened for the unrestrained development of nihilism in philosophy, of relativism in values and morality, and of pragmatism – and even a cynical hedonism – in daily life."
Pope Benedict XVI also sees a kind of apostasy in Europe’s a turning away from universal and absolute values which form part of Europe’s Christian tradition. In a discourse to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Treaty of Rome signed on March 25, 1957, the Pope spoke of the situation in Europe as being in a "remarkable form of ‘apostasy’ from itself, even before [apostasy] from God."
The Catechism of the Catholic Church
This use of the word "apostasy" brings to mind the same topic in the new Catechism of the Catholic Church which was promulgated under Pope John Paul II. The topic treating this apostasy follows immediately the discussion of the conversion of the Jews which traditionally is one of the events that is destined to mark the life of the Church as she goes forward in history. Although the conversion of the Jews has quite often been cited as one of the events that will come about in the unfolding of the Church’s history, the apostasy is not. Nevertheless, basing itself on 2 Thessalonians 2:1-8 (as is clear from the footnotes), the Catechism (in number 675) states:
"Before Christ’s second coming the Church must pass through a final trial that will shake the faith of many believers. The persecution that accompanies her pilgrimage on earth will unveil the ‘mystery of iniquity’ in the form of a religious deception offering men an apparent solution to their problems at the price of apostasy from the truth. The supreme religious deception is that of the Antichrist a pseudo-messianism by which man glorifies himself in the placed of God and of his Messiah come in the flesh."
This pseudo-messianism is perhaps best described in the quote we have just seen in Pope John Paul’s Ecclesia in Europa where he says that through the apparent absence of hope in Europe, there is a vast field that has opened up "for the unrestrained development of nihilism in philosophy, of relativism in values and morality, and of pragmatism – even a cynical hedonism – in daily life." However, he also brings out clearly the link between 2 Thessalonians and our present crisis. The passage in Thessalonians speaks of the "lawless one … who opposes and exalts himself above every so-called god and object of worship, so as to seat himself in the temple of God, claiming that he is a god …."(2 Thes 2:3-4). This is a clear reference to atheism, where, by default, a human takes the place of God. The most obvious form is classic atheism such as we find in Marxism, however there are other forms as well. There is, for example, the practical atheism which develops by simply ignoring a God who becomes more and more theoretical to those weak in faith. Then there are the various forms of New Age pantheism in which each individual is somehow recognized as "divine" and any dialogue with God is contemptuously seen as "dualism."
Whatever the reason for replacing God with the merely human, Pope John Paul II clearly describes this atheistic aspect of the situation in the paragraph 9 of Ecclesia in Europa that we have already mentioned: "At the root of this loss of hope is an attempt to promote a vision of man apart from God and apart from Christ. This sort of thinking has led to man being considered as the absolute center of reality, a view which makes him occupy – falsely – the place of God and which forgets that it is not man who creates God, but rather God who creates man." Thus, it is, "no wonder that in this context a vast field has opened for the unrestrained development of nihilism in philosophy, of relativism in values and morality, and of pragmatism – and even a cynical hedonism – in daily life."
Causes of the Current Crisis of Faith
The question arises, how and why has this apostasy come about at this point in time? The complete answer would no doubt require a long analysis, however, some things that Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have said point to some of important aspects of our present day situation. In his book, Crossing the Threshold of Hope, there is an extremely important and synthetic chapter entitled, "What has become of the ‘History of Salvation’?" With his profound background in philosophy, Pope John Paul sees Descartes as an important turning point in the history of human thought. This thinker is commonly seen as the Father of Modern Philosophy. With his well-known statement: "I think, therefore I am," Descartes brings about the "anthropocentric shift" in philosophy wherein the individual becomes the center of philosophy rather than the Creator and provident God of traditional Christian thought. The Pope stresses that it was this God -- viewed as the fount of the existence of all reality -- that formed the basis of the philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas. It is specifically the thought of St. Thomas that Catholic Church has strongly proposed as a model for theologians and philosophers especially since the time of Leo XIII’s Aeterni Patris (1879) in the first glimmerings of the dawn of the twentieth century.
After Descartes, the tendency in the most influential European philosophers is to push to one side the role of God in the world and concentrate on human thinking. Berkley’s (d. 1753) phrase, "esse est percipi" ("Being is [human] perception"), is symptomatic of this approach and became a dogma for many philosophers. In this approach, it is the thought of each human individual that takes center stage rather than the objective world and its ultimate cause: God. The Pope points out that this anthropocentric view produces modern immanentism and subjectivism to such a degree that philosophy turns from the study of objective reality, which was the main interest of the previous philosophy, to concentrate on human thought and experience. Pope John Paul II concludes that "The consequence was that man was supposed to live by his reason alone, as if God did not exist." He adds that "A God working through man turned out to be useless to modern knowledge." Finally, he adds, "since the existence of a Creator or of Providence was in no way helpful to science, it was also necessary to act as if God did not exist, as if God were not interested in the world."
The Pope indicates the precise error of philosophy after Descartes by noting that it distanced human thought from the view of St. Thomas. In short, it turned away from the God of existence and a philosophy of existence in which God is "Ipsum Esse Subsistens" (The very act of Being in a stable way), i.e. a God who is Existence itself and is the origin of all that exists. Instead of the God of existence, the thought of the individual takes center stage.
As we have seen, Berkeley had popularized and really dogmatized the notion that "Being is human perception." This wrong notion of being made it impossible for later philosophical thought to understand how God is the origin and active participant in all of history. Nor from this viewpoint, could it be seen how God is the underlying cause of all things. In the view of a philosophy of existence as in St. Thomas, creatures can act only in virtue of the fact that they are continually sustained in their existence by this Perfect Cause who is infinite Goodness. Thus, any defect or evil arising from the creature’s responsibility arises only because that creature is at all time sustained in its activity as creature by the Creator. After Descartes the true God is replaced by the "god" of the deists, whom the Pope describes as the "God outside the world." In other words, God is seen as the perfect watchmaker whose clock now can go on independently without its maker.
This wrong view of God, as the Pope points out, is based on a wrong view of what existence is, and it is a view that has gone on to dominate contemporary philosophy. We have already seen St. Paul’s brief description of our true relation to God "For we are his handiwork, created in Christ Jesus for the good works that God has prepared in advance that we should live in them" (Eph 2:10). It is when mankind forgets this relationship to God that we fall into the old error of the Greek philosopher Protagoras that "man is the measure of all things." It is a view that the heroic Socrates strenuously resisted with his insistence on a greater objective Truth that St. Augustine revealed as God himself.
It is through the glorification of humanity at the expense of God that we arrive at the key problem of our contemporary apostasy as the Bible describes it. This is the apostasy where we see "the lawless one … who opposes and exalts himself above every so-called god and object of worship so as to seat himself in the temple of God, claiming that he is god" (2 Thes 2:3-4). When any person believes as Protagoras did that "man is the measure of all things," and when subjectivism becomes the dominant mentality, there is no longer any law and everyone becomes "the lawless one" who pushes God to one side in his personal life and in all sectors of human existence. This is precisely the situation that prevails for many especially in the European thought that these two popes have described. However, in the process of globalization this trend has extended its tentacles on a vaster level.
The Role of Vatican II
However, the word "apostasy" indicates a loss of faith, not simply a lack of faith, and this applies therefore in a special way to the Church. This situation was analyzed already in the first year of the pontificate of Pope Benedict in his Christmas address to the Roman Curia (December 22, 2005). He quotes St. Basil after the Council of Nicea. St. Basil lamented how after that council, "the confused din of uninterrupted clamoring, has now filled almost the whole of the Church, falsifying through excess or failure the right doctrine of the faith …." Pope Benedict explains that he chose this quote to indicate how a similar problem has arisen since Vatican II.
He attributes the problem to those within the Church who interpret the documents in a wrong way and see the Council as a radical break with the past rather than a development which maintains authentic continuity. The dissidents’ approach is to claim to follow the "spirit" of the Council rather than the actual texts, and the Pope concludes that "room was consequently made for every whim." To correct this wrong notion, the Pope points out that the bishops are simply "stewards" of what Christ himself has entrusted to the Church; they cannot manipulate and change things simply to suit human preferences or trends. In other words, man (humanity) is not "the measure of all things" as some disciples of Protagoras continue to maintain.
Implicit in the Pope’s critique of those who have falsified the Council is the fact that they have chosen to remain within the institutional Catholic Church though they in fact no longer share the same beliefs as those expressed in the Council and post-Conciliar pronouncements. It is clear that this is important in explaining the problem of apostasy which these two popes have highlighted. In fact, in the past, at times dissident Catholics have found political refuge outside the Church as in the classic cases of Luther and Calvin, but there are of course many other examples in history. These clear breaks in the unity of the Church had the advantage of clarifying matters considerably, but as history has shown, such schisms can then go on for centuries.
Another quite different example is that of the Jansenists of the 17th and 18th centuries. They too caused considerable confusion within the Catholic Church because they insisted on their membership within the Church though the official Church saw them as heretics. In fact, without the benefit of political support, they could never establish a separate church and so they faded away in history. Thus, our present situation can be viewed as the lesser of two evils; there is confusion within the Church, but there has been no open schism that establishes these dissidents as a separate church. Nevertheless, the present situation is hardly without negative effects on the Church’s mission, which is essentially linked to her fidelity to the authentic message of Christ rather than passing human philosophies.
It is no doubt instructive to see how the Anglican Communion has weathered the storms of tradition versus transformation. The headlines speak of the question of gay bishops, gay clergy, and gay marriage, amongst other thorny and controversial issues, but already back in 1930 a previous ruling by the Lambeth conference had already begun decupling sexuality’s connection with family when it first allowed contraception. This break with what was then the universal and classical Christian morality was an important break along the road of separation from traditional Christianity. They were already on the way to what Pope John Paul II describes as the path "of relativism in values and morality, and of pragmatism – and even a cynical hedonism – in daily life."
In the light of the gradual erosion of authentic Christianity within Anglicanism, it is interesting to look at the other characteristic of the apostasy as described by St. Paul who, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, comments, "For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work. But the one who restrains is to do so only for the present until he is removed from the scene. And then the lawless one will be revealed …" (2 Thes 2:7-8). As one looks at the progressive deterioration of authentic Christianity with the Anglican Communion and really in Christianity in general, the spontaneous comment arises that without the office of Peter, their ship has run against the reefs of human opinion. Could St. Paul have been referring here to the teaching authority of the Church, especially the Pope, which is denied outside the Catholic Church? Is it not a result of attacks on the Pope that traditional Catholic belief in the fundamentals of Christian life has progressively weakened even within the Church through criticism and open rebellion? There is no doubt, as Pope Benedict has indicated, that the dissidents within the Catholic Church have shoved aside the restraining role of the Pope in their own lives and work to promote this attitude within the Church as a whole.
Hope for the Future
The account of the future of the Church in the Bible’s conclusion, the Book of Revelation, ends on a triumphant note, and the passage from 2 Thessalonians is no different. The Bible predicts God’s victory over the lawless one "whom the Lord will kill with breath of his mouth" (2 Thes 2:8). This is a clear reminder of that first crisis of faith in the Church among the apostles at the time of the crucifixion and how it was resolved: Jesus himself came in an apparition where he literally blew away their fears and doubts when "he breathed on them and said to them ‘receive the Holy Spirit’" (Jn 20:23).
It is hardly surprising, therefore, that recent pontiffs have often looked to the Holy Spirit as the answer to humanity’s problems as well as those of the Church at this time in particular. Indeed, in his official prayer for the Second Vatican Council, Pope John XXIII was inspired to boldly request a "new Pentecost." At the time, no one could have imagined that almost 50 years later, future popes would have seen the genuine and truly urgent need for a most special outpouring of the Holy Spirit to face the problems caused by the atheism and lawlessness of our times. Pope John’s invocation of the Holy Spirit has been repeated by various popes over these years since the Council.
At the World Youth Day in Sydney in 2008, Pope Benedict was therefore not just launching an showy slogan when he said the event had been "transformed into a new Pentecost," stating that from it, "the mission of the young people called to be apostles to their contemporaries was relaunched." The Pope was reminding us that the Holy Spirit is being poured out abundantly to meet the special needs of our times, precisely as Pope John XXIII was inspired to implore. Pope Benedict again returned to this theme when he addressed a group of priests and seminarians on August 5, 2008. He recalled his experience at Sydney and said that, "there was a moment in which we truly felt the breath of the Holy Spirit …." In his talk, he mentioned specifically the apparition of Jesus to his Apostles right after his resurrection when he breathed on them. He concluded that the Holy Spirit can be considered as the breath of Christ, and therefore, "we, in a certain sense, must ask Christ to breathe on us always, so that his breath will become alive and strong and work upon the world."
Filled as he is with Christian hope, the Pope stressed that it is the Spirit that "creates light in the darkness and makes us feel not only that faith has a future but that it is the future." It remains for us, however, to remain "available as instruments." At the same time the Pope stated that, "we cannot pass on the Holy Spirit effectively or make him perceptible to others unless we ourselves are close to him." Therefore we must, "remain, so to speak, within the radius of the Holy Spirit’s breath, in contact with him. Only … if he dwells in us, will it be possible for us to pass him on to others."
The Pope’s approach is profoundly mystical, but it is also quite pastoral and transformative. He speaks of the Spirit who then "gives us the imagination and creative ideas about how to act, ideas that cannot be planned but are born from the situation itself because it is there that the Spirit is at work." Pope Benedict always remained a pastoral man and a true shepherd of souls even when he was living in Rome before he became Pope, and therefore it is easy to understand his very practical and pastoral view on the action of the Holy Spirit in the Church. He quotes St. Augustine who said, "If you desire the Spirit of God, you must be in the Body of Christ"(the Church), and the Pope adds that the Spirit "moves within the Mystical Body of Christ." By a solid spiritual life, therefore, based on the word of God and the sacraments, we remain within this "radius of the Holy Spirit’s breath." It is then that, if we cooperate, "something happens to us: the day acquires a form, and in it our life itself acquires a form, and this light will shine from us without us having to give it much thought or having to adopt a ‘propagandist’ – so to speak – way of acting: it comes automatically because it mirrors our soul. If we live with Christ we will also succeed in human things."
The Pope sees a parallel between Genesis (where God breathes life into Adam) and the resurrected Jesus breathing on his Apostles (Jn 20:23). There is therefore a new creation produced by the action of the Spirit. To live this new life "we must keep close to Christ." He adds that this is done by "meditating on his Word." But ultimately it is the Spirit who communicates this word to us. It is then that "through his Word we speak with God, when we do not only seek the past in it but truly the Lord who is present and speaks to us, then …. it is as if we were to find ourselves strolling in the garden of the Holy Spirit; we talk to him and he talks to us." The Pope describes this as an "environment of the Word of God" which then "introduces us into the breath of God. And then, naturally, this listening, walking in the environment of the Word must be transformed into a response, a response in prayer, in contact with Christ … first of all in the blessed sacrament of the Eucharist."
The Pope insists that the Spirit which animates this new creation is eminently practical in this world: "Indeed, faith does not only involve a supernatural aspect, it rebuilds man, bringing him back to his humanity ….our life should be oriented to the Holy Spirit ….in the body of Christ, and from this we experience humanization, we nurture the simple human virtues and thus learn to be good in the broadest sense of the word." All of this, says the Pope, promotes in us initiatives which develop "a missionary force and in a certain sense prepare the ground for the moment when it becomes reasonable and comprehensible to speak of Christ and of our faith."
The Bible is a book of hope. As Jesus said, "Fear not little flock"(Lk 12:32). The Pope’s grim warnings of apostasy should be taken most seriously and faced with realistic and courageous determination by the faithful. But at the same time, these very warnings should fill us with hope for the future, a hope that trusts in the Holy Spirit of Christ rather than our merely human powers. St. Luke’s words describe the right attitude for Christians faced with in our troubled times, "…. When these signs begin to happen, stand erect and raise your heads because your redemption is at hand" (Lk 21:28). It is the Pope who is teaching us how with the power of the Spirit we can raise our heads in hope and act in the charity that flows from our faith in Christ as we look forward to the future.