By Fr. James Fannan, PIME
Introduction
Professors of theology and philosophy are often frustrated and challenged by their students’ lack of interest in the history of human thought. Often students tend to be interested most of all in the latest trends and seem ready to jump on the nearest bandwagon without being so concerned about an analysis of where it is heading and what its true nature is. The title of this article reflects upon both of these aspects of thought in the light of contemporary theology. In other words, is there a trend to return unknowingly to the past?
Nestorianism
The Nestorians definitely have had an important role in Asian theology. Not only was Nestorianism born in Asia, it also flourished in Asia to the eastern extremities, outside the confines of the ancient Roman Empire, eventually reaching China and India. Except in India and Iraq, it has vanished without a trace in most places, and apparently it was mostly absorbed by Islam and Buddhism.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church briefly discusses Nestorianism which first came to the attention of the ordinary laity when Nestorius asserted that it was incorrect to call Mary "the Mother of God." It was especially this conclusion that revealed an underlying error of Nestorius which was not at first so evident to the ordinary believer. The Catechism of the Catholic Church sums up Nestorianism in N. 466. It states that the Nestorians "regarded Christ as a human person joined to the divine person of God’s Son." Of course, it is clear that Jesus was truly a human and the son of God as well, and so the error of there being two persons rather than one is not readily apparent to everyone. However, the logic of his own theories led Nestorius to the conclusion that Mary is not the Mother of God. It was this conclusion that was the catalyst for the Council of Ephesus in 431. The council condemned the underlying theory that Nestorius had about Christ as the union of two persons. The same council also clarified that Catholic theology teaches that, "the Word, uniting to himself in his person the flesh animated by a rational soul became man." It further added that, "Christ’s humanity has no other subject than the divine person of the Son of God, who assumed it and has made it has own from his conception." What is especially important here is that the council stressed that Christ is only one person (not two) even though he has taken on a human nature to become truly a human being like us. The incarnation occurred, moreover, in a very specific time and cultural context. As Jesus said to the Scribes and Pharisees, "before Abraham came to be, I AM" (Jn 8:58).
It is due to the fact that Jesus is only one person (the Word of God) that the divine person of the Word can enter into a relationship with Mary whereby she is truly his mother. She is not the origin of his divinity, but it is through her that his humanity is united to his divinity in the one person of the Word. The exact words of the council were that she is the: "Mother of God, not that the nature of the Word or his divinity received the beginning of its existence from the holy Virgin, but that, since the holy body animated by a rational soul, which the Word of God united to himself according to the hypostasis, was born from her, the Word is said to be born according to the flesh."
The Catechism in N. 467 pursues the matter by stating that twenty years later in 451, the Council of Chalcedon further clarified the matter. Speaking of the divine and human natures of Jesus they affirmed, "The distinction between the natures was never abolished by their union, but rather the character proper to each of the two natures was preserved as they came together in one person (prosopon) and one hypostasis." It reaffirmed therefore that Mary is "the Mother of God" and that Jesus is like us (humans) "in all things but sin." It is noteworthy that theology and philosophy actually took a step forward in this controversy since previously the distinction between the person and the nature of a person (human, angelic, divine) had never really been clearly put into focus. There were individual humans and angels who were "persons" according to the concept presented by these two councils, but previously the focus had been more on the nature of a particular individual. The dual nature of Christ required this clarification. Thus it was Christian theology and philosophy that pursued and deepened our understanding of what exactly it is to be a person and what the distinction between nature and person is. In simple language, the word person indicates who we are; the word nature indicates what kind of being we are. They are two separate ideas that reflect different realities in the world.
It was this notion of person, therefore, that distinguished traditional Christianity from the doctrines of Nestorius, and clearly the concept of person remains key to preserving Christianity in its authentic form. This is why it is significant that in recent decades, due to certain theological trends, there is the tendency to cloud over this traditional theological notion of person. This in turn has led to confusion in the area of Christology and the rest of theology, which clearly depends on a correct Christology.
Echoes of Nestorius in Contemporary Catholicism
A recent evidence of the contemporary problematic in this area is a declaration in 2007 regarding the theologian Fr. Peter Phan. Although he wrote his book as a professor at Georgetown University in the United States, his book is an effort to make a contribution to Asian theology; hence the title is Being Religious Interreligiously: Asian Perspectives on Interfaith Dialogue. It was the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith that requested the United Sates Conference of Catholic Bishops to arrange an evaluation of the book of Fr. Phan. This is a noteworthy step inasmuch as the Congregation here is encouraging the American bishops to take responsibility for what is taking place in their own country rather than expecting the Vatican to do something that is first and foremost within the American area of pastoral concern. Ideally, however, such prodding should not have been necessary since it is in fact the responsibility of the local bishops to take care of their flock and to be alert to their needs.
In their analysis of Fr. Phan’s book, the American bishops made ample use of quotes from the declaration Dominus Jesus which had already been issued by the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on August 6, 2000. That fact is important because it indicates that certain theological errors had already been diffused widely enough to make it necessary for a statement at a universal level. I quote from the American Document here because it highlights the question I raised in the title of this article. The American document is entitled "Clarifications Required by the Book Being Religious Interreligiously: Asian Perspectives on Interfaith Dialogue by Reverend Peter C. Phan." The authors of the document are the Committee on Doctrine of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.
The Nestorian aspect of the problem emerges specifically in number 11 of the American bishop’s statement; however, they are actually quoting Dominus Jesus. They state that "The union of humanity and divinity that takes place in Jesus Christ is by its very nature unique and unrepeatable. The person who is the eternal Son of God is the very same person who is Jesus Christ."
History repeats itself
From the quote we have just seen, it is clear that the question of Nestorianism is not a closed chapter for some contemporary writers and thinkers in the Catholic Church. The quote from Dominus Jesus is aimed at correcting errors that are found in more than just one writer; they are clearly ideas that are widespread enough to merit such a clarification. Be that as it may, it is useful to focus here on what the American bishops actually had to say about the book of Fr. Phan. I think that it then becomes clear that the roots of the contemporary problem are not directly related at least historically to the thought or context of Nestorius himself; however, for special reasons, both trends of thought, whether contemporary or classic Nestorian, end up in the same place. Namely, both fail to recognize the true unique reality of Jesus, and thus they are in fact closely related and at times virtually identical theories in their consequences for theology.
Let us first look at some of the observations of the American bishops. In number 11 of their statement, they say that, "Because the humanity and divinity are united in the person of the Son of God, he brings together humanity and divinity in a way that can have no parallel in any other figure in history." This is contrasted in number 10 with a quote from Dominus Jesus which states that "In contemporary theological reflection there often emerges an approach to Jesus of Nazareth that considers him a particular finite, historical figure, who reveals the divine not in an exclusive say, but in a way complementary with other revelatory and salvific figures." However, the bishops again quote Dominus Jesus correcting such a view and add that it must be firmly believed that, "Jesus of Nazareth, son of Mary, and he alone, is the son and the Word of the Father." The conclusion that the bishops reach in number 15 of their statement is found in another quote from Dominus Jesus that asserts that "the theory of the limited, incomplete, or imperfect character of the revelation of Jesus Christ, which would be complementary to that found in other religions, is contrary to the Church’s faith."
From these quotes, it becomes clear that the focus of the problem is not on the philosophical and theological concept of "person"; the focus is on the uniqueness of Christ in his mediation and in his revelation. The lack of clarity about Christ’s true nature therefore in some contemporary theological writings is really the fruit of an unwillingness to recognize his unique role in salvation history as the sole mediator between God and man as the God-man and the incarnate Word of God. Going back to basics, the American bishops in number 13 again quote Dominus Jesus starting that "Only Jesus’ sacrificial death makes possible the forgiveness of sins and the reconciliation of sinful humanity with God." The salvific value of his death, in contrast to other historical martyrdoms is based on the fact that he is a divine person whose actions have universal value. As St. John the Baptist put it, "Behold the Lamb of God" (Jn 1:36), indicating Jesus as a sacrificial victim in the Old Testament tradition which continues in the New Testament as the universal salvific victim (cf. Jn 19:36; Rv 5:6-14).
To avoid any misunderstanding, however, the American bishops, add in number 14 (again citing Dominus Jesus) that "This does not mean that members of other religions cannot possibly be saved, but it does mean that their salvation is always accomplished in some way through Christ." As far as other religions themselves are concerned, it adds that, "Although participated forms of mediation of different kinds and degrees are not excluded, they acquire meaning and value only from Christ’s own mediation, and they cannot be understood as parallel or complementary to his." This flows logically from the sacrificial nature of the death of Jesus, the God-man. In other words, it is not enough to stress spiritual truths outside of Christianity; it is necessary to also stress the fundamental value of Christ’s offering of himself as the victim who makes reparation for the sins of all humanity. It is this offering alone that opens up to all the hope of eternal life precisely because of the unique nature of the sacrifice offered by the God-man.
The Problem of Interreligious Dialogue
I feel that all of what we have seen so far puts in the proper context that reason for the lack of clarity about the true identity of Christ among a number of contemporary writers. This lack of clarity arises from the temptation to propose a theology of dialogue with non-Christian religions that at the very least ignores the uniqueness of Christ as the key figure in the history of salvation. This was described by the bishops’ document in number 10 where it states that "In contemporary theological reflection there often emerges an approach to Jesus of Nazareth that considers him a particular, finite, historical figure, who reveals the divine not in an excusive way, but in a way complementary with other revelatory and salvific figures."
It is understandable that those who are deeply committed to promoting interreligious dialogue find the claims of Christ and consequently of the Church to be awkward. Pope John Paul II recognized this fact in 1990 in his encyclical Redemptoris Missio. In number 55 he speaks directly to the situation in Asia stating: "I recently wrote to the Bishops of Asia . . ." He then goes on to insist that "Dialogue should be conducted and implemented with the conviction that the Church is the ordinary means of salvation and that she alone possesses the fullness of the means of salvation." He also quotes Christ proclaiming himself to be, "the way, the truth, and the life." Clearly claims like this can be awkward for one who wants to promote interreligious dialogue. Such absolutism seems to leave little room for some sort of comfortable compromise – an "I’m OK, you’re OK" feeling in which all can return home without having been really challenged by anything that has been said. It is precisely this latter kind of exchange which is sometimes falsely regarded as dialogue. However, the Pope makes it clear that this is not really dialogue as the Church understands it; it is only laying the groundwork for a genuinely authentic dialogue. It is still, therefore, an initial stage of establishing a relationship that can be a basis for a sincere future exchange of thought. The Pope clarifies the nature of true dialogue by stating that , "Those engaged in this dialogue must be consistent with their own religious traditions and convictions and be open to understanding those of the other party without pretence or close-mindedness, but with truth, humility and frankness … There must be no abandonment of principles nor false irenicism, but instead a witness given and received for mutual advancement on the road of religious inquiry and experience, and at the same time for the elimination of prejudice, intolerance, and misunderstandings."
Anyone who has engaged in dialogue knows that it is a delicate enterprise. On the one hand, there must be an authentic presentation of religious doctrines, including their differences; on the other hand, there must the willingness to listen and learn without falling into some sort of debate. This ideal, however, can fail to be reached when doctrine is presented in such a way that certain truths are explained in an ambiguous way that is only part of the truth. This can occur when some sort of verbal agreement is being sought which is really based on a misunderstanding. Quite often this can be the temptation on the Catholic side. Normally those Catholics who engage in dialogue in a serious way are rather well versed in this field before they actually reach the state of dialogue in the sense of religious give and take with members of another faith. The danger is that to preserve the atmosphere and process and contacts, some Catholics are afraid to state frankly what the Catholic position is. This really makes it impossible for the non-Christian participants to fully engage in authentic dialogue since they then fail to grasp what exactly it is that Christians believe.
To turn specifically to the question of a kind of Nestorian Christology which has reappeared in our times, if Jesus is simply the Catholic guru, or teacher, or prophet, then it is easy to fall into a comfortable "I’m OK you’re OK" attitude in which the Catholic position is really falsified because it is presented in an ambiguous and incomplete way. If, however, Jesus is presented as the unique incarnate Word of God, the way, the truth, and the life, the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world, there is no falsification of the Christian Gospel. A non-Christian cannot be expected to agree with this, but he at least must understand that we do not see Jesus as simply a guru, or teacher, or prophet of our religion. To be honest with our interlocutors, we must be clear that we see Jesus as unique and absolute. It may be difficult to find partners for a true dialogue of this nature, but it has to remain the authentic goal for which preparatory and imperfect steps are needed; however, these preparatory steps must never seen as being the fulfillment of the goal of a discussion based on an honest and clear presentation of the Catholic faith.
The title of this article speaks of "Nestorianism" not in the sense that we are dealing with precisely the same reality, which was born in another context, but what we are dealing with is a kind of Christology in which Jesus becomes just one of many prophets, teachers, and gurus because he no longer is quite simply the Word made flesh. In this case, it is easy for our partners in dialogue to simply conclude that we prefer Jesus and they prefer somebody else, and then the discussion can move on to speak of various moral or doctrinal matters. Instead, for genuine religious dialogue, it must be clear that we accept the claim of Jesus to be "the" way (not "a" way) as well as "the truth and the life." Of course, in dialogue, it is not our intention to convince others of this truth, but they must understand that we believe this truth. Otherwise, it is not yet a true dialogue since there is still a fundamental misunderstanding which comes from a less than accurate presentation of Christianity as it is believed and practiced all over the world by the great masses of believers.
On the Catholic side, it seems that there can be two wrong approaches to dialogue which touch on the topic of this article. One is to present the truth in this ambiguous way (in which it is no longer the whole truth). The other approach is to reach the conclusion that in fact all religions are simply an imperfect attempt to deal with a reality that is too big for any of them. Obviously, this last approach is totally inadequate since it is incapable of presenting Christianity and is simply the private religion of some thinker.
The Situation in India
Let us look at this last theory first. In 1998, the Vatican came out with document entitled "Notification Concerning the Writings of Fr. Anthony De Mello, SJ." They summarize important errors in his writings which touch on the topic of this article. For example, "he considers Jesus as a master alongside others. The only difference from other men is that Jesus is ‘awake’ and fully free, while others are not." As far as the teachings of Christianity are concerned, they add that he teaches that, "In place of the revelation which has come in the person of Jesus Christ …. Nothing can be said about God; the only knowing is unknowing." Following his own logic, Fr. De Mello concludes that the Bible is an "idol." Clearly, this kind of approach to Catholicism could gain a more sympathetic hearing from some non-Christian listeners than the genuine Catholic position, but such an approach is of no value for genuine dialogue. In fact, it is not a presentation of the Christian position. The Vatican document concludes that De Mello’s views "are incompatible with the Catholic faith and can cause grave harm." Needless to say, a key aspect of his error is precisely his failure to see Jesus as the incarnate Word of God.
The other wrong approach is that of being ambiguous. Again, I turn to the views of qualified experts rather than my own analysis and opinion. In this case, the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued a "Notification on the book Toward a Christian theology of Religious Pluralism (Orbis Books: Maryknoll, New York 1997) by Father Jacques Dupuis, SJ." Here the problem is ambiguity rather than clearly erroneous assertions. In the preface, the Sacred Congregation stated that they "recognized the author’s attempt to remain within the limits of orthodoxy" but they go on to say that in his book they found "notable ambiguities and difficulties on important doctrinal opinions which could lead a reader to erroneous or harmful opinions." They summarize these points saying that they are in reference to "the interpretation of the sole and universal salvific mediation of Christ, the unity and completeness of Christ’s revelation, the universal salvific action of the Holy Spirit, the orientation of all peoples to the Church, and the value and significance of the salvific function of other religions."
Since the Sacred Congregation does not accuse Fr. Dupuis of actually saying anything heretical (but simply saying things in a way that could lead to "erroneous and harmful opinions"), it proposes that future edition of the book should have a clarifying list of doctrinal statement that he, as a Catholic, accepts. In the first number it states that "Jesus Christ, the Son of God made man … is the sole and universal mediator of salvation for all humanity." In number 2, it adds that, "it is contrary to the Catholic faith not only to posit a separation between the Word and Jesus, or between the Word’s salvific activity and that of Jesus, but also to maintain that there is a salvific activity of the Word as such in his divinity independent of the humanity of the Incarnate Word."
Here the there is a clear effort on the part of the Vatican against any interpretation of Christ’s role that has a Nestorian tendency to divide Jesus into two separate realities that are not strictly united. In number 3, it adds that it is "contrary to the Catholic faith to maintain that revelation in Jesus Christ (or the revelation of Jesus Christ) is limited, incomplete or imperfect." On the contrary it insists that, "The historical revelation of Jesus Christ offers everything necessary for man’s salvation and has no need of completion by other religions." In number 4, it comments on truths found in other religions and clarifies that "it is erroneous to hold that such elements of truth and goodness, or some of them, do not derive ultimately from the source mediation of Jesus Christ." In number 6, it states that, "It is contrary to the Catholic faith to consider the different religions of the world as ways of salvation complementary to the Church."
Authentic Interreligious Dialogue
After all these points that might be profoundly discouraging for some of those who want to engage in dialogue, the Vatican adds in number 8, that, "It is therefore legitimate to maintain that the Holy Spirit accomplishes salvation in non-Christians also through those elements of truth and goodness present in the various religious; however, to hold that these religions, considered as such, are ways of salvation, has no foundation in Catholic theology also because they contain omissions, insufficiencies and errors regarding fundamental truths about God, man and the world."
What we have seen here, then, is in fact a tendency in contemporary theology and specifically in some Asian theologians to work along lines that share in the fundamental error of Nestorius. Fr. Phan specifically addressed his book to the topic of "Asian perspectives." Fr. De Mello was an Indian, and his books are still widely available in Catholic bookstores. Fr. Dupuis had worked for 36 years in India as a theology teacher and was even the director of the important theological journal of Vidyajyoti College of Theology. Thus, it is probable that these kinds of theories are not just the personal ideas of these three men alone. It is important therefore to be aware of the importance of this theological tendency in contemporary theology, particularly in Asia where the urgency of the matter is keenly felt.
Asia is the sole continent where Christianity has not had a powerful, transforming impact, and it is, of course, especially the work of Asian theologians to enter into dialogue with the Asian religious world which surrounds them. The ideas we have seen thus far should be a clear indication of what is the right way forward at this point. I stressed the idea of Nestorianism because I think it helps show the error of pursuing that kind of Christology not just from a doctrinal perspective, but also from a strictly historical perspective. If Christianity has penetrated and transformed the other continents, why has it failed over these past two thousand years to penetrate Asia in the same way? It would seem reasonable to believe that much of the blame is due precisely to Nestorianism.
When Islam swept up to conquer vast swathes of territory between the West and the great civilizations of India, China, and Indo-China, it found a Christian presence that reached all the way to China and was especially strong in Iraq, Iran, and southern India. A glance of contemporary reality, however, reveals that unlike Western Christianity, Nestorian Christianity was either reduced to a ghetto or finally completely disappeared. It is no wonder that a Jesus who was merely closely connected with God in some mysterious way could be replaced by some other figure who was seen as being somehow superior to Jesus. Rather than opening the path to dialogue, this kind of approach easily leads to what we have seen in De Mello’s writings – a complete abandonment of genuine Christianity. Otherwise, it is reduced to an ineffective and unconvincing preference for a person – Jesus – who is basically more or less like any other famous religious figure.
The right approach is, of course, fidelity to the fundamentals of Catholic teaching as we have seen in the various interventions of ecclesial authorities in this paper. It seems to me that a healthy and solid approach is to stress and explain in the early stages of our presentation quite simply the magnificent introduction that St. John was inspired to place at the beginning of his Gospel. He was a mystic and evangelist in a non-Christian milieu. He was the author of the letter to the "seven churches in Asia" (Rv 1:4). And it is he who summed up beautifully the truths we have been looking at in this paper. If we include his prologue in our dialogue with non-Christians, it is then clear to all the hearers that for us Jesus is not just like other saints of history, and since it is taken from the Gospel of John, the words are not a matter of our own choosing. Whether listeners believe or not, at least this introduction should make clear to them where we are coming from:
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came to be through him, and without him nothing came to be. What came to be through him was life, and this life was the light of the human race; the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it. A man named John was sent from God. He came for testimony to testify to the light, so that all might believe through him. He was not the light, but came to testify to the light. The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world. He was in the world, and the world came to be through him, but the world did not know him. He came to what was his own, but his own people did not accept him. But to those who did accept him he gave power to become children of God, to those who believe in his name, who were born not by natural generation nor by human choice nor by a man's decision but of God. And the Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us, and we saw his glory, the glory as of the Father's only Son, full of grace and truth. John testified to him and cried out, saying, ‘This was he of whom I said, the one who is coming after me ranks ahead of me because he existed before me,’ because while the law was given through Moses, grace and truth came through Jesus Christ. No one has ever seen God. The only Son, God, who is at the Father's side, has revealed him." (Jn 1:1-18).