back  A Listening Heart continue
Brother David Steindl-Rast

Sacred Sensuousness
A Step-by-Step Approach

The three steps
of
a listening heart:
1. Childlike Openness;
2. Youthful Courage;
3.
Mature Communion.

Our first point regarding transformation through sense experience will easily be granted. If you know from experience how it feels to listen to music so deeply that suddenly you are no longer over against the music as listener, but "you are the music / while the music lasts," then you know also that this is not your accomplishment, but an overwhelming gift. If, as a child, you had a Saint Bernard dog in whose shaggy coat you could dig your fingers and bury your face until you became "dense and happy as fur," or if you have ever raised your eyes to snowy peaks reaching into a deep blue sky and felt everything within you rise and shine, then you know that these are moments of grace, nothing anyone could earn or deserve, but gifts, freely given.

Our second point may be less obvious. It claims an existential, rather than an aesthetic impact for moments when "you are the music / while the music lasts." If this impact were merely aesthetic, only our sense of beauty would be affected, but such moments are apt to affect our whole life. Peak experiences of this kind do not just tell us something about our taste. They show us who we are.

See if you can validate this claim against your own experience. Music is not the only realm in which sensual pleasure can reach so high a degree that it ignites, and in the blast makes our awareness fuse with its object. To many people this happens in nature or in sports - think of marathon runners - or in art forms other than music.

We might ask: What kind of music is likely to be "heard so deeply / that it is not heard at all, but you are the music / while the music lasts"? ls this likely to happen with Muzak? To be heard so deeply music demands more than that we turn it on as we turn on a fan on a hot day. It demands that we truly listen, that we pay attention - attention plus. The "plus" consists in this: We must somehow give ourselves to music before it takes hold of us. Our laziness feels more comfortable with music for easy consumption than with music that is demanding. Demanding? Let us take this expression seriously. What does it imply?

Demanding and difficult are closely related terms, but there is a fine distinction between the two. Exploring what distinguishes the merely difficult from the demanding will help us find that edge of our awareness where the aesthetic plunges down into existential depth. As dose as difficult and demanding are to each other, the difficult is not always demanding, nor is the demanding always difficult. Check some examples: You spilled coffee on your friend's newly upholstered couch; removing the stain may be difficult, though not demanding; admitting your clumsiness is demanding, but where is the difficulty? Climbing Annapurna may be unimaginably difficult and demanding yet, bowing to weather conditions and turning back a hundred feet below the summit is still more demanding, although it cuts short the difficulties.

Analyzing a piece of music according to all the intricacies of musicology is certainly more difficult than simply to sit back and listen with wholehearted enjoyment; yet, to listen deeply is more demanding than to analyze the structure. Analyzing takes knowledge and skill; true listening takes all of you. It might not seem difficult to give ourselves to the rapture of beauty. Yet, out of it emerges a Presence, a Voice, name it as you wish, that goes beyond aesthetics and makes existential demands: "You must change. ..."

Transformation:
is gift,
not achievement;
is existential,
not aesthetic;
is self-fulfilment,
not exchange
of self.

So far, I have made two points concerning this change: the transformation is not achieved but given, and it is not aesthetic but existential. My third point is that we are not transformed into something other, but into our own true self. It is this third point we must consider now. It will be helpful to start with an insight which Oscar Cullmann expressed when he wrote, "There is faithfulness at the heart of all things." The moment we stop taking for granted this faithfulness at the heart of things, we wake up. We find ourselves "at the brink of our longing." On this side is the multifarious fullness accessible to our senses; beyond is the simple fullness of its sense and meaning: the heart of all is faithfulness.

Instinctively we must have sensed this from the start. We could not have taken the first step, the first breath, had we not trusted that the world is trustworthy. A spark of trust glimmers in our guts. When we let it shine also in our heads and hearts, it becomes more than blind instinct; it becomes trust in life, trust in the very source of life; it becomes full-fledged faith, the only appropriate response to the faithfulness at the heart of all there is.

Is this the same as faith in God? Neither "yes" nor "no" is an adequate answer to this question. If I say "no," I am denying that trust in life is of one piece with trust in the source of life, called God. But if I say "yes," I am causing a short-circuit, since much of what passes as faith In God is merely a fearful clutching of beliefs and has little to do with its genuine counterpart. Genuine faith is courageous trust in God's trustworthiness.

This understanding of faith stands behind St. Paul's central claim: the message of Christ establishes the right relationship between God and humans "from faith to faith" (Rom. 1:17). This key formula traces the bond between God and us humans most succinctly "from (God's keeping) faith to (us having) faith" in God's reliability. In the biblical tradition human faith is the response to divine faithfulness. What we are talking about is not restricted, however, to any particular tradition or creed. It is a universal phenomenon accessible to every human heart. All who follow their senses to the faithful heart of reality find themselves both challenged and encouraged to a faith which all the creeds in the world presuppose as their common matrix.

Buddhist faith lets itself silently down into ultimate faithfulness. Hindu faith meets that faithfulness in the <;:ave of each one's own heart. Biblical faith expresses the encounter with faithfulness in terms of dialogue, "God speaks."

The Bible conceives of everything as created by God's word, and so as actually being a word. In this world view every thing, every person, every situation is at its core a spelling out of God's faithfulness calling for a

response of faith on the hearer's part. Do not deny too quickly that you know what is meant by the poetic image, "God speaks." Yet, don't take my word for it either. Search your own awareness. We are talking about something that is easily missed, "a small, still voice," easily drowned out by our own noises, something shy that wants to be befriended. Only when we become ever so quiet inside do we sense in the smallest speck of reality a great Presence, both strange and familiar, waiting to meet us. Strange this Presence seems to us, because it differs from all else we know; at the same time, we seem to know it more intimately than anything else we ever knew. We dread its strangeness; we long for its intimacy. It is this Presence that looks at us, when we dare to expose ourselves "on the heart's mountains" and demands our transformation: "You must change. ..."

To speak of a Presence is a somewhat poetic way of personification; yet we have no other way to express so

subtle an aspect of reality. Let us remember, though, that we are exploring reality, not a fiction of our imagination. On one level we are saying nothing more profound than that a boulder will faithfully remain rock; that a goat will remain a goat through and through; that an oak tree will display oakness to the core, and hydrogen will reliably be itself down to a single atom. What catapults our awareness to a higher level is our capacity for surprise.

If you have never been surprised that your dog remains so dependably a dog and does not turn suddenly into a kangaroo or a hippopotamus, chances are that you are still taking reality a bit too unquestioningly for granted. Allowing ourselves to be surprised that things are what they are makes us wake up as from a deep sleep. Children, before we clip the wings of their adventurous minds, are capable of this kind of surprise in which Plato recognized the root of all philosophy. It can be cultivated. Cultivating surprise will do wonders for our wakefulness, our aliveness.

Wakeful attention makes us aware of facts we had overlooked in a more superficial contact with reality; the fact, for instance, that in a real sense we become that to which we give ourselves with all. our 'senses. Remember T. S. Eliot's experience of becoming music; remember what it does to you when you watch skaters dancing weightlessly as it seems on a mirror of ice. An orchard in bloom makes us bloom inside. Beauty seen makes the one who sees it more beautiful. The Presence transforms us into itself: Reality makes us real. Here we have reached a decisive insight: to the extent to which we respond with faith to the faithfulness at the heart of reality we ourselves become real.

AlI the toy animals in the children's story The Velveteen Rabbit have one great longing: to become real. Discussing this, while the children are sleeping, the Teddy bears ask the wise; old rocking horse, "Does it hurt to become real?" The answer is, "When you become real, you no longer mind the hurt." The deepest reason for our refusal to wake up and to respond fully to reality is our timid flinching in the face of its hardness. In the measure in which we brave the hurt we become real.

This transformation is pure gift, is existential, and as my third contention claimed - transforms us not into something other, but into ourselves. Becoming real is transformation into our own true self. Here, once again, Rilke finds the perfect expression. In his poem A Walk he speaks of "that which we cannot grasp" - the Presence - as grasping us and transforming us "into that which unawares we are." It cannot be put more succinctly. What we experience as a Presence is the trustworthiness of that which is ultimately real. Through courageous trust in this ultimate reality we become real, Le., we realize our being one with it.

But does this formula remain valid also if those who feel comfortable enough with the word "God" use it in place of ultimate reality? It ought to work, for it would be a sorry God who was not ultimately real. Can we say, then, that by opening our senses wide and courageously to reality we can reach that ultimate goal of our longing, God in us, our own true self? Yes, indeed. By this affirmation we merely reaffirm what St. Augustine knew: Our heart is restless in its quest until it finds God who is from the start closer to us than we are to ourselves" who is the true Self of ourselves.

Consider the remarkable implications. We can indeed find sense through our senses; even ultimate sense, ultimate meaning. Full acceptance of our sensuousness is a genuine spiritual path. Even for spiritually aware Christians the discovery of sacred sensuousness at the core of their own tradition can come as a startling surprise.

Discovering sacred sensuousness is like waking up from a stupor into which Christian spirituality fell in spite of itself, long ago. This awakening is the beginning of a genuinely incarnational spirituality. Sacred sensuousness takes it seriously that God is not only beyond all that we can imagine, but is also the very source of the sensuous reality that feeds our imagination. What a privilege for us to be alive in this period of history when mOJ:1 and more people are waking up to the realization that sensuousness is sacred. Not as if this were some n~ fangled fad. It is merely a re-discovery of the healthy biblical enjoyment of the senses in which Jesus himself was brought up and felt at home. In that same spirit, Irenaeus, one of the earliest Christian theologians, coined the famous saying, "The glory of God is the human being fully alive." Surely this implies aliveness of all the senses. Irenaeus continues, "Life for humans is to see God." How could we expect to see God if we are insensitive to God's Self-revelation to us through all our senses?

Re-discovering
sensuousness as sacred
is re-discovering
Incarnation Spirituality
at the
heart of Christianity.

St. Benedict urges us to open our eyes to the Deificum lumen - the light that makes the beholder divine. This is one of the boldest expressions in Christian spiritual literature. And it stands not in some obscure passage but in a document that has inspired the Christian tradition for three quarters of its history. One has to go to the Latin original in order to get the full impact of St. Benedict's words. Translations turn strangely bland if not outright evasive when they reach this passage, too timid to face "the light that makes divine." Admittedly we are dealing with a bold expression here, but nothing short of sue h boldness can do justice to the bold Good News of transformation "from faith to faith."

Our waking up to sacred sensuousness is only the beginning of transformation, the beginning of a life-long adventure. Opening one's eyes to "the light that makes divine" is only the first step of "walking in the light" (1 Jn. 1:7). Personal transformation is only the starting point for a transformation of the whole world by those to whom the thunder voice calls out, "You are the light of the world" (Mt. 5:14). We shall take a closer look at this challenge in the next chapter. What we have established here, I hope, is that in a spirituality faithful to Jesus Christ sensuousness is not suspect but sacred. A listening heart recognizes in the throbbing of reality pulsating against all our senses the heartbeat of divine life at the core of all that is real.