A Listening Heart ![]()
Brother David Steindl-Rast
Sensuous Asceticism
To distinguish the genuine voice from distracting voices takes practice. Guidance comes to the obedient heart from the heart of reality itself, as we face it with trust and courage and wide open senses. A scene from C. S. Lewis' Perelandra charmingly illustrates this key insight of sensuous asceticism. Ransom, the hero of this space novel, has traveled from Earth to Perelandra, a Paradise-like planet.
In asceticism
delight is primary.
Renunciation
is merely a means
for more genuine
delight.
There we watch him walking through a grove and plucking a fruit from an unknown tree. Through Ransom's eyes we see the ripe fruit's glow and fresh flush; we feel its smooth skin, its plump shape heavy in his hand; with Ransom we smell its fragrance, taste its tart flesh as it first resists his teeth and then melts on his tongue - a deliciously sensuous experience. Ransom licks the juice from his chin and his fingers and - Earthling that he is - typically looks for more. Just as he reaches out, wanting to clutch the next fruit, something surprising happens: he hears - not with his ears, but nevertheless hears - this second fruit saying a loud and clear, "No. One was enough!"
This whimsical story is worth some attention. The setting is imaginary but the experience springs from sober perception; we can check it out by our own experience. This could correct a tendency to give first piace to renunciation when we think of asceticism. No. Delight must come first. Had Ransom not opened all his senses to the "yes" of delight, he would not have heard the "no" of renunciation. And yet, too often ascetic practice is presented not as learning wholehearted attention, but as fitting into some mold of abstinence; not as joyful attunement of all our senses, but as their rejection. Thus, asceticism becomes "mortification" - literally "killing" - instead of life-affirming listening with a grateful heart.
This can lead to dreadful distortions. No wonder we find a healthy hesitation even among spiritually serious people, today, when the topic of asceticism comes up. We have been misled too often. A sound intuition tells us: delight deseryes first piace and renunciation itself is merely a means for greater, more genuine delight. Bernard of Clairvaux, an ascetic if there ever was one, listed the benefits of fasting. On top of this list he put: "food tastes so much more delicious when you are hungry." Eventually asceticism can take us far beyond sensuous pleasure, but unless it starts with the senses it will take us nowhere. Our senses are sparkplugs for healthy ascetical practice; the spark of joy starts it off; what keeps it running is obedience. Without obedience asceticism does not even deserve its name; it is simply debauchery upside-down. But with obedience, with loving listening we discover step by step new levels of joy. Gradually we begin to discern that sense, that meaning, to which the senses can only point the way.
To miss the transition from sensuous delight to a delight beyond the reach of our senses is to miss the upward movement of the inner life. Without the runway of the senses we could never take off. Yet, how shall we get airborne if we stick to the runway? In order to move through the senses to sense we must leave the senses behind.