A Listening Heart ![]()
Brother David
Steindl-Rast
The Environment as Guru
What I wish to share with you is aimed at making you feel at home in a monastery. We might begin with the question: "What should this environment do for us?" Maybe some of you have never been in a monastery; perhaps others have spent most of their lives in one. But it might be worthwhile for all of us to ask ourselves, "What is a monastery, actually?"
The easiest answer, of course,
and probably the best, is to say, "Come and see!" And if one came
quietly enough, one might find out much without any talk. If, however, we must
speak about it, I would suggest that a monastery is, first of all, a controlled
environment, with all the advantages and disadvantages included in this notion.
It's inevitably a somewhat artificial environment, for a particular professional
pursuit.
We know there are controlled environments for other professional pursuits. The
monastery is a controlled environment for the professional pursuit of
cultivating one's contemplative dimension. Those who live in a monastery have
made this their profession. They have made public profession of dedicating
themselves radically to the task of cultivating that contemplative dimension,
which in fact belongs to every one of us. If we call monks the professionals of
the contemplative life, this does not mean that they are better at it than
amateurs may be.
We all know that very often, when you need your sink fixed, an amateur plumber
will do a much better job than a professional. That someone is a professional
does not mean that he or she is better at the relevant professional skills; but
it does mean that one ought to try harder. When we say that monks are
professionals, therefore, we are saying that they have accepted the
responsibility of cultivating professionally what many enjoy merely as amateurs,
the contemplative dimension.
But what do we mean by "contemplative"? If we follow our own particular tradition as Benedictine monks and trace the very word to its Latin root, we may come to see an aspect of contemplation that might complement those that stand more in the foreground of other traditions. I stress this because Father Damasus, the founder of Mount Saviour monastery, used to consider it of great importance; in our tradition the notion of contemplation hinges on the Latin word contemplari. The image and, originally, the reality that stands behind this notion, is that of the Roman augurs, who marked off a particular area in the sky, the templum. Originally, templum was not a building on the ground but an area in the skies on which the augurs, professional seers, fixed their eyes in order to find the immutable order according to which matters here below should be arranged. The sacred order of the temple is merely the reflection of the sacred order above. Father Damasus kept stressing the fact that contemplation consists in the bringing together of the two temples, as the con in contemplari suggests.
Along with this Roman notion there is the biblical pattern: Moses built the sanctuary exactly according to the vision shown him by God on the mountain. Again and again the Bible stresses the faithful correspondence between the temple on earth and its heavenly exemplar. In this sense, Moses truly fulfils the role of the contemplative. And not by chance: what he attempted and what the augurs attempted springs from the same root. The contemplative gesture is deeply rooted in our heart and in our longing for universal harmony. Through the ages humans have longingly looked up to the harmony and order of the starry universe, attuning their heartbeat to its measured movement.
Measure seems to be the basic meaning of the linguistic root from which stem not only cognates like temperature, temperament, template and temporality, but, of course, temple and contemplation. To measure one's step by a universal rhythm and thus to bring one's life into harmony with a universal order - this is contemplatio in our tradition.
Contemplation
attunes our heartbeat
to the rhythm of the
universe.
To move in step, one needs to listen; to sight one's course, one needs to look. The monastery is, therefore, conceived as a place where one learns to keep one’s eyes and ears open. "Listen!" is the first word of St. Benedict's Rule for Monasteries, and another keyword il "consider!" – literally meaning to lay your course by the stars. St. Benedict, the patriarch of Western monks, wants them to live apertis oculis and attonitis auribus, with open eyes, and with ears so alert that the silence of God's presence sounds like thunder. This is why a Benedictine monastery is to be a schola Dominici servitii, a school in which one learns to attune oneself to ultimate order.
But such an order means nothing rigid. That would be the great danger, that would be the trap into which one could fall, to conceive of ultimate order as static. On the contrary, it is profoundly dynamic; the only image that we can ultimately find for this order is the dance of the spheres. What we are invited to do, what we are to learn in the monastery, professionally, is to listen to that tune, to attune ourselves to that harmony to which the whole universe dances. St. Augustine expresses the dynamism of'order when he says, "Ordo est amoris", which means that order is simply the expression of the love that moves the universe, Dante's l'amor che muove il sole e l’altre stele. But the fact is that while the rest of the universe moves freely and gracefully in cosmic harmony, we humans don't. It costs us an effort to attune ourselves to the dynamic order of love. At some point it even costs the supreme effort of, yes, making no effort. The obstacle which we must overcome is attachment, even the attachment to our own effort. Asceticism is the professional approach to overcoming attachment in all its forms. Our image of the dance should help us understand it. Detachment, which is merely its negative aspect, frees our movements, helps make us nimble. The positive aspect of asceticism is alertness, wakefulness, aliveness. As we become free to move, we begin to learn the steps; to listen to the music, listen and respond.
Asceticism (in its negative-aspect) may thus be understood as training in detachment for the sake of being in tune with universal harmony (the positive goal). But if this harmony is to be truly universal, it must encompass all of reality. If contemplation aims at "bringing the two temples together," all of reality must become transparent to its innermost luminous structure, and ultimate order must find its expression in space and in time. Asceticism must, therefore, cultivate its own environment, as well as its awareness of space and time, as a form of obedience to the environment as guru.
If I understand it correctly, the word guru means "dispeller of darkness." Not in the sense that there is something light and good, and something bad and dark. No, reality is not split in two. Let us understand dispelling of darkness in its symbolic sense as the dispelling of confusion. If it is the guru's function to dispel confusion - beginning with the confusion that there are two parts to reality - the result will be order. Only let us keep in mind that it is the dynamic order of life and love, the mysterious order of the great dance. The various traditions have developed a great variety of forms for learning to put one's life in order - into such order. Prominent among these forms is what we might call an environmental asceticism of space and time.
Both in our tradition and in others, asceticism of space, the training in detachment as it relates to any given place, centers on learning to be present where we are. This is the first step: and how often do we fail in it! We are ahead of ourselves or are hanging behind. Part of us is stretching out to a future that is not yet, part is hanging on to a past that is no more. What is left of us is not truly present either. We are here and not here, because we are not awake. To be present where we are means to wake up to this place.
In the Judeo-Christian tradition a classical locus for insights regarding the asceticism of space is the spiritual exegesis of the scene in which Moses confronts the Burning Bush. The voice out of the Bush calls to him, "Take off your shoes! This is holy ground." To take off one's shoes - this is the asceticism of space. To take off one's shoes means being truly there, fully alive. The shoes or sandals we take off are made from the skin of dead animals. As long as we wear them, there is something dead between the live soles of our feet and the ground on which we are standing. To take off this deadness means taking off that familiarity which breeds contempt and boredom: it means coming alive in primordial freshness to the place where we are.
Any place is
sacred ground,
for it can become a place of
encounter
with the divine Presence.
At first it is a specific place, the sacred precinct, which we enter barefoot. But then comes the next step, the decisive one: you come to realize that wherever you take off your shoes, you stand on holy ground. "All around in every direction: Holy of Holies" (Ez. 45:1), a passage Father Damasus never tired of quoting to his monks. All you have to do is to "take off your shoes" and you will realize this. In the Benedictine tradition this insight determines the attitude required toward every detail of the environment. The Rule of St. Benedict is concise to the point of being abrupt, yet it devotes an amazing number of passages to the various parts of the environment: the architectural layout, the use of tools, the food and clothing of the monks, the furnishings of the monastery. The final proof comes when St. Benedict says that every pot and pan in the monastery should be treated like the sacred vessels of the altar. This means: Take off your shoes and recognize that you are standing on sacred ground; this whole place is a temple.
Any place is sacred ground, because it is, potentially, a place of confrontation – confrontation with the divine Presence. As soon as we take off the shoes of "being used to it" and come alive, we realize: "If not here, where? When, if not now?" Nowhere if not now/ here, we are confronted with Ultimate Reality. "In the fields or on a journey, in whatever place the monks may find themselves when it is time to pray, let them reverently bend their knees then and there," enjoins the Holy Rule. And thus the asceticism of place opens up toward the asceticism of time. To the here, the holy ground, belongs the now, the Kairos, the holy moment, the acceptable time, the today of which we sing in the liturgy over and over again. "Today, when you hear his voice, harden not your hearts" – a decisive passage. And this today is always.
Time is something entirely different in the monastic context from that which a chronometer could measure. Time is not ours. When T. S. Eliot says, "Time, not our time," he points toward true detachment from time. We claim to have time, gain time, save time; in reality time does not belong to us. It is measured not by the clock, but by when it is time. That is why bells are so important in a monastery.
Time is not
clock-time,
but opportunity to wake
up
to the timeless now.
Bells are a great help in getting monks out of bed early. No one will deny the importance of that. But the really important thing is that in a monastery we do things not when we feel like it, but when it is time. When the bell rings, St. Benedict wants the monk to put down his pen without crossing his "t" or dotting his "i". Such is the asceticism of time.
There are occasions when it is time for something, whether you like it or not. And if you come only five minutes late, the sun is not going to re-rise for you; it is not going to re-set for you; and noon is not going to come a little later because you turned the clock back. Those are decisive moments, around which the whole monastic day revolves - moments that the bell indicates, not just the arbitrary time of some timetable someone has made up. Let all these bells which you will hear ringing remind you that it is time, not our time.
The moment we let go of our time, all time is ours. We are beyond time, because we are in the present moment, in the now which transcends time. The now is not in the time. If any of us know what now means we know something that goes beyond time. For certainly the future is not, it has not yet come; and certainly the past is not, it is no more. So we say, "Well, but now is." But, when is the now? Is it in time? How long does this now last? Assign the shortest span of time to the now - you can still divide it in half: one half for the future, one half for the past. Is the dividing line then the now? As long as it remains a span of time, you can divide it again and again, ad infinitum. And so we find that in time there is only the seam between a past that is no more and a future that is not yet; and the now is not in time at all. Now is beyond time. And we humans are the only ones who know what now means, because we exist, we "stick out" of time. That's what it means to exist. And all those monastic bells are simply reminders for us: now! - and that's all.
To get through this asceticism of space and time from confusion to order, to harmony of darkness and light that's what we try to do at the monastery. Of course, we cannot claim to have accomplished it. To quote Eliot again:
For most of us,
this is the aim
Never here to be realized;
Who are only undefeated
Because we have gone on trying....
The Dry Salvages, V
For us, there is
only the trying. The rest is Not our business.
East Coker, V
We are trying to enter into that asceticism of space and time, to open ourselves to the environment as the dispeller of darkness, i.e., confusion, thereby finding peace.
Our Latin tradition defines peace as tranquillitas ordinis, the stillness of order. Order is inseparable from silence, but this is a dynamic silence. The tranquillity of order is a dynamic tranquillity, the stillness of a flame burning in perfect calm, of a wheel spinning so fast that it seems to stand still. Silence in this sense is not only a quality of the environment, but primarily an attitude, an attitude of listening. This is a gift that each of us is invited to give all others: the gift of silence. Let us, then, give one another silence. And let us begin right now.
Let us give to one another that gift of silence, so that we can listen together and listen to one another. Only in this silence will we be able to hear that gentle breath of peace, that music to which the spheres dance, that universal harmony to which we, too, hope to dance.