ARTICLES Faith and Reason:  SUMMARY
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy 4   5 

By Fr. James Fannan, PIME    

Map

   New Age Philosophy

We now turn to a school of thought which is so recent that there is still a somewhat confused concept in the minds of many of what it really is. This is also because, like existentialism which contains diverse views on such basic matters as the existence of God, this philosophy is diverse and not uniform. It is the called the "New Age" philosophy, and it has gained a certain popularity with the general public. There is no one proponent of this school of thought, but its influence is far reaching. Its success is symptomatic of much of contemporary philosophy; it no longer follows the strict logic of Aristotle, and it does not address itself only to intellectuals. It is popular with the general public who pick and choose as they please and do nor require a carefully constructed, logical presentation. In one sense, it is a return to the ancient idea of philosophy as being the supreme unifying wisdom for practical real life. It brings in elements from science, psychology, ecology, the history of religions, and philosophy for a comprehensive world vision.

A good overview of New Age thought is found in a book by the Pontifical Council for Culture and Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue. The name of the book is Jesus Christ, the Bearer of the Water of Life: A Christian Reflection on the "New Age." New Age theory actually claims to revive the philsophia perennis (the philosophy that flows through history as the perennial philosophy). Ironically, when Catholic papal teaching says that seminarians should be formed in philosophy, it also speaks of the philosphia perennis. Obviously, in the context of the Church, there is a reference to the great philosophers of the past, and in particular, as we have seen, St. Thomas Aquinas.

The New Age fills a cultural vacuum, especially in the developed world, for those who have no Christian faith or who have no real intellectual understanding of their Christian faith. New Age seeks wisdom in pre-Christian thought forms and proposes itself as an alternative to the God of Biblical revelation. Today, God is too often seen as the One who holds people responsible for their actions and is therefore perceived more as a threat to our autonomy rather than a savior. As we have seen, after the French Revolution and the Napoleonic conquests, an anti-Catholic sentiment was aggressively spread in many places, especially through the Masonic lodges. Occult (magic) practices were introduced in these circles as means of gaining success. As long as Europe was still mostly factory workers and farmers, the ordinary citizens were not so exposed to these esoteric theories. Modern society, however, has produced a large number of people who are educated, but not schooled in critical thinking or religious studies; these provide an ample field for New Age penetration.

New Age thinking sees the universe as an organic whole which is filled with a kind of energy which some would call a Soul or a Spirit. New Age thus tends to Pantheism (everything is divine) or Panentheism (the divine force animates everything like a soul in a body). This opens New Age thinking to an ecological perspective that is more a spiritual relationship rather than pragmatic care for the planet on which we live. At times the earth is seen as the divine feminine Gaia. In New Age thought, there are enlightened masters or gurus that act as guides to people who wish to rise to a higher level and control their own lives. This last point is of importance. At the dawn of Christianity, an important rival was Stoic philosophy, which also saw the world as unified and marching towards a final perfect unification in a universal fiery conflagration. Fire was the divine energy for the Stoics, but for modern people, New Age thinking is a more attractive alternative. Stoicism encouraged all who were wise to submit to the Supreme Wisdom that guided all things. New Age thinking is much more attractive because it tells people that they themselves can by their own energies achieve a new perfection and self-realization. All they need is to be taught. New Age sees individuals as being somehow part of this greater divine One and thus it is opposed to all forms of "dualism" such as that which is found in Creator and creature. Clearly prayer is no longer a dialogue with the divine Other who is Savior and Creator; prayer is seen as penetrating deeper down to the level of the true self which is somehow divine.

For this reason, it also has a link with ancient Gnosticism, which appears to be a very ancient fusion of Babylonian and Persian thought going back at least five centuries before Christ. The Pope John Paul II took note of this Gnostic trend in contemporary thought and saw St. Paul as speaking of Gnosticism, when he wrote, "See to it that no one takes you captive through philosophy and empty deceit, according to human tradition, according to the elemental spirits of the universe and not according to Christ"(Col 2:8). And the Pope adds that, "the Apostle's words seem all too pertinent now if we apply them to the various kinds of esoteric superstition widespread today, even among too many believers who lack proper critical sense" (N. 37).

There is abundant historical evidence that soon after the appearance of Christianity, Christianity itself was quickly infiltrated by Gnosticism which took on a Greek vocabulary. The basic idea we see in the vast amount of literature it produced, including a number of apocryphal gospels and epistles, is that human beings can save themselves by secret knowledge and the recitation of sacred sounds and formulas (mantras). Knowledge is thus the means of personal salvation. Thousands of these magic tablets have been excavated in Syria and Iraq. All of this stands in clear opposition to Christian faith. Although God is everywhere in the universe, he is not present as a soul in a body. As the Catholic Catechism explains, he is the God who gives existence as the First Cause. He is not a soul of the world. It is God who saves humanity by his intervention in our lives and by his invitation to enter into a covenant relationship with humanity. He saves us; we cannot save ourselves by our own efforts. This relationship between the human and the divine runs against the basic tendency of New Age thought towards pantheism or panentheism. They therefore denounce the classic Christian approach as "dualism," which for them is a totally erroneous view of reality.

In the 1970’s a book was published called Jonathan Livingston Seagull. It was an immensely popular book that sold over a million copies in 2 years and was even used in religion classes by some. Its basic idea was that the perfection that lies dormant in each of us that must be awakened by a guide who leads us to achieve unimaginable potentials by our own power. The fact that the book was used even in catechesis shows how subtle the New Age approach is in its ability to infiltrate even ecclesiastical confines. Their whole notion of salvation is a self-help exercise by anyone who now knows how to overcome the limitations of the past. Here there is no saving God who compassionately comes to our aid. Many readers failed to really understand how completely different this message was from the Christian view.

Although New Age thought accepts the notion of karma from Indian thought, it transforms it into a gentler version. For them, karma does not involve any future retribution for our misdeeds in a future reincarnation. Karma is seen more in the sense of ignorance rather than moral evil, and bad karma merely delays our advancement on the way to perfection. An important figure in the growth of the New Age thought is a woman who claimed to be a medium or guide through her mystical communication with some of the great thinkers of the past. Her name was Helena Blavatsky (d. 1891). She was a co-founder of the Theosophical Society in New York in 1875. She combined Hindu and Buddhist elements in her theories and actually lived in India for a period where a center was established before she left due to poor health. In New Age philosophy, the goal is not a union of love with our Creator, instead there is a search for power and mastery.

 

The New Age philosophy also tries to integrate science into its synthesis. Pope John Paul II had complained in his Crossing the Threshold of Hope that modern philosophy was intolerant of the God of existence found in St. Thomas Aquinas. If any God is tolerated, he said, it is the god of the deists, the great designer of the universe who then leaves the cosmos to autonomously follow the laws of nature. For those infected with deism, the miracles of the Bible are simple inventions because according to their viewpoint, the god of the deists cannot intervene in creation. Ultimately, this also would exclude a real incarnation of God. This thought pattern of the deists was present even among Christians when Charles Darwin (d. 1882) wrote his Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (1859). There he stated that our various modern species of animals were the result of natural selection in which those fittest for survival gradually replaced the former species. Any role for God in this process is excluded by the deist viewpoint. For a Catholic, the God of existence is involved in every creature and at every moment of time, and God rules history by his providence.

Darwin did not at first claim that life simply appeared from lifeless matter, but this would be the mindset of many of those who looked to him for inspiration in later years. Such a vision is clearly deist, if not atheist, and it has serious problems. Darwin knew nothing about genetics, and it was genetics that held the key to the whole discussion. Interestingly, it was an Augustinian Monk, Gregor Mendel (d. 1884), who made the pioneering discoveries in the area of genetics that are necessary for understanding the possibility of change in a given hereditary line. He was a contemporary of Darwin and disagreed with Darwin’s conclusions. Perhaps for this reason, his work was ignored for many years, and even today his name is rarely mentioned. Nevertheless, it was the work of Mendel that led to our modern understanding of DNA. Darwin knew nothing of DNA.

Today the initials DNA are something we find mentioned frequently in newspapers, though most do not know what exactly it is. What DNA reveals is that each cell of a living being contains an amazingly complex chemical code. The idea that such a complex code could arise by chance is absurd. It would be like believing that an encyclopedia had been written by just randomly hitting the keys of a computer. This simple fact led one of the major advocates of atheism in the past, Professor Anthony Flew, to completely change his opinion and abandon atheism. This, by the way, caused outrage among the atheists and a public debate arose in the media. Interestingly, the logic of theists regarding DNA is very similar to that of Cicero who argued for the existence of the divine ordering of nature before the advent of Christianity. He said that believing that order of the world was by chance is like thinking you could throw the letters of the epic Aeneid in the air and expect them by chance to spell out the epic poem on the ground. This, by the way, is another example of the principle of sufficient reason. Today it is referred to as the argument of intelligent design in this context. Although modern Darwinism might seem to have nothing to do with New Age, in fact it eliminates (they feel) the need for the active intervention of a Creator in the history of creation, which would be dualistic.

 

  The Catholic Aspect of New Age Philosophy

The most influential western philosopher that is quoted in the New Age circles is oddly a Catholic priest, Teilhard de Chardin, SJ (d. 1955). He was really trained primarily as a scientist in the field of paleontology, but like all priests, he also did his philosophical studies, and so he was able to give a vision that tried to respond to the scientific and philosophical questions raised by Darwinism. Indeed, Darwinism was a key factor in his thought; already as a seminarian he became convinced of Darwinism and spent his life pursuing this vision in both a practical and theoretical way. One of the big problems of Darwinism was the search for the "missing link." If people are really descended from apes, then, according to Darwin’s thinking, there should be examples of skeletons showing this gradual transformation. In fact, there are none that conclusively establish the link. Though the anxious search has been going on for more than one hundred years, the examples of anything like a precise "link" are still missing.

In 1912, Teilhard had the misfortune to participate in an excavation which "discovered" a famous skull that was supposed to be such a missing link. This skull, called the Piltdown Man, was much later discovered to be a fraud that had been placed at the excavation by unknown hands. It was a carefully constructed skull made of human and ape parts to deceive the public. There is no reason to believe that Teilhard knew it at the time. Although there were some skeptics in the scientific world, in general there was a stampede to publicize the discovery of the long awaited missing link. Hundreds of copies were made to be sent around the world to various museums. The fraud lasted 40 years, and this was long enough to make many believe that the theory of evolution had been finally proven in the case of humans. The fact that it was revealed to be a fraud came too late in the debate to change the minds of committed Darwinians. The embarrassing setback was simply swept under the carpet in the collective memory.

Teilhard’s zeal for evolution involved him in a second scientific fiasco, the discovery of the Peking "man." This was finally judged to be a Chinese ape and was in no way a homo sapiens (true human). The Catholic Church, moreover, has always maintained that as far as humans are concerned, the theory of evolution is precisely a theory, and in any event, the spiritual soul of man requires a special creation by God every time a person is conceived since humans have a spiritual (immaterial) soul that cannot arise from matter or any lower form of life. Pope Pius XII summed up the Church’s position on some of the cardinal points of New Age thinking in a few words in his encyclical Humani Generis when he condemned those who "audaciously support monistic and pantheistic opinion that the world is in continual evolution" (N. 5). Pope John Paul II confirmed in 1996 another statement of Humani Generis about the problem of evolution. In his Message to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences on Evolution (October 22, 1996), he stated that in regard to the problem of the evolution of human beings, the Church maintains that in any event: "the spiritual soul is created directly by God" (N. 5). This is another application of the principle of sufficient reason. Matter cannot produce a rational soul by its material nature, and thus every soul of every person is directly created by God.

It is precisely as a Catholic priest who had studied philosophy that Teilhard was able to try to respond to Catholic objections based on the principle of sufficient reason for the appearance of human life when he claimed that even rocks and minerals possess a small, immeasurable level of consciousness, a "spark of spirit." Of course, there is no scientific evidence for this, but logically Teilhard had to affirm this as a prerequisite for the evolution of man. This is because in the light of philosophy since Socrates, Teilhard knew that mere matter was not a sufficient reason for the spiritual qualities of man. He believed moreover that as the universe marches on in time, more and more complex structures will continue to be formed in this consciousness which has already reached the human level. He believed that there was an inherent compulsion in consciousness to rise towards the Omega point of unity. This vaguely Hegelian notion was enthusiastically received by atheists like Sir Julian Huxley who published the (condemned) works of Chardin after his death.

The theories of Teilhard on these matters had been condemned by the Church at many levels, starting with his own Jesuit superiors. The Vatican forbade him to teach at Paris as early as 1933. Most importantly, the Vatican condemned his theories on June 30,1962 with a "monitum" (warning) entitled: Warning Regarding the writings of Father Teilhard de Chardin. The warning was a wide-reaching directive which exhorted "all Ordinaries as well as superiors of Religious institutes, rectors of seminaries and presidents of universities effectively to protect the minds, particularly of the youth, against the dangers presented by the works of Teilhard de Chardin and of his followers." As often happens in cases like this, at some stage or other, the claim is made the original condemnation is no longer in force and so it is no longer necessary to obey. That is why on July 20, 1981 the Vatican repeated its earlier condemnation in a simple press communiqué.

Nevertheless, Teilhard’s writings remain as an attractive presentation for those who are oriented to New Age thought. He sees the world necessarily evolving towards a final stage which he calls the Omega Point. This vision has many resonances with Hegel’s philosophy and earlier Neo-Platonic thought. It opens the door to the immanentism (which rejects providence) that Pope John Paul sees as characteristic of philosophy after Descartes. Even modern psychology has played an important contributing role in the formation of New Age theories. Carl Jung (d. 1961) is renowned in the development of psychological theories about humanity. He postulated the existence (along rather Platonic lines) of a "collective consciousness" in which each person has his individual place. This is another example of how New Age thought unifies diverse areas of human thought around a few guiding principles.

The connection of Teilhard with New Age thinking shows how very much we are in a global village where Eastern and Western traditions can be blended in a way that in this case is more poetic than strictly logical. As was said earlier, contemporary philosophy has lost the idea of what abstract thinking is. It is the kind of thinking that Socrates took note of, the kind of thinking that makes it possible to discuss deep ethical questions. Also in the case of Teilhard, one can ask how even the "consciousness" he finds in animals could manifest itself in the abstract thinking that is characteristic only of humans. This is just one of the reasons why the Vatican mentioned "ambiguities" and "errors" in his thought. Nevertheless, the judgment of the "world" is otherwise, for Teilhard has gained his monument in the spiritual room of the United Nations in New York and is looked to by many New Age devotees as one of their inspirations.

   Inculturation

Our study of New Age thinking marks the first time in our study that we have found it necessary to go any further east of Europe than Iran. As with Alexander the Great, the Indus remained a barrier. In his encyclical Fides et Ratio, Pope John Paul II took the unusual step of speaking specifically of one country, in this case, India, in number 72 of the encyclical. He stressed that according to the teaching of Vatican II, the work of inculturating the faith must continue also in India. However, he also stressed that this had to be done in such a way that it integrates new insights into what already exists as a result of the inculturation of Christianity into the Greco-Roman world. In other words, it is a question of one theology based on a perennial philosophy (faith and reason) which is open to further elaboration. It is not a question of two contradictory theologies. Any valid insight is valid for Christians everywhere. He stated his position in this way, "care will need to be taken lest, contrary to the very nature of the human spirit, the legitimate defense of the uniqueness and originality of Indian thought be confused with the idea that a particular cultural tradition should remain closed in its difference and affirm itself by opposing other traditions."

The Pope in the context of inculturation also warns those who "prompted by a mistaken notion of cultural pluralism simply deny the universal value of the Church’s philosophical heritage," and he adds that "the specific contribution of philosophical enquiry enables us to discern in different world-views and different cultures; ‘not what people think, but what the objective truth is.’ It is not an array of human opinions but truth alone which can be of help to theology" (N. 69). It is noteworthy here that even in this context the Pope found it useful to quote directly a phrase from St. Thomas. In a positive way the Pope says that, "the message which believers bring to the world and to cultures is a genuine liberation from all the disorders caused by sin and is, at the same time, a call to the fullness of truth. Cultures are not only not diminished by this encounter; rather, they are prompted to open themselves to the newness of the Gospel’s truth …."(N. 71).

Just how difficult the work of inculturation is, can be seen from the history of philosophy we have studied in the previous pages. How many ideas had to be rejected! How many had to be subjected to major surgery to form part of the perennial philosophy that the Church finds amenable to theological progress. The same problems exist in inculturation today. Fr. Anthony De Mello, SJ (d. 1987) is worthy of consideration here because his work is an example of the problems in this area. De Mello apparently never understood or else rejected the use of analogies in speaking about God. We already mentioned how the only work of Aristotle that was used in Western Europe before the Crusades was the Logic of Aristotle. Their study of the use of words fine tuned their discussion about God.

Neo-Platonic thought said that we could speak of God exclusively in negative terms. Hence God is invisible, immortal, untouchable, etc. The consensus in the West was summed up by St. Thomas. He said that we can speak positively about God by analogies or comparisons in which the absolute perfection of God is mirrored in creation (cf. Rom 1:18-31). Thus a created and therefore limited reality is found in God in a higher and different way, but the excellence of that reality itself is truly found both in the creature and the Creator in an analogous way. Thus, we say that God is Love in the Bible, and Jesus also tells us to love one another as he has loved us. Although this virtue exists only in God in a perfect way, the imperfect reflection in creation is sufficient to give us a true concept which we can attribute to God by using an analogy. Thus, in the Bible, human language can be used to say that God is good, wise, loving, a father, etc. Commenting on this aspect of knowledge, Pope John Paul II writes, "I want only to state that reality and truth do transcend the factual and the empirical and to vindicate the human being’s capacity to know the transcendent and metaphysical dimension in a way that is true and certain, albeit imperfect and analogical" (N. 83).

De Mello denied this without ever really engaging in a serious discussion of the matter. The logical conclusion of his thought is that we cannot speak of God in a true way and hence the Bible cannot really tell us about God since it is all based on merely human concepts. De Mello, following his own logic on words, even calls the Bible "an idol." Needless to say, on June 24, 1998, his views were finally condemned by the Church (Notification Concerning the Writings of Father Anthony De Mello, SJ). Besides his statement on the Bible, various other opinion were mentioned, especially a theory he had that is like that found in the New Age movement, i.e. the idea that Jesus is just one of many enlightened gurus as opposed to being the unique incarnate Son of God. The Vatican’s general comment on his writings is that he seems to have a concept of spirituality that is more Taoist and Buddhist than Christian.

   Conclusion

Particularly the section on the New Age philosophy brings to mind a biblical quote that seems terribly apt for this context of New Age thinking. It speaks of a world view that is one of the fruits of these last few centuries of human thought which has turned with hostility and contempt away from the Church’s teaching: "the time will come when people will not tolerate sound doctrine, but following their own desires and with itching ears will accumulate teachers and will stop listening to the truth and will be diverted to myths" (2 Tm 3 :3-4). As a remedy to this, St. Paul advised Timothy (and us) to "convince, reprimand, encourage through all patience and teaching" (2 Tm 2:2). This is precisely what both John Paul II and Benedict XVI have been doing over these past decades, and hopefully in some small way this article will help all those who are eager to know the truth which is the sole goal of faith and reason. I would like to close with a quote that Pope John Paul II saw as relevant to the theme of his encyclical and to our times. It is a quote of St. Bonaventure who invited his readers to recognize the inadequacy of: "reading without repentance, knowledge without devotion, research without the impulse of wonder, prudence without the ability to surrender to joy, action divorced from religion, learning sundered from love, intelligence without humility, study unsustained by divine grace, thought without the wisdom inspired by God" (N. 105).