By Fr. James Fannan, PIME
Since European civilization was reconstructed amidst the ruins of the former Greco-Roman world, it was reconstructed with its foundations firmly in the Gospel, but this does not mean that the Gospel (faith) stands in contradiction with reason. In the area of ethics, humanity had been created in the image of God, and therefore it was capable discerning the right rule of conduct even in its fallen condition. This is because God never abandons his creatures but accompanies them always with his grace and guidance. As St. Peter said to Cornelius, "I see that God shows no partiality. Rather in every nation whoever fears him and acts uprightly is acceptable" (Acts 10:34-35). When St. Paul spoke of the judgment of God on the non-Christians in his letter to the Romans, he explained: "When Gentiles who do not have the law by nature observe the prescriptions of the law, they are a law for themselves even though they do not have the law. They show that the demands of the law are written in their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even defend them …"(Rom 2:14-15). This law that is "written" in human hearts is traditionally called the natural law. It is a concept that goes back to the dawn of Greek philosophy when the early philosophers realized that the universe was under the rule of law and was not chaotic. It is also an objective law, a law that sincere human intellects anywhere can attain.
The Catholic Catechism quotes the pre-Christian philosopher Cicero (d. 43 BC) who wrote: "For there is a true law: right reason. It is in conformity with nature, is diffused among all men and is immutable and eternal; its orders summon to duty; its prohibitions turn away from offense … to replace it with a contrary law is a sacrilege; failure to apply even one of its provisions is forbidden …" (N. 1956). This pattern of thinking reflects the original quest of Socrates for authentic virtue. It led to Plato’s discovery of a True, Good, and Beautiful stable reality which is the foundation of all reality. Finally it led Aristotle to write his great ethical works the Nichomachean Ethics and the Eudemian Ethics. Both Christian and non-Christian thinkers in the Apostolic age were convinced that there was an objective basis for law that could be understood by the sincere in contrast to the notion of Protagoras that "man is the measure of all things." We see here faith and good reason going hand in hand in the face of the bad philosophy of Protagoras.
Once the natural law is no longer recognized, each philosophy must necessarily seek some other basis whether it be one based on a sense of duty, likes or dislikes, the customs or laws of the country, etc. In short, without natural law, there is no real, fixed reality to which one can appeal in making moral decisions or laws. In his encyclical Fides et Ratio, Pope John Paul II observed: "once the idea of a universal truth about the good, knowable by human reason, is lost, inevitably the notion of conscience also changes. Conscience is no longer considered in its prime reality as an act of a person’s intelligence, the function of which is to apply the universal knowledge of the good in a specific situation and thus to express a judgment about the right conduct to be chosen here and now. Instead, there is a tendency to grant to the individual conscience the prerogative of independently determining the criteria of good and evil and then acting accordingly. Such an outlook is quite congenial to an individualist ethic" (N. 98). The Pope puts his teaching on morality in a positive way when he observes: "only true values can lead people to realize themselves fully, allowing them to be true to their nature. The truth of these values is to be found not by turning in on oneself but by opening oneself to apprehend that truth even at levels which transcend the person" (N. 25).
Earlier, we spoke of the role that divine voluntarism played in the role history of philosophy. By its claim that God can rule the world and morality in an unsteady and whimsical way, the whole basis for a philosophic ethics is destroyed. This idea ran against Christian tradition as we have seen it and instead prepared the way for various attempts to solve the problem of human conduct based on philosophies that denied that people can actually break out of their subjectivity and reach objective truth in matters of ethics. These solutions are many and varied and it is not necessary to examine them one by one. It is sufficient to see that in the moral debate around us, each person is always convinced that something is good or bad not because I like it or I do not like it. It is clear in the moral debate that each side faults the other, often with considerable annoyance, for not being reasonable about the objective situation under discussion. Right reason is therefore the goal of philosophy just as Cicero and the Church have maintained in their discussion of natural law.
On April 18, 2008, Pope Benedict XVI addressed the United Nations in the year in which the sixtieth anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is observed. In that discourse he summed up the whole Catholic concept of Natural Law which still held sway sixty years ago. He stated:
"It is evident, though, that the rights recognized and expounded in the Declaration apply to everyone by virtue of the common origin of the person, who remains the high-point of God’s creative design for the world and for history. They are based on the natural law inscribed on human hearts and present in different cultures and civilizations. Removing human rights from this context would mean restricting their range and yielding to a relativistic conception, according to which the meaning and interpretation of rights could vary and their universality would be denied in the name of different cultural, political, social and even religious outlooks …. Efforts need to be redoubled in the face of pressure to reinterpret the foundations of the Declaration and to compromise its inner unity so as to facilitate a move away from the protection of human dignity towards the satisfaction of simple interests, often particular interests …. The Universal Declaration, rather has reinforced the conviction that respect for human rights is principally rooted in unchanging justice on which the binding force of international proclamation is also based."
To say it very simply the Pope added: "Augustine of Hippo … taught that the saying: Do not do to others what you would not want done to you ‘cannot in any way vary according to the different understandings that have arisen in the world.’" Clearly, when someone denies the objective, universal source of natural law, law then becomes simply a matter of human decision makers, something anthropocentric and subjective. The Pope speaks out clearly against this: "Experience shows that legality often prevails over justice when the insistence upon rights makes them appear as the exclusive result of legislative enactments or normative decisions taken by various agencies of those in power. When presented purely in terms of legality, rights risk becoming weak propositions divorced from the ethical and rational dimension which is their foundation and their goal."