ARTICLES   Faith and Reason:  SUMMARY
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy  1 
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy 2

By Fr. James Fannan, PIME    

About this article

This article is written in a language and style which should make it accessible to the general public. However, in a particular way, it is the fruit of many years of teaching experience with seminarians. Many seminarians are so overwhelmed by their philosophical studies, that their studies’ connection with theology remains unclear at best. This article therefore aims at the ordinary reader or seminarian who wants to understand the basic relationship that philosophy has with theology. The fact that the Church requires seminarians to study philosophy before theology has a very practical motive, and this article should make clearer the fact that good theology presupposes good philosophy.

Because of this rather specific aim, many figures or themes in the history of philosophy are not even mentioned or are quickly passed over in this article. Other philosophers, instead, are treated at some length on just one aspect of their thought. The key aim of this article is to show the relationship between faith and reason. The aim, therefore, is not to present a shorter version of the history of philosophy, and this explains why certain things are studied in depth and others ignored.

In 1998, now more than ten years ago, His Holiness Pope John Paul II wrote an encyclical called Fides et Ratio (Faith and Reason). It is appropriate that a article like this be made available to that public which until now is perhaps not in a position to understand the precise importance of the encyclical. This article, however, is not precisely a comment or analysis of the encyclical itself. What this article does is indicate where the Pope’s thought is applicable in the development of philosophy. In this sense, this article opens up Fides et Ratio to that public which otherwise might not be able to understand precisely what the Pope was talking about in various parts of his encyclical.

Although this article is aimed, therefore, at those who are not professional academics, there are many insights that will be interesting for those who are involved in the teaching or study of philosophy, and so the book is truly aimed at a wide public.

Map

 

  Introduction

The classical definition of theology is "faith seeking understanding." This definition reflects the fact that the word of God must be enunciated in a human context by means of a world view within which reasoning goes on. This is the reason why both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI have underlined so strongly the need for attention to the aspect of faith and reason in our time. The fact that the Church requires the study of philosophy as part of training for the priesthood flows from the fact that priests, in their prophetic role as spokesmen for God, will be required to proclaim the truth of the Gospel in varied human contexts with varying world views. It is the job, therefore, of the priest to present the revelation of Jesus Christ, the unchanging Word of God, in a world of continuous change. This problem is so important that Pope John Paul II devoted a whole encyclical to it with the Latin title Fides et Ratio (Faith and Reason). In the following pages, by means of quotes from the Pope’s encyclical, the link between the history of philosophy and Catholic theology will be put into focus. I would like to begin with a quote from the encyclical in which the Pope quotes St. Augustine on this intimate unity between faith and reason in common sense terms: "To believe is nothing other than to think with assent … Believers are also thinkers: in believing, they think, and in thinking they believe … If there is no assent, there is no faith, for without assent one does not really believe" (N. 79).

We could compare faith and reason to two hands that, although they have developed on different arms of our body, are destined to a perfect complementarity – they harmonize when we raise them united in prayer. This is not to say, of course, that faith and reason can always reach independently the very same conclusions. What is does mean is that when theology is correctly made, it will be able to make use of philosophy and not find itself in contradiction with a true philosophy. In this union of faith with reason, "reason is offered guidance and is warned against paths which would lead it to stray from revealed Truth and stray in the end from the truth pure and simple. Instead, reason is stirred to explore paths which of itself it could not even have suspected it could take" (N. 73).

Turning to the question of faith, the Pope points out that natural faith is a necessary part of any life: "Who, for instance, could assess critically the countless scientific findings upon which modern life is based? Who could personally examine the flow of information which comes day after from all parts of the world and which is generally accepted as true?" (N. 31). If this is so in other areas of life, why should faith not be necessary in religion, especially when one is dealing with the Transcendent and not just ordinary every day matters? As far as the compatibility of faith and reason is concerned, the Pope points out that: "The unity of truth is a fundamental premise of human reasoning, as the principle of non-contradiction makes clear … It is the one and the same God who establishes and guarantees the intelligibility and reasonableness of the natural order of things upon which scientists confidently depend, and who reveals himself as the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ" (N. 34).

This presentation, therefore, is an attempt to assist students of philosophy to see this complementarity or harmony. Otherwise there is the risk that when students reach theology, the teachers may assume that the students already see the connections between reason and faith, and then these teachers may therefore feel that it is not necessary to articulate this connection. On the other hand, given the vastness of philosophical speculation, the professors of philosophy at times might limit themselves to simply presenting the immense quantity of data that exists without synthesizing those elements that point to the harmony between faith and reason. This would leave a serious gap in the knowledge needed for the proper study of theology. Therefore, we will make use of the data of philosophy to point out some key ideas and their role in theology.

Traditionally, Asia is regarded as the birthplace of the great religions because Palestine, Saudi Arabia, and India are in all Asia. By this same criterion, Asia can also be called the birthplace of "Western Philosophy" because it was born among the Greeks who lived along the coast of what is now Asian Turkey. In fact, there was a part of Turkey called "Asia," and the whole continent of Asia got its name from part of what is now Turkey! Western philosophy was born in those areas that St. Paul evangelized before he crossed over to Europe. Moreover, in our own times, because of the spread of Marxism, Islam, and Christianity, the primitive Greek philosophy of Turkey has become a global philosophy in the global village of humanity. Marxism, Islam, and Christianity have in fact all established their philosophical structures on those Greek foundations put down before the birth of Christ in what is now Turkey.

  Early Greek Philosophy

One of the aspects which we find in the early Greek philosophers is their conviction that in the changing world around them, there was some sort of stability that coexisted as a foundation for this change. Though the fundamental basis might be conceived by them as water, or air, etc., they were convinced that in the midst of change there was something stable and constant. Even change itself, they believed, was ruled by some sort of constant law that could be discovered by human reasoning. This conviction of theirs about an underlying law would be fruitful for the future development of science and particularly aided philosophy in a way that opened it for Christian theology and prepared a fertile ground for the early Church to evangelize the world.

The first thinker from this period that deserves our special attention is Parmenides (fifth cent. BC). He had a fundamental insight of great importance, and it is often found in its Latin version: "Ex nihilo, nihil fit." This means that from a total absence of being, no new being can arise: From nothing, nothing comes. He reduced the cosmos to the simplest term: a solid ball of matter. He then asked, where would any new matter come from? Where would any of the matter that is already there go? He reached the (wrong) conclusion that change must be an illusion, but he was correct in his basic insight that there must be some stable reality at the basis of our daily life; in other words, life was not simply change. A study of this period reveals that the philosophers of this era were looking for some stable foundation to the cosmos. Parmenides was already pointing to a basic distinction between two kinds of being – one which is permanent, the other of a secondary, transitory nature, which he described as "illusion."

Here it is important to note that at this point of time, no one had any idea of a Creator God who speaks and brings forth a world that arises from nothing. This will be the extraordinary contribution of the Jews. Creation from nothing is an idea that comes forth from Biblical revelation rather than a purely philosophical speculation. At this point, this pre-Christian thought simply assumed (without really questioning) that matter had always been there. However, looking at the changes around them, their question really regarded what the were the causes of the changes in matter, not where does matter come from. Since they had no idea of "spirit" beyond matter, they often assumed that in some mysterious way a kind of churning motion arose like we see in water going down a drain in the kitchen. It seems to the observer that it just happens spontaneously. This churning motion was evident in the apparent movement of the sun, moon, and stars around the earth. The insight of Parmenides that "from nothing, nothing comes" remained fundamental and would often lead future thinkers to put some stable material element in their theories without however denying the reality of change.

Parmenides had therefore correctly pointed out that something new cannot come into existence all by itself or spontaneously. He was not denying the possibility of a spiritual creator God – this idea was not even imagined then. What was clear to him was that a new reality cannot appear spontaneously. Ultimately, he was showing, without himself realizing it, that the change we see around us is not illusion; it is rather caused by a stable spiritual being whom we call God, and it is this creator God who brings into existence from nothing the new realities that appear in the flow if time. Who of us can go back in time? Who can jump from now till next year in an instant? It is the Creator God who continually makes all things new as he brings into existence what did not exist before and what we see as our present world where the past is only a memory. The Christian God is the God who creates reality in the flow of time by giving a creation that is continually renewed by the God of Existence. Truly change cannot arise by itself or just spontaneously.

The next significant step towards a Christian view of philosophy comes from Anaxagoras (d. 428 BC). It is not exactly clear what he meant by the word "Nous" (mind), but this theory of Anaxagoras gave Socrates (d. 399 BC) what he needed to clearly expound on the activity of spirit in the material world. Anaxagoras spoke of Nous as initiating the churning motion of the cosmos. Socrates developed the idea along the lines that would lead to Plato (d. 347 BC) and Aristotle (d. 322 BC) to describe man as a spiritual form united with matter. In this new view of things, God, the unmoved mover and fountain of change can be seen as a spiritual reality and cause. This was an important step beyond Parmenides. It is important for us today to understand the context of this development.

Philosophy, which begins as Philo-sophia (love of wisdom) was not the same study then as it is today. It was basically all there was to know about everything. Much of it would be seen today as primitive science seeking an explanation for ordered change. We find therefore the terms like "atom" which was later borrowed by the scientists. We even find the idea that life somehow evolved from sea animals (Anaximander d. 546 BC) as well as many other "modern" theories. Thus, for a long time philosophy and science were one. Indeed, the philosopher Aristotle was regarded by most people as the greatest scientist before the development of modern experimental science around 1,500 AD.

The first efforts of the philosophers therefore really were concerned with cosmology, i.e. the origin and nature of our universe. However as time passed and prosperity and commerce increased, more and more teachers were employed. It was then that the center of attention shifted to more practical matters such as public speaking (useful in politics, negotiations, and court cases). These teachers were known as sophists (from Sofia, i.e. wisdom). Unfortunately public speaking can involve learning techniques of defending and promoting the personal goals of the speaker whether they are good or bad, true or false. It can lead to learning how to deceive others with clever arguments. Learning then is no longer seen as a simple search for the truth. This clearly would prepare the ground for the use of reason to oppose the truth and remains an ever present danger to true philosophy and theology.

The other aspect of this period was a skeptical attitude towards any "truth" whatsoever. The Greeks in particular were seafarers and had spread themselves from southern France all the way to southern Russia. They became aware that there were many different gods, mythologies, beliefs and customs that were irreconcilable. Education thus could often lead to a student doubting everything about the beliefs that had been handed down in his local tradition of his parents.

This kind of skepticism has many examples in the philosophers leading up to Socrates, and it helps to explain how a simple philosopher like Socrates was condemned to death for "corrupting the youth" and teaching what the Athenians regarded as "heresy." The irony is that Socrates was actually trying to find firm foundations for the truth precisely to combat the skepticism and relativism which he saw as a growing threat to Greek civilization. When the study of philosophy becomes merely a tour of various opinions rather than a journey to the truth, it becomes a mere curiosity, a kind of hobby, rather than a truly life fulfilling study. That was the problem at that time and even in our own times.

In those days, this flood of ideas produced confusion rather than providing the youth of Greece with a solid grasp of basic truths. Even today philosophy, when it fails to find the truth, is often seen as impractical and leading to nothing. Some years ago, when I told someone I was teaching philosophy, he answered scornfully that I should teach something useful. At the time Marxism was still in its glory, dominating the world from East Germany all the way to Vietnam, with a various degrees of Marxism elsewhere. It was easy therefore to reply that it was due to that philosophy that so many people were living in misery, so philosophy certainly had a practical impact in the world as any theory leads to praxis (practical results). In the case of Marxism, its errors therefore led to impractical and even tragic results, and hundreds of millions died or lived in misery because of it.

On the other hand, in places like America today, philosophy is often not even studied because it is often taught as a brief tour of curious opinions with no clue as to where the truth is to be found. It is precisely this situation that has led various popes over the centuries to insist that the correct study of philosophy can lead to the truth if it is undertaken carefully. Then it creates a cultural context in which Catholic faith can readily be integrated. Hence, the true faith seeks a clearer understanding by means of a true philosophy. This is the idea behind Fides et Ratio of John Paul II who basically develops the line of Papal teaching extending over the centuries.

Thus there are similarities between our own times of confusion and the time of Socrates. Socrates felt that the relativism of his time was best illustrated by Protagoras (d. 410 BC). Protagoras in our own times has many disciples though they may have never heard of him. Protagoras believed that each individual had his own "truth" (opinion) which was just as good as that of anyone else. Today the Popes refer to this kind of thinking as subjectivism and relativism. The Popes see this as a major threat to reaching genuine objective truth, i.e. the reason that harmonizes with faith. Protagoras coined the phrase "Man is the measure of all things" to express his thought. Socrates saw the danger that this presented to the youth of his time and made it his goal to defend the existence of objective truths. This was especially necessary in the area of virtuous human behavior so that the nation would be strong and stable.

  Plato and Aristotle

Socrates had a famous disciple, Plato, who tried to spread the doctrine of Socrates after his death. Plato did this through a popular method. He wrote imaginary conversations between Socrates and his questioners. These were based on the time he had spent with Socrates. These talks were called dialogues. In the dialogues, Socrates takes the basic insight of the cosmology of the Greeks (the constant stable basis that underlies the world of change) to an ethical level. He believed that there were unchanging stable moral truths that should direct human behavior. Plato’s dialogues were a huge success and most of them have survived to our own time unlike most of the philosophy of those days. This in itself is a proof of their value. They were in a relatively simple language and dealt with topics of interest to anyone who wants to act in a reasonable and virtuous way.

As time went on, Plato tried to describe this constant basis for ethics as the constant basis for all things. He regularly referred to this spiritual basis as the "world of ideas." He believed there must be a spiritual stable foundation to our world of change. It was a union of goodness, truth and beauty which he even referred to as a "father." When we read Plato, we can understand why St. Paul could write to the Romans that the existence of God was something that was knowable to the sincere efforts of any reasonable man. People like Plato showed that God could be discovered by the sincere lover of wisdom. Here is how St. Paul expressed it in his letter to the Romans: "For what can be known about God is evident to them … his invisible attributes of eternal power and divinity have been able to be understood and perceived in what he has made" (Rom 1:19-20).

It is no accident, therefore, that Plato became the main philosopher whose insights were used both in both the Western and Eastern Catholic Church. Due to the theological synthesis of St. Augustine, Platonic thought became the dominant thought in Catholic theology in the countries where the Latin heritage prevailed (Western Europe and Western North Africa). Plato had basically discovered the ultimate spiritual being whom Catholics recognized as God. He was eternal and unchangeable, uniting the stability of Parmenides with the fount of virtue found in Socrates. An important question to be solved was the exact relation of the stable God to the changing world. Plato saw the stable "world of ideas" as a model and somehow a font for our world, but he could not give a satisfactory answer as to how the reality of the world was produced by this eternal reality that we recognize as God. Plato still knew nothing of the Christian God who is Unlimited Existence itself. It was St. Thomas Aquinas who would enrich Western philosophy with a careful analysis of God as Unlimited Existence. As we shall see later, Pope John Paul II sees this insight as key to a philosophy that truly harmonizes with our Catholic faith.

Aristotle at his time attempted to solve this problem of the relation of God to the world in a more satisfactory way. We have already seen that the ancient Greeks regarded matter as eternal. Thus there was no effort to look for a creator God. As Parmenides had already stated: Ex nihilo, nihil fit (from nothing, nothing comes). It was assumed, therefore, that matter had always existed and that the changes in the material world pointed to a stable spiritual reality that didn’t change in itself. It was the spiritual reality, though, that was the font of change in the material world. This is why Aristotle described God as the "unmoved mover" – the spiritual one who moves without changing in himself. There was a problem though; in the normal interaction between things, the one who moves is also affected by moving the object. Thus we get tired if we have to push a car. How would this apply to the Unmoved Mover (God)?

Aristotle found a clever solution to this problem, though his answer would still not be satisfactory to later Catholic theology. He said that this beautiful God is not the only spiritual being. There are other spiritual beings that are captivated by the beauty of the Supreme Stable Reality (God), and it is their reaction to the divine beauty that sets up the churning motion that gives rise to the world as we know it: the world at the center of the revolving sun, moon, stars, etc. This solution was clever because it allowed God to be stable, spiritual, and unchanging, and at the same time to be the final cause of change in the world. God is thus the unmoved mover. What Aristotle called "theology" (the study of God) was for him the highest point of his philosophy.

Now let us shift our attention from God to man. We have already seen that Anaxagoras had proposed the idea of a new kind of reality which is spirit. It is this spiritual reality that both Aristotle and Plato saw as the supreme reality. However, in a limited way, Aristotle and Plato also saw each person as spirit and matter. Here we should note that although Aristotle and Plato are both talking about things that are of great theological importance, they are also in a difficult position. It is important to recognize that Socrates was executed for his thinking as a kind of heretic in his pagan Greek culture. The Greek world had its own gods and goddesses, temples, and rituals. Other neighboring peoples had their own religions – all of which were different. It is therefore not surprising that these great thinkers steer clear of many theological questions that would be interesting to us but might have created problems with the authorities if a philosopher offended too many with his speculations. In any event, Plato and Aristotle were both convinced by their analysis that each person has a body and spiritual soul.

Plato believed, for his own reasons, that this soul existed before the body and that the time we spend in the body is actually not the ideal state for humans. In fact, although he did not advocate suicide, Plato saw death as a liberation of the immortal soul. It is easy to see how future generations of Christians would find much to praise in this stress on the nobility of the soul, but it also had its perplexing side for Christians who looked forward to the resurrection of the body. Various non-Christian thinkers both in the east and west have been led by their thinking to have a kind of contempt for the body, and so the idea of the resurrection of the body to them seemed to be useless and even negative.

This is the kind of audience that St. Paul had when he first proclaimed the resurrection to the philosophers at the Areopagus in Athens, which was the capital of philosophical thought in the Roman Empire (Acts 17:22-34). In spite of the negative aspects of many Greek philosophers, we can see, therefore, how early Christian writers, like St. Paul, made use of some of Greek thought, especially Plato, to expound Christian teaching in a way that made sense to their contemporaries: fides et ratio, faith and reason.

In his encyclical Fides et Ratio, Pope John Paul speaks of how some of the early Fathers of the Church saw this philosophical preparation for the Gospel as providential – something planned by God to prepare the way for Christianity We can compare it to the role of John the Baptist in preparing the Jews for Christ. The Pope cites the example of St. Clement of Alexandria (d. 215 AD), who compared the role of Greek philosophy for the Gentiles to the role of Moses for the Jews in preparing the way for Christ. In fact, we see that Greek thought already had a concept of the spiritual eternal soul in each human person. After death, the souls could enter into the joy of union with the Eternal Beauty. This is very much the line we see in St. Augustine (d. 430 AD). St. Clement of Alexandria is quoted by the Pope on the defensive role of philosophy, "in rendering the attack of sophistry impotent and in disarming those who betray truth and wage war upon it, Greek philosophy is rightly called the hedge and protective wall around the vineyard" (N. 38). It should be noted, however, that in the study of philosophy, one will encounter many other philosophical theories that have nothing in common with Christianity and are completely false. This makes it clear that "inculturation" in the Greco-Roman world of those days did not mean just taking any idea of any philosophy and trying to somehow make it Christian. This is also useful to remember in our modern context.

True inculturation means picking and choosing those elements which are true in a philosophical system and can be harmoniously blended in a synthesis that is both reasonable and open to further progress in the light of the data of divine revelation. In this way, it can be used in better understanding the truths of our faith. It is worth noting here that when Jesus Christ was born, both Plato and Aristotle had the status of giants in human thought. It was not the Church that made them important because they helped show the harmony of faith and reason. They already were recognized as important and had discovered important eternal truths about mankind and God. Their thinking is found as the foundation of what Church documents call a "perennial philosophy", i.e. a synthesis of concepts which have gradually developed over the centuries and blend in a harmonious way with the truths of faith.

  Plotinus

At this point we come to a temptation. Its creator is Plotinus (d. 270 AD); often he is not given much attention in the history of philosophy. In fact, his approach has had a profound influence on those who try to find some alternative to the Gospel. In truth, it would be necessary to say that his approach has many contemporary elements. Plotinus was actually a student of an ex-Christian, and he develops a philosophy that is clearly an alternative to Christianity. His philosophy is called Neo-Platonism. We have seen how the early Fathers of the Church found elements, especially in Plato, that were useful for expounding Christianity. As soon as Christianity appeared, there were new movements that mixed Christianity with other systems and provided tempting alternatives to Christian orthodoxy. The Gnostic heresies are one such temptation which is explained in the history of theology. Here we want to examine Plotinus who will also provide an alternative to Christian orthodoxy.

Plotinus came from Alexandria in Egypt which at this time was one of the chief, if not the chief center of Catholic theology. It had a long Jewish tradition, and the Jews there were fluent in Greek and quite familiar with Greek thought and culture. It was in this context that strong hints of the Trinity emerge in a highly philosophical language in the Old Testament in a book called the Book of Wisdom. Here, it should be noted that at the time of Christ, the Old Testament was regarded as an open-ended work. They were still waiting for the Messiah and whatever prophets God might send. After the Fall of Jerusalem, the situation of the Jews changes dramatically with the destruction of the temple and the loss of the dominant cultural center of Jerusalem. Although the temple and city had been destroyed once before, this time the Jewish leaders took the remarkable step of closing the Old Testament to any further additions and rejecting even some of the books which appeared in the famous Greek translation of Jewish sacred writings known as the Septuagint. Among the books in the Septuagint which the Jews finally excluded was the Book of Wisdom. When Catholics finally specified which books were part of the Old Testament, they included the Book of Wisdom. In any event, the ideas in Wisdom show an important school of thought in the area around Alexandria already before the time of Christ.

The Book of Wisdom is notable in strictly monotheistic Judaism because it indicates alongside the God of the Old Testament another personality called Wisdom. This tradition is part of the Wisdom literature of the Bible. However, in the Book of Wisdom, Wisdom is described in terms that reflect a vision which inculturates Greek philosophical language and describes Wisdom as having qualities which up until then would have only been attributed to God. Christians of the first centuries already saw Christ, the second person of the Trinity, as Wisdom. This idea emerges clearly in the letter to the Hebrews which seems to come from an Alexandrian milieu. Interestingly, the word in Hebrew grammar for Wisdom is feminine, thus the translation makes use of the word she rather than it or he: "for Wisdom, the artificer of all, taught me. For in her is a spirit, intelligent, holy, unique, manifold, subtle, agile, clear, unstained, certain, not baneful, loving the good, keen, unhampered, beneficent, kindly, firm secure, tranquil, all powerful, all seeing and pervading all spirits ... for she is an aura of the might of God and a pure effusion of the glory of the almighty … the spotless mirror of the power of God, the image of his goodness … passing into holy souls from age to age, she produces friends of God and prophets" (Wis 7:22-27).

It was in this Alexandrian context that produced the Book of Wisdom that an important Jewish philosopher later appeared called Philo (d. 40 AD). In a way similar to the Book of Wisdom, he speaks of a being he calls the Logos (Reason) that has similarities to the personified Wisdom in the Catholic Old Testament. This theory of Philo is extremely important because it is from this same city that Plotinus will go forth to teach a philosophical doctrine that totally denies the Christian concept of the triune God though it borrows concepts that were useful for describing the Trinitarian notion of the One God.

Plotinus proposes a theory that takes aim directly at our concept of a personal God and turns God into an "It." He proposes an impersonal first cause. He argued in this way: if the One (original being) had an intellect, this would set up a duality within the One. The One therefore has no intellect. If the One had a will, this also would set up a duality. The One therefore has no will. The One is simply there as the beginning of a process that necessarily produces the first mind (nous) that can understand. This production of this first mind is through a process of necessary emanation.

We can say that the best model for understanding emanation would be the sun which seems to produce light without itself changing. The light flows necessarily from it. Of course, nowadays we know that in fact the sun is slowly running out of energy, but that was not evident then. Thus, this theory had a certain attraction and offered an alternative to the Creator God of the Christians. In fact, the earlier Greek philosophers had simply supposed matter to be eternal and had not even been aware of the existence of spirit. Christianity and Judaism had given an attractive idea of a spiritual God who creates the world out of nothing and sustains it in history. Here was a non-Christian answer: the world arises from a necessary emanation from the One and continues through a process of further emanations which finally lead to the appearance of our visible world.

This theory clearly runs against Christianity, and it is an example of immanentism which Pope John Paul II identified as one of the philosophical problems of our times. The simplest model of immanentism is the egg of a chicken. Within that egg, the whole chicken is already potentially present. If you open it, you simply see the yolk and the white. But if you allow this to develop, it will become a complete chicken by its own natural processes. Immanentism appears in philosophy when someone proposes that from an impersonal "it" a gradual natural and necessary evolution takes place and the result is our contemporary world.

We can see many things in this approach that ran counter to Christianity. There was no true freedom in this vision of the world. We may not be able to see the necessity that underlies events, but the follower of immanentism is convinced that we are ruled by necessity. In immanentism there is no explanation, however, of why the process began or what caused it. Then, there is the logical question that if all comes from an impersonal reality, where does our experience of freedom and understanding come from? As Parmenides had said, no new reality can arise from nothing. If there is no intelligence or will in the original One, where does ours come from?

We have already seen that the two great philosophers of pre-Christian times, Plato and Aristotle, did not really clarify the personal nature of God or point to his involvement in the world. This goes back to the idea of Parmenides about the stability and the ultimate being. It was precisely this isolation that kept God immutable (stable) and isolated from the changing world. On the other hand, Plato and Aristotle really had no concept of the production of the world from nothing (creation). Plotinus answers the Christian idea of creation with the idea of necessary emanation which leaves the "One" (supreme being) unchanged in its isolation. Plotinus thus gave non-Christians an alternative explanation for the origin of the universe without really explaining how created freedom and knowledge can appear if they are absent in the One itself. Plotinus apparently was not trying to establish philosophical atheism, but this sort of reasoning would be used later on precisely in this way.

Given the rather vague personal aspect of God in Plato and Aristotle, it is easy to see how philosophical thought would see Plotinus as a continuation rather than a deviation. Thus the philosophy of Plotinus was called "Neo-Platonism" (new or updated Platonism). As a matter of fact, however, as we have already seen, Platonism could easily be used by Church thinkers in expounding Christian doctrine in a philosophical way. Neo-Platonism, however, has never been a completely suitable vehicle for theologizing because of the impersonal nature of the One and especially because of the lack of a genuine doctrine of creation and freedom. The doctrine of necessary emanation is irreconcilable with these Christian doctrines. Nevertheless, aspects of Neo-Platonism have been profitably used by later Christian thinkers including St. Augustine. Others, however, were led astray by it, as we shall see later.

The biggest puzzle (mystery) about God for theologians is the doctrine that he is three persons united in one divine nature. Neo-Platonism offered a tempting "explanation" for this (by really denying, however, the mystery of the trinity and the unity of God). Thus, in a heretical Christian view, Jesus as the Word would be the first emanation, then the Holy Spirit would emanate from the Word, and so we would arrive at a whole process leading to the existence of our universe. This destroys the unity and trinity of God and also divine freedom. Nevertheless there would be future thinkers that would try this Neo-Platonic approach without succeeding to produce a truly satisfactory solution.