ARTICLES Faith and Reason:  SUMMARY
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy
A Stroll through the History of Philosophy 1   2   A Stroll through the History of Philosophy 3

By Fr. James Fannan, PIME    

Map

  The Spread of Neo-Platonism

Neo-Platonism gradually began to infiltrate Christian thinking through an extremely effective means: the Pseudo Dionysius. The word pseudo in Greek means false, and this modern title indicates our awareness today that for about a thousand years, Christians were deceived about the origin of this writing. In the New Testament, Paul converted at Athens a man named Dionysius. As far as modern scholarship can determine, around the year 500 some unknown person wrote a work that incorporated Neo-Platonism in an otherwise Christian context. It would seem that the author was sincerely attempting to inculturate Christian thought into a philosophy that harbored serious dangers for Christian orthodoxy. In any event, he succeeded in convincing future generations that his work was of the famous Dionysius whom St. Paul had converted.

This gave his work enormous status. Eventually it was also translated into Latin, and thus it had a significant influence even in Western Europe – always because it was misrepresented as an authentic first century witness of Christian Philosophy. John Scotus Erigena (d. 877 AD) had the misfortune of trying to write a theological synthesis based on the Neo-Platonic approach he found in the Pseudo Dionysius: he ended up condemned as a heretic, but the real fault was most probably in the Neo-Platonic influence contained in the Pseudo Dionysius. The basic ideas of genuine Neo-Platonic thought were simply irreconcilable with authentic Christianity. Meister Eckhart (d. 1328) also was much influenced by Neo-Platonism, and it led him to certain theological expressions which the Church later condemned. In general the Neo-Platonic temptation is to construct a spirituality in which the soul returns by love to the primitive union of the One. This same concept is found in Islamic Sufism. Whereas ancient Gnosticism stressed knowledge as a means of salvation, radical Sufism stresses love which leads to monistic union with no distinction between the Godhead and the loving devotee.

Neo-Platonism was also successful in penetrating Aristotelian thought, and it was this mixture that finally became an essential part of the two Arabic language theologians who most influenced the West: Averroes (d. 1198) and Avicenna (d. 1037). The doctrine is also found in the Jewish Cabala. Neo-Platonism remained a force in Western thought through various sources. When Islamic thought began to have more and more impact in Western through Latin translations which started to appear around the time of the Crusades, it was the Neo-Platonic Aristotelianism of Averroes and Avicenna which was most influential. These historical facts have an importance because they help explain why immanentism always had disciples in the West.

The study of the development of philosophy in Europe from the time of the Middle Ages really requires the study of Islamic philosophy. To attempt to comprehend the development of philosophy in Europe without understanding the Islamic influence would be like reading a mystery novel and skipping several chapters in the middle. You would end up with unanswered questions and perhaps complete puzzlement. Islam also provided valuable contributions that were made use of by the great philosophers of the Middle Ages in Europe. I already mentioned that the term Western Philosophy is inadequate, and here again we see that the philosophy that was created by Greeks living in Asian Turkey was already assuming wider global dimensions with the spread of Islam.

Philosophy owes a debt of gratitude to the Muslim philosopher Alfarabi (d. 950) who was born in what is now Iran. We have already seen how the Neo-Platonic approach as well as the original Aristotelian writings had the effect of removing the Supreme Being from activity in the world. This is because of the roles given to intermediate inferior beings which were given cosmic roles. In discussing God and his role in our changing world, Alfarabi has the merit of focusing attention on God as the one who gives existence to the essences. By essence we are referring to the fact that the things of the world have natures which the human intellect can identify as having a specific nature whether or not the thing actually exists in this moment. Thus, if I say, I wish I had a glass of water, I have a very clear idea of what the essence or nature is that I would like, though it remains only an idea of a reality that does not exist for me at that time and place.

The connection of God with the act of existing, of course, did have roots in the Bible. God had already told Moses to tell Pharaoh that "I Am" had sent him (Ex 3:13-15). God’s name as revealed to Moses in Hebrew was Yahweh (i.e. I am who I am). Jesus also stressed the Hebrew meaning of the name of God when he said, "Before Abraham came to be, I AM" (Jn 8: 58). Likewise in the writings of the Fathers of the Church in the first centuries, there are clear references to the fact that we receive our existence from God. However, this stress on existence did not really correspond to the pre-Christian philosophy of the Greeks.

As we have already seen, there was no idea of a God who creates out of nothing in their pre-Christian philosophy. It was assumed that matter was eternal, and there were various ways of explaining how changes took place in the essences or natures of things. It is a definite merit of Alfarabi that he went beyond the pre-Christian tradition by emphasizing that whatever comes into existence at any time does so because God gives it existence at that point in time. Here we see a God who is not a remote origin of action; we see a God who is completely involved in this world. None of this would have been news to either Christians or Jews, but the fact is that the topic had been neglected because of the pagan heritage in which philosophy had formed. In his book, Crossing the Threshold of Hope, Pope John Paul II strongly stressed the necessity of returning to this awareness of God as the God of existence. In fact, a whole chapter is centered on this problem with the title "What Has Become of the ‘History of Salvation’?"

  Aristotle in Christianity

At this point we can return to focus on Medieval Europe, and we come to a great step forward: the incorporation of Aristotelian thought into Western Europe. Here it is worth noting that the old Roman Empire had been divided basically into and Eastern and a Western half at the time of Constantine (d. 337). Gradually this division became markedly linguistic with the decline of the political influence of the city of Rome beginning in the fourth century. The Eastern capital, Constantinople (what is now Istanbul in Turkey) continued to thrive and prosper even after losing Egypt and Palestine to the Muslim Arabs. Rome, however, was already going downhill economically; and both commerce and transportation were collapsing as Germanic tribes brought an end to a unified Western empire. The German tribes went on to establish their own regional kingdoms.

It may seem amazing to us today, but this brought about the disappearance of Greek as a known language among scholars in the West, except in Ireland. Thus, in general, only things that were translated into Latin became part of the philosophical heritage. From the works of Aristotle, only his logic had ever been translated, and so it was through Latin translations of the great Arabic philosophers that some clearer idea of Aristotle began to emerge in Western Europe around the time of the Crusades. The understanding they had of Aristotle was quite confused at first because, as we have seen, the Arabic writers had introduced Neo-Platonic elements. These elements, plus some of the other positions of Aristotle, such as the eternity of matter, led to an initial hostile response from Catholic philosophers However, gradually writers began to find positive aspects in this new philosophy, and likewise they began to discover the real Aristotle (rather than the Neo-Platonic Muslim variations on his philosophy).

This moment in history constitutes a turning point because all the elements were now present to express clearly certain aspects that had remained in the shadows up until this point. We have already seen that Alfarabi had focused attention on existence. This is the aspect that St. Thomas Aquinas takes up to produce a new synthesis which incorporated St. Augustine, Plato, and Aristotle into one philosophy and theology. St. Augustine died in 430 and St. Thomas would die in l274; during those 800 years, it was the theology of St. Augustine that had formed Western thought in a Platonic mold. The incorporation of Aristotle was controversial as we have seen, yet just as the Muslims had "the Book" (the Koran), and "the Prophet" (Mohammed), they also had "the philosopher" (Aristotle). He was widely regarded as the greatest genius of all time at a period when there still was no clear distinction between philosophy and science. Thus, St. Thomas was able to synthesize the philosophical thought of the greatest philosophers of ancient times together with the greatest theologian that the Western Church had produced.

The work of St. Thomas was controversial. He took up the Platonic and Aristotelian notion of a stable God at the basis of our changing world specifically under the dimension of existence. He described God as Ipsum Esse Subsistens. i.e., the act of existence itself like a stable reality (i.e. substance). This God, as Alfarabi had indicated, is not remote, for he is involved in every new change that takes place because it is God who brings every new change out of nothingness, and it is this same God who maintains all beings in their existence. Of course, there is a mysterious action here, but Parmenides’ principle of "from nothing, comes nothing" demands such an explanation for change. It is God, the supreme act of existence, who, without changing himself, brings forth all the changes in the world that he himself created and continually renews.

At this point in time, the Lateran Council IV (1215) could use a philosophical vocabulary to speak of God in terms which are found in number 202 of the Catholic Catechism of Pope John Paul II: "We firmly believe and confess without reservation that there is only one true God, eternal, infinite (immensus) and unchangeable, incomprehensible, almighty and ineffable, the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit; three persons indeed, but one essence, substance or nature entirely simple." To this, St. Thomas could add the valuable insight that God as an unchanging act of existence was the fount of the existence of created reality. The best biblical symbol of this is perhaps that of the burning bush (Ex 3:2) which symbolized the presence of God for Moses. On the one hand there was a stable and unchanging, living reality (the bush), but at the same time, without undergoing any change, it produced a continual flow of ever changing reality (the flame).

In Fides et Ratio, the Pope had special words of praise for St. Thomas because of his reaching out to Arabic, Jewish, and classical Greek thought. He illustrated in his philosophy the harmony that exists between faith and reason so that no contradiction divides them. However, he was famous for his awareness that it is the gift of the Holy Spirit that opens the way to a knowledge of divine realities. (N’s 43-44). Needless to say, St. Thomas never claimed that reason could delve into the depths of truth without the gifts of the Holy Spirit, but he was convinced of the enormous potential of reason under the light of Divine Truth. This enabled him to produce his synthesis in which reason drew inspiration from revelation: reason was illumined by revelation.

 

  The Advance of Skepticism

When Pope John Paul II wrote Crossing the Threshold of Hope, he wrote a chapter on Salvation History in which he recognized that philosophy had given to Descartes (d. 1650) the title of being the Father of Modern Philosophy. He then went on to lament the fact that since the time of Descartes, philosophy has been dominated by subjectivism and immanentism and had turned away from the God of existence as found in St. Thomas Aquinas. In his encyclical, Fides et Ratio, the Pope adds that,: "Rather than make use of the human capacity to know the truth, modern philosophy has preferred to accentuate the ways in which this capacity is limited and conditioned. This has given rise to different forms of agnosticism and relativism which have led philosophical research to lose its way in the shifty sands of widespread skepticism." He notes that there is "the assumption that all positions are equally valid, which is one of today’s most widespread symptoms of the lack of confidence in truth … everything is reduced to opinion" (N. 5). Against this trend the Pope noted that on the other hand, "Everyday life shows how concerned each of us is to discover for ourselves, beyond mere opinions, how things really are" (N. 25). He mentions the great adversary of skepticism, St. Augustine, who wrote: "I have met many who wanted to deceive, but none who wanted to be deceived" (N. 25).

 

How did this rise of skepticism come about in our times? We have already seen that Socrates had risen up against the subjectivism of Protagoras who proclaimed that "man is the measure of all things." The idea that all viewpoints are equally true was seen by Socrates as something clearly untrue and also as something that would lead to bad consequences for any society that accepted it. Socrates tried to understand and explain the objective nature of virtues. Thus qualities of loyalty, courage, honesty, etc. were of great importance for the formation of youth and society, and Socrates believed it was clear that these qualities have an objective nature that can be discovered by patient investigation and dialogue. This gave an impetus to Aristotle to do his great study of ethics and it also led Plato to look for the reason why these virtues did have this objective nature that could be recognized by all. Plato believed that it was the spiritual world of ideas that provided this objective, stable foundation for the existence of virtue in our changing world.

Clearly these classical thinkers were convinced that it is possible for the human mind to know objective reality and to study it by sincere dialogue and reflection. The temptation to simple skepticism was one of the philosophical temptations of the ancient world – how can we be sure of anything? Aristotle answered by indicating a fundamental rule of both reality and our way of thinking about reality: "it is impossible for a thing to be and not be at the same time in the same respect." This is traditionally known as the principle of contradiction, which also is often called the principle of non-contradiction. By this principle, Aristotle enunciated a very fundamental fact about reality and also our understanding of reality. If I were to say, "I doubt this principle of Aristotle," I am already recognizing the difference between doubt and certitude and recognizing that the two attitudes cannot coexist in the same person about the same fact. Later on St. Augustine would answer the skeptics of his time with a similar statement: "Si fallor sum" (Even if I am in error, I exist). Being in error clearly presupposes the existence of a certitude, i.e. the existence of the one who is in error! Skepticism thus was temporarily defeated by good philosophy, but future thinkers would find new ways of advocating skeptical positions.

An important theory that leads to skepticism is found in the philosophy of William of Ockham (d. 1349) who had a great influence in Catholic philosophy for a while (though he was condemned by the Church already during his lifetime). It was really after his death that his influence became gradually more and more widespread. He gave birth to a philosophy known as Nominalism. Up until his time, philosophers were convinced that we could know and discuss reality. To a certain degree they were confirming what ordinary people would call "common sense" – which is the oldest school of thought in the history of humanity.

That is why the Pope wrote "All men and woman … are in some sense philosophers and have their own philosophical conceptions with which they direct their lives" (N. 30). Thus people recognize that gold is not silver, water is not lead, etc. It is clear that they are different substances or natures to the ordinary person. Aristotle used the word substance to refer to these basic realities which may change in a superficial way, but remained basically the same. Thus gold can be fashioned into ornaments, water can freeze, etc. These superficial aspects of substances, such as the quantity, place, shape, etc., Aristotle called accidents. (Obviously, this is not the same meaning we find in newspapers today; it has become a technical term in philosophy.)

Nominalism attacked this common sense approach to reality. If we went out to the apple tree and brought back three apples, everyone would think they are the same kind of substance (nature), and thus we would call each of them an apple. Ockham would claim that there is no true basis for the statement that they are all apples. He would claim that each of the apple was totally unique in its nature, but that we merely grouped these objects together on the basis of a perceived similarity with a common name. The word name in Latin was nomen, and this gave rise to the word Nominalism for this philosophy.

This theory might appear a bit odd to modern people, but it had serious consequences in theology. In fact, Catholic theology stated that Jesus had a true human nature as a son of Adam. For Ockham, the humanity of each person was just a name. Each of us had his own nature in such a way that it truly made it impossible to state that we had the same kind of nature. Thus, the human nature of Jesus would not really be the precise same kind of human nature that we all possess. Traditional philosophy recognized, of course that an individual apple or person had its own individuality, but at the same time, our language reflected a fact that individual persons and apple all had the same kind of nature. Thus, there is the idea about humans "all are equal." Otherwise, one could conclude that there is no such thing as equal rights for all humans based on their equal nature. Thus in the field of theology, the theories of Ockham had the effect of destroying not only traditional theology about Christ (as God-man) but the whole natural moral law which is based on generalizing from particular natures: e.g. you shall not covet your neighbor’s goods.

The ancient Greeks had at the very beginning recognized that nature had regular patterns and therefore was governed by some sort of laws. It was clear that things did not just happen randomly. They developed the idea of the laws governing physical changes, such as when water changes to ice. But they also recognized a law of morality. It was this law, in fact, that Socrates found most important for the welfare of the people. Ockham’s attack on our ability to know the true natures of the things around us also extended to the relationship between concrete existing objects. Thus, the relationship of cause and effect was also denied by Ockham.

This attacked not only common sense, but the whole possibility of the scientific study of nature. Thus one could not say that fire by its nature caused the water to boil; there was simply the fact that after putting the kettle on the fire, the water began to boil. For Ockham, causality was found not in natures but in the will of God. Making the will of God the unique origin of apparent cause and effect would not have long term success in philosophy, but his views would raise the question of cause and effect both in philosophy and theology in the years to come. In any event, at this point in history, knowledge of the physical sciences was quite limited anyway, but Ockham’s approach would widen the gap between philosophy and the physical sciences by his approach to the physical world.

  Nominalism and the Reformation

The Church was concerned about Ockham and condemned his theories, but the damage had been done, and most scholars see the teaching of Luther as the fruit of Ockham. Jesus had promised that those who eat his flesh would live forever (Jn 6:54). The Christians who wrote and read the New Testament writings understood that there was a kind of life the Jesus was giving that went beyond the mere life of nature which ends in the grave. The technical name in theology for this new kind of spiritual life was sanctifying grace (a divine gift which makes us holy). This new source of activity was a new life, a new creation acting within Christians. As Paul said, "I live now not I, but Christ lives in me." The seven sacraments were all concerned with establishing and promoting this "supernatural" life. This life was a reality and not just a word or label.

With a nominalist philosophy, it was easy for Luther (d. 1542) to see justification as a name or label whereby God accepted us as forgiven without any real change taking place in the believer’s soul. Classic Catholic theology had seen a new life, a new creation, in each person who received the sanctifying grace whereby God worked in them, elevating their spiritual lives to a new level, a supernatural level. St. Thomas had used the idea that grace does not supplant nature, rather it builds on nature and perfects it. Jesus had explained so simply: "I am the vine, you are the branches … without me you can do nothing … By this is my Father glorified, that you bear much fruit ..."(Jn 15:5-8). God as first cause did not ignore or circumvent his creatures. He genuinely worked through them, elevating their nature with supernatural graces. Nominalism therefore attacked the whole philosophical structure of Catholicism – the reason that harmonized with revelation.

There was also another aspect of Catholic theology that apparently Luther did not understand. The teaching of Christ had described Christians as sharing a life with him as his branches. This idea had been developed by St. Thomas from his viewpoint of God as the one who continually moves the world (unmoved mover) by conserving the existing world with his own infinite power. Thus a free nature (e.g. human) moved and governed itself according to God’s law of love with the force provided by God. The terminology used was this: God as the unmoved mover is the first cause. The creature, acting according to its nature, provides the second causality. This "first" and "second" does not refer to time, it refers to the phrase of Christ: "without me you can do nothing."

Just as the fruit of the vine is produced cooperatively by the vine and the branches in the realm of nature, in the realm of human freedom, all good acts are the fruit of this cooperation between a first and second cause (uncreated and created) which concur or act simultaneously at different levels –that of Creator and that of creature. Following the principle "from nothing, nothing comes," a creature is incapable of producing anything without the cooperation of the first cause, God. St. Paul had applied this same idea in his letter to the Philippians stressing a mystery of Christian faith. On the one hand man is truly free, but on the other hand it is God who moves him freely: " work out your salvation with fear and trembling. For God is the one who for his good purpose, works in you both to desire and to work" (Ph 2:12-13). Thus God moves all things according to their nature, and he moves free things according to their free nature. Just as human minds cannot understand how it is possible for God to create out of nothing, it is also impossible to understand how God moves free persons to action while preserving their freedom. We have no personal experience of this kind of creative causality, yet the principle "from nothing, nothing comes" requires such a fount of being. A creature is incapable of producing anything new without the continual aid of the Creator who conserves all things in the flow of history. Thus Catholic thought is radically different from Ockham’s and Luther’s.

From the standpoint of faith and the traditional philosophy of the Church, humanity is created in the image of God. This means that human freedom cannot correctly be seen as a simple indifference before good and evil. In God, divine freedom is one with the divine goodness. Thus, also in the creature, freedom must be drawn towards union with what is truly morally good, otherwise it is a defective and incomplete freedom. It is not a genuine freedom in its full perfection if it turns (irrationally) from the true good. This is why Pope John Paul II wrote in his encyclical Fides et Ratio, "freedom is not realized in decisions made against God. For how could it be an exercise of true freedom to resist to open to the very reality which enables our self-realization?" (N. 13).

What the Pope said here is almost always overlooked in discussions on freedom because in line with personal voluntarism, especially since Descartes, freedom is looked on as a blind preference on the part of the creature rather than a faculty made in the image of God’s perfect freedom which is always united to the good (i.e. love). Reflecting on this, the Pope further clarifies the matter in this way: "The truth of Christian Revelation, found in Jesus of Nazareth … As absolute truth … summons human beings to be open to the transcendent, whilst respecting both their autonomy as creatures and their freedom. At this point the relationship between freedom and truth is complete, and we understand the full meaning of the Lord’s words: You will know the truth, and the truth will make you free’" (Jn 8:32) (N. 15).

Another aspect of Nominalism that we should look at in relation to Luther was precisely how Luther misunderstood Catholic thinking. Pelagius (d. 418), taught and believed that people were good by their own efforts (without any special help from God). Thus, people merited (by their own efforts) God’s favorable verdict as Judge. This error was combated by St. Augustine and also condemned by the Church in that era. With the passage of centuries, Pelagius was no longer the center of Church debate, so Luther erroneously thought that the Catholic Church’s teaching was the same as that of Pelagius (though it had been rejected by the Church already centuries before). Luther moreover seems to have been unaware of the solution of St. Thomas. He also simply ignored passages like Philippians 2:12-13 which we saw above. Luther therefore proposed a solution along Nominalist lines: God pronounces us justified based merely on our faith not only at the time of our conversion but even till the Day of Judgment, regardless of what good or ill we have done since our conversion. The fact that St. Paul had stated that we could have faith "to move mountains" (I Cor 13:2) and still be nothing without charity seems not to have discouraged Luther in his doctrine. Neither did the teaching of St. James convince Luther that he was making a mistake. St. James, in fact, had clearly stated: "Faith without works is dead" (Jas 2: 26).

The last aspect of nominalism that we will look at here is one that manifested itself in the Protestant Reformation and had to do with God’s freedom. The notion that God is love would indicate that in the exercise of his freedom he acts according to his Divine Nature which is love. An unjust, whimsical or cruel God is thus a contradiction in terms for a Christian. The idea that God can choose to do anything whatsoever simply because he is almighty is called divine voluntarism. In such voluntarism, the law of God depends simply on his will and cannot be analyzed logically by looking at the God who reveals himself in the Bible as a God of Love. This voluntarism undermined the whole Greek and Catholic tradition of a natural law which is rooted in the eternal will of God. Till this time, it was believed that the law of God, the natural law, could be discovered by a sincere personal effort on the part of humanity. Luther, on the other hand could use the voluntarist approach to justify his theories based on what he believed was the will of God, i.e. we are saved by faith alone whether or not we live our lives in conformity with that faith. A more dramatic example was the other famous Protestant reformer, Calvin. He stated God could send evildoers to heaven and the virtuous to hell by his eternal decree (predestination) since God can do whatever he chooses. This theory of predestination, based on a voluntarist notion of God, was quite different from Catholic thought that took into account both God’s Love and humanity’s genuine created freedom.

Nominalism thus had a very destructive impact on Catholic thought and prepared European thought for many errors. It would be good here to pause at this question of divine freedom. We have already seen that the notion that "God is Love" is incompatible with the voluntarist view of a God who can act in an arbitrary way. In the past and even today there are those who say, "then why is there evil in the world?" It is important to note that according to the Bible, at the time of creation, God said that it was "very good" (Gn 1:31); likewise Jesus compared the world to a field sown with good seed. The bad that is there comes from the devil, and Jesus himself said that God tolerates evil and evildoers till the day of judgment for the sake of those who will be saved through faithfully carrying their cross (Mt 13:24-30 and Mt 16:24).

It is evident from the centuries of human experience that sanctity is a rare quality. Ordinary people should thus be thankful that God is so merciful, remembering that as sinners we are all "evildoers." St. Paul’s change from great sinner to great saint is not the only example from history. The patience of God shows his wisdom and mercy since he wills that all come to salvation (2 Pt 3: 9). In the final analysis, the Bible states that the reward of the just outweighs any earthly consideration: "Eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor have entered into the heart of man, the things which God has prepared for those who love him" (1 Cor 2:9). Jesus himself put the same idea in a negative way, "For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world and lose his own soul?" (Mk 8:36). These are clearly statements of faith, but they do not run counter to reason. In fact, it is important to note that when we speak of the harmony between faith in reason, it does not mean that reason alone can ever reach all the teachings of faith. It means that careful reasoning does not contradict the teachings of Catholic faith; on the contrary, in the long run it actually confirms them.

  The Roots of Subjectivism

Nominalism was ahead of its time in claiming that we do not know things as they really are and simply attach the same names to them because of their striking similarities. This means that we do not know reality as it is and therefore our analysis of the world is a purely human creation rather than a faithful description of the objective world around us. This idea will return again and runs completely counter to the conviction of the great philosophers before Descartes that the mind could truly know an objective reality outside of itself. Nominalism is just an early example of the subjectivism noted by Pope John Paul II as characteristic of philosophy after Descartes.

This denial of our ability to discover identical natures in the world around us as well as the denial that creatures are true causes makes a harmony between philosophy modern science impossible. The whole idea of science is the discovery of the nature of things and causal relationships in the world around us. Nominalism would make all science, and even common sense, just a subjective mental creation. Nevertheless, again it must be said that nominalism was ahead of its time in both these areas. Nominalism was preparing the way for British empiricism. However, such a philosophy brings about a divorce between common sense and philosophy. This may give some philosophers a smug feeling of superiority over the rest of humanity, but in fact, this attitude leads to a situation in which philosophy comes to be seen as irrelevant to "real" life. It is clear that such a situation does not help philosophy to assume a significant role in human civilization. The highest degree in the academic world is called a Ph. D, which means Doctor of Philosophy. Today there are many educated people with Ph. D’s who have never studied philosophy which is now often seen as irrelevant.

The Protestant Reformation came shortly after the invention of printing which had a great impact also in the history of philosophy. Printing also helped to lead to this situation in modern philosophy that has just been described in the last paragraph. Before the Reformation, European intellectuals were united by a common Latin language and philosophy was engaged in by a professional class of thinkers especially in great universities. This was called scholastic philosophy because it was a product of the schools or universities of Europe. The breakdown of Christian unity also promoted a breakdown of linguistic unity among European intellectuals who had gathered around these universities. National languages became the medium of communication and publication.

This had a bad effect of eliminating from many minds a vast wealth of knowledge that had been accumulated since the birth of Christianity. With the use of national languages, there was also lowering of the standards of philosophy. Philosophy was no longer engaged in by people who had studied in depth the philosophy of the past; it was now possible for anyone to write his speculations to an audience that bought whatever they wanted to read. It was up to the literate public to decide whether to buy the book and to judge the worth of the theories proposed in it. This led to a wealth of theories and speculations which in turn helped to promote skepticism about the possibility of establishing the truth about the deep questions of life.

Aristotle’s logic had been translated into Latin just after the fall of the Roman Empire in the West. The period of scholastic philosophy arose gradually in the following period and formed the bridge between the Roman Empire (476 AD) and the world of Descartes. This meant that in the scholastic period, reasoning was carefully analyzed as to whether or not it followed Aristotle’s rules of logic. With the rise of the national languages and a literate, though philosophically ignorant reading public, it was easy for superficial philosophical works to win a public following. It is also important to note that the great Christian (Catholic) philosophers before the Reformation actually combined philosophical speculation with their theological writings rather than writing purely philosophical works. This fact also would discourage later philosophers, especially Protestants, from even reading such works in search of the philosophical thinking they contained.

The tendency of thought after the Reformation therefore was to continue a tendency that had appeared already in the Renaissance of going back to the ancient pagan philosophers of Greece and Rome for ideas and inspiration or else to dialogue on contemporary issues without also considering the debates in the Middle Ages. In this way, valuable insights were totally forgotten and ignored. An example of this is found in one of the most famous philosophers of the nineteenth century, Hegel (d. 1831). He left notes that were gathered into a History of Philosophy; it devoted only part of a page to the philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas. In a similar way, Will Durant has written a popular history of philosophy The Story of Philosophy which has been quite widely circulated in the last eighty years. His thick volume jumps from Aristotle to Francis Bacon (d. 1626). This shows how little was his appreciation of the philosophers of those intervening years. This approach is hardly serious as scholarship; it simply demonstrates the ignorance of such authors and the uncritical acceptance of the educated reading public who could read and write but were actually quite ignorant of philosophy.

  Descartes: The Father of Modern Philosophy

Amidst the confusion that arose after Nominalism and the Reformation, there appeared Descartes. He is regarded as the Father of Modern Philosophy, a kind of new starting point that ends the Medieval Catholic period. He was himself a Catholic and was very much influenced by St. Augustine and therefore Plato. Descartes noted that the new physical sciences were progressing in an understanding of the world that met with wide consensus. Philosophy was instead increasingly confused. He hoped, however, to solve this problem by finding some starting point on which to carefully construct a philosophical system that would put an end to the reigning confusion. He starting point actually echoed a phrase of St. Augustine against the skeptics "Even if I am in error, I exist." Descartes said simply, "I think, therefore I am." This phrase was undoubtedly true, but really there was an idea from Aristotle that was implicit in it but not stated: it is impossible for a thing to be and not be at the same time in the same respect, i.e. the principle of non-contradiction. Obviously, all communication, including the phrase "I think, therefore I am" presupposes the principle of non-contradiction or else we would have words with no clear meaning. I am, for example, does not mean the same thing as I am not.

Unfortunately, by starting in this subjective way, Descartes was turning his attention away from an objective truth, the principle of contradiction. This subjective approach was to lead to many problems. The basic problem was that by starting with a subjective state (his own human thought), Descartes arrived at a position where the soul and body of man seemed to be two separate realities for him which he found it impossible to unite in his system. Modern philosophy would give birth to two extreme positions on this problem. One theory was idealism (there is no material reality; all is thought). The other theory was materialism (there is only matter; there is no spiritual reality).

As a Catholic, Descartes solved his dilemma about our bodily role in knowledge by stating that God guarantees the accuracy of our sense knowledge about the world around us. This solution, however, was not satisfactory, especially to the spirit of the times in which he was living. In any event, this stress on the knowing individual (I think, therefore I am) is called the anthropocentric shift (a shift to a way of thinking that puts the human mind at the center of philosophy). It means that more and more there is the tendency in philosophy to leave the objective world aside (as the domain of the physical sciences). Philosophy instead begins to become bogged down in the question of whether we have any true knowledge about anything at all. Rather than solving the problem of confusion in philosophy, Descartes had become part of the problem and even a promoter of the problem. He had in this way become the Father of Modern Philosophy!

Rather than making philosophy more credible, Descartes had sown the seeds of more doubts about our ability to find the truth by means of philosophy. We have already seen how skepticism leads to philosophy becoming irrelevant to ordinary people. There was the theory of Ockham, for example, that denied the truth value of calling things by the same name because he thought it was wrong to say that words with the same meaning really accurately reflected the fact that they stood for things with the very same natures, e.g. one diamond, two diamonds, etc. He said that we do not really discover common natures in things but instead impose our own words (nominalism) on things that really do not share a common kind of nature. Normal human speech that classifies objects such as diamonds, pearls, apples and people would be for Ockham something imprecise since it indicates a sameness of nature in these objects which he denied. He would thus put in doubt that each of us has the very same kind of human nature found again and again in many different people. This puts into doubt the whole moral law for interpersonal relations. Nietzsche (d. 1900) would later speak of some persons as being "supermen" for whom it was quite proper to dominate and oppress others. Hegel saw Germans as the superior nation, and Hitler described Germans as the "master race."

It is not surprising that a later Englishman (Oxford had given rise to Ockham) named Hume (d. 1776) would introduce a theory that also widened the gap between the way things really are and the way we think and talk about them. Hume pushed the problem of the natures of things to the denial of "substance." Aristotle had given a name to the stability that we find in individual objects. He called this reality a substance. Thus, in the changing world, he noted that there was something more stable about an object and something less stable. A diamond remains the same diamond today as it was yesterday, but we can change it’s place, we can polish it, etc. Likewise people change with time, but they always remain the same human beings. The man who was Peter yesterday is still Peter even though he may have shaved off his beard. Aristotle called the changing realities accidents that were found present in a substance that was the stable reality in the midst of change. The root of the word accident and "it happens to be" is the same in Latin.

Hume denied the reality of substance. He said that we can only see and judge the changing appearances (accidents), but we cannot see this stable reality. He therefore denied the reality of substance. For him, substance is something that the human mind imagines to give a unity to the changing accidents. Here we see a step beyond Ockham and a big break with ordinary human thinking. Common sense, the philosophy of ordinary people throughout the ages, assigned names to things on the basis that things should receive the same name because they had the same kind of nature: this is an apple and that is an apple; this is a pearl and that is a pearl.

Hume denied that these things had any substance at all. Substance for him was just a mental creation of the observer as names were a verbal creation for Ockham. Ockham had attributed causality to the will of God. Hume instead believed that causality was nothing more than our subjective observation of a pattern of stable conditions before a given effect. This position of stating that we only have knowledge of what our senses can perceive and no more than that is called empiricism. For Aristotle, instead, sense perception was merely the beginning of our consideration of the universe. It is the universe that we know as the object of ours study, and the senses are merely our "window to the world."

The divorce between common sense and science on the one hand and such philosophy on the other is apparent here. It means that we live and talk as if substances and causes are real, but theoretically as philosophers we deny them. Hume himself was quite disturbed by where his mistaken logic had led him, but he could not find the right way out of this puzzle. If he had lived in the Middle Ages, he might have had colleagues who could help him. As it was, he instead found many disciples who read his books.

It is perhaps understandable that later science would revolt against all this and arrive at the conclusion that a statement is only meaningful if it is empirically verifiable and that any effort at metaphysics is to indulge in nonsense. Thus, all the philosophical truths that are supposed by scientific studies (e.g. causes and natures) are simply and simplistically ignored, and science goes on as if philosophy did not exist. Ethical statements, for example, are simply regarded as feelings and preferences.

The philosophies of this type can be classed as forms of positivism. They cannot solve the problems that Hume raises simply by ignoring his doctrine. The first thing to establish in the study of science is whether science is talking about reality and not just our own subjective categories of interpreting reality. Positivism does not solve the problem in any rational way. Pope John Paul II has harsh words for this approach, which he labels as "scientism." He calls it "a philosophical notion which refuses to admit the validity of forms of knowledge other than those of the positive sciences, and it relegates religious, theological, ethical and aesthetic knowledge to the realm of mere fantasy. In the past, the same idea emerged in positivism and neo-positivism, which considered metaphysical statements to be meaningless … No less disappointing is the way in which it approaches the other great problems of philosophy which, if they are not ignored, are subjected to analyses based on superficial analogies lacking all rational foundation" (N. 88).