back  A Listening Heart continue
Brother David Steindl-Rast

Sensuous Asceticism

Have you ever noticed that fragrance comes only in momentary wafts? We cannot hold on to it. We can look at the same color for hours, listen to the same tone for as long as we wish, but an odor must impinge on our nasal membranes in spurts in order to be perceived. The heavy honey smell of acacia or linden trees in bloom fills the evening air, but we perceive it only in wave after wave. Even if you dab cologne right into the hollow of your upper lip, you will smell it not continuously, but only in whiffs.

This points to another connection between smells and wisdom: we need to stay alert for moments of inspiration. The word "inspiration" means literally, "in-breathting." Only on an in-breath will we catch the scent that directs us like hounds that have a trained nose for where their duty lies. Like the senses of hounds our senses need to be trained so they will guide us from mere delight to delighted service. Wisdom proves its genuineness through compassion. We are destined to become as incense.

The language of mystics proves how futile it would be to separate spirituality from sensuousness. And why should we try to force a separation? Dull handbooks have tried this, but hardly with success. Sacred scriptures and mystical writings of every tradition bear witness to spiritual sensuousness and sensuous spirituality.

A privileged biblical image for sense perceived through the senses, yet surpassing the sensuous realm, is the Burning Bush (Ex. 3). A dried-out desert thornbush blazes into flame. Moses herding his sheep hears the fire crackling and turns. Amazed he asks himself, "why is this bush not burnt?" Many times before, he must have seen a bramble ignite in the desert noonday heat; in a flash, the bush would turn to ashes. What made this sight so strange was not the fire, but the preservation of tinderdry wood in the midst of the fire. This "strange sight" (Ex. 3:3) signals a centraI theme of the whole Bible: God's presence in our midst, the co-existence, even more than that, the inter-penetration between what is accessible to our senses and what goes altogether beyond them. These two "suffer no confusion, but permit no separation" (non confusionem passus, neque divisionem) as a Christmas antiphon puts it, full of wonderment and awe. The image of the Burning Bush boldly proclaims: Divine Reality is accessible through the senses. This is quite a claim. It becomes even more striking as we read on.

Out of the fire a voice startles Moses: "Do not come closer!" A warning, no doubt, to keep a proper distance out of awe and sacred dread and reverence. This is one possible understanding. But another rabbinical tradition has reached a deeper insight: you do not need to come closer. Note that the voice continues: "Take off your shoes. The pIace on which you are standing is holy ground." You will become aware that you need not come closer, the moment you take off your shoes. You will realize that you are already standing on holy ground, the moment you remove the skin of dead animals which you have put between your live soles and the holy ground under your feet. The shoes stand for the very opposite of grateful sensuous aliveness. They symbolize deadness, insensibility, and taking-for-granted. Wherever we stand, we are standing on holy ground, but by insensibility we exile ourselves from the Holy Presence accessible through our senses. "What was the real exile?" the rabbis ask. "Was it Egypt? Was it Babylon? - No!" they answer, "lt was: getting-used-to-it." Take off your shoes and return from exile: feel holy ground!

Walking barefoot - what better image for recovering the world of touch? "My foot converses with the stones on which it treads," says "The Blind Girl" in Rilke's poem (Buch der Bilder II: 2). Anyone's feet can learn to converse with the ground. As soon as we remove what gets in the way, be it shoes or thoughtless habit, we are in touch; conversation becomes possible. The Presence Beyond Words speaks to our sense of touch in countless different languages. To learn these languages is a delight. God in the wet meadow speaks to my feet in a language different from that of sun-warmed granite in the dry creek bed. The tile floor around the fountain speaks a cool language, like Latin. Hay that tickles my toes prattles like peasant children. My feet are fluent in the idiom of floorboards, doormats and alI sorts of sand and pebbles on the beach.

Linen, leather, loofa - how differently each of them speaks to neck and shoulders. Straw hat and fur cap, beanie and helmet; pants loose and baggy or tights; how different their touch. Every area of our skin responds differently to different kinds of touch - brushing, scratching, rubbing, kneading, tickling, stroking. Yes, for our sense of touch, too, the fountains of blessing are filled to the brim.

Hands - as yet I haven't even mentioned hands: palms, thumbs, fingers, fingernails, fingertips. When I dust the chair in the hermitage, fingering the spaces between spindles at its back, this can be a series of caresses; I can do it as mindfulIy and lovingly as when I stroke Poppy, the cat. I remember Soen Roshi saying to us young monks, who thought of sweeping as something to get over and be done with: "That's no way to treat the dust. Your hands are to make the broom say to the dust, 'Sorry, you happen to be in a pIace where you don't belong; let me help you out.' " The language of hands can be rough or refined. Hands can be taught to be polite; this is part of sensuous asceticism.

Watch the hands of musicians tenderly touching their instruments. The gentle touch with which The Guitarist Tunes Up is a prototype of affectionate reverence. Frances Cornford (1886-1960) describes it in a poem with that title. "With what attentive courtesy he bent / over his instrument," she marvels, reminding us that a true master treats an instrument "not as a lordly conqueror," but with lovingly listening fingers. To listen with one's fingertips no less than with one's ears is the essence of obedience. Her guitarist behaves:

...as a man with a loved woman might
Inquiring with delight
What slight essential thing she had to say

Before they started, he and she, to play.

The Japanese tea ceremony is a time-honored method for teaching hands to listen. Long ago, it was simply the way monks prepared a cup of whisked tea, served it to a guest, and washed the dishes - mindfulIy. Now, these three steps have become formalized in many different styles, and in Japan, every year, hundreds of thousands of students from alI walks of life enroll in courses to study this sensuous ascetical practice.

It was a historic event when Sen Soshitsu, Japan's Grand Tea Master, visited New York. I knew that his ancestor, the great Sen Rikyu, had given the tea ceremony its classical form almost half a millennium ago. Of course, I was eager to meet Sen Rikyu's successor and descendant - the 16th in an unbroken line. But this soft-spoken gentleman with the hands of an artist proved to be far more than a celebrity distinguished by lineage and title. Here was a true master of sensuous asceticism. A small incident I was privileged to witness showed me this.

I stilI remember the reflections of city lights in the East River and in the rain-wet pavement of United Nations Plaza, twenty-two floors below the candle-lit apartment where a reception for Mr. and Mrs. Sen had been prepared with exquisite taste. Their hosts wanted to treat the honored guests from the East to the finest of Western culture. A famous keyboard artist had been engaged to play on a harpsichord rented for this occasion. There the instrument stood in alI its elegant simplicity, its wood aglow in the light of candelabra. But it was locked and a whisper was going around that the key to the falIboard was nowhere to be found. Time for the performance came closer. The guests started whispering, getting flustered, embarrassed, tense. FinalIy everyone fell silent. The Tea Master caught on. Calmly he walked up to the harpsichord, stretched out his slender hand and passed his palm over the silky surface of the lid, back and forth, quite a few times. Then he looked up at us, smiled, and the spell was broken. All possible music seemed to have streamed from the silent harpsichord through these listening hands into his alI embracing smile. We were in touch. AlI of us felt held by a firm but gentle embrace.

Touching is always mutuaI. We are able to see without being seen (children like to peek); we can hear without being heard, and smell without (we hope) emitting a smell; but no one can touch without being touched. This is so obvious that we take it for granted. Yet, it adds a new aspect to my contention that personal ascetical practice leads to social change. People who practice mindful looking wilI see what needs to be done in the world; those who learn to listen wilI hear the challenges which social evils shout at us; noses that come alive wilI smell it when "something is rotten in the State of Denmark."

Being out of touch
makes one sick.
Touch is healing.
We need not fear
contact,
only lack
of
it.

But to be in touch with the world around us goes one step further: it puts us in touch with the sore spots of our society, and this contact will prove to be a mutualIy healing touch. Being out of touch makes one sick. Touch heals. We need not fear contact, only the lack of it. It is not contact that leads to violence, but alienation. When we create a gap between highly charged poles, a lethal spark is bound to jump. Contact, even friction, alIows the charge to flow rather than build up to dangerously high voltage. Touch keeps blessing in flow. The more alert we become to the blessing that flows into us through everything we touch, the more our own touch wilI bring blessing.

Only one sensation puts us in even closer touch than touching: tasting. Seeing allows for a great distance from what we see - an unimaginably vast distance, in fact. Standing under the night sky, we look at stars so far away that the light we now see started travelling when dinosaurs were still roaming on Earth. Our range of hearing is incomparably closer, our range of smelling closer stilI. Touching allows for no distance at all, yet it gives only surface contact. But tasting what dissolves on our tongue dissolves the barriers between subject and object. What we have tasted we know "inside out." No wonder, tasting became a metaphor for sapiential knowing. Sapientia, the Latin word for wisdom, means quite literally the ability to taste.

Nothing will reveal the world to us as intimately as savoring its bittersweet taste. To live to the full is to "taste life." To die consciously is to "taste death." In that same idiom the Psalmist encourages all who seek wisdom to "taste and see that the Lord is good" (Ps. 34:9). In this passage, tasting refers to our senses, the rabbis point out; seeing, to our intellect. These two must not be separated. Wisdom demands both tasting and seeing. Without sensuous experience the intellect can at best acquire book learning. But Lady Wisdom, as the Bible depicts her, with all her perfumes, ointments, spices, and tasty dishes leads us through "tasting life" with all our senses to "seeing life" in a light for which only the heart has eyes.

We met Holy Wisdom a few pages back in connection with ascetical training of the sense of smell. Tasting and smelling are as close to each other as mouth and nose. What loss it would be if we could not also smell the food we taste. Yet, what many consider the most important taste of all has no smell. "The nose knows not the savor of salt," a proverb of the Hausa of Nigeria reminds us. Salt is an ancient and widespread symbol for wisdom. Salt brings out the taste of food for the body, wisdom for the mind.

Salt preserves food from corruption; since stench and decay were associated with demonic influence, salt came to stand for divine blessing. So sacred was salt held to be that "every sacrifice must be salted with salt" (Lev. 2:13, Mk. 9:50). In the act of immolation incense and salt fuse into one symbol. Sacrifice expresses transformation. The ascetical path of wisdom and compassion cannot bypass sacrifice. From giving oneself to blessing this path leads to giving oneself as blessing. Those who follow the path of sensuous asceticism will become "the salt of the Earth" (Mt. 5: 13), a blessing for the whole world; but first they must be "salted with fire" (Mk. 9:49), with transforming fire in which wisdom becomes fully itself by becoming compassion.

Every meal worth its salt is worth being eaten mindfully, worth being tasted with wisdom. My Buddhist friends chant before meals: "lnnumerable labors brought us this food; we should know how it comes to us." Do we know it? Do we think of the innumerable creatures who labored and suffered and died to provide us with food? The practice of cultivating our sense of taste ought to include this dimension, too. Listing fruits, "apple, pear, gooseberry, banana..." Rilke marveled, "All this speaks / death and life into your mouth" (Sonnets to Orpheus, I: 13). Have you ever thought of your mouth as being spoken into like the mouthpiece of a telephone? "Where words used to be, discoveries gush forth" (ibid.), discoveries not only of life, but also of death, the death on which we feed and the life that finds fulfillment in becoming food for others.

"We eat to support life," Buddhist monks remind themselves in their chant before a meal. We eat to support our own life and the life of others who eat us up metaphorically and, eventually, literally. The food chain is a closed circle. On the biological level we humans are but one link in that chain. Wisdom will taste life and death with full awareness and will relish their tart intermingling. But wisdom has a wider perspective. Wisdom can see a food chain, as it were, that transcends biological life not a closed circle, but an ever-rising helix. Fr. George Kosicki tells a delightfully whimsical story about this.

Once upon a time, there was a dandelion growing in a meadow. The dandelion whispered to the amino acids and all the other nutrients in the soil, "How would you like to become dandelion? You need only to allow yourselves to be dissolved in a drop of water and I will suck you up through my roots. You won't feel a thing. But afterwards, you will be able to grow and to flower and to fly away in the wind as a thousand miniature parachutes carrying seed." "Okay," said the amino acids and other nutrients in the soil. They let themselves be dissolved in rainwater and sucked up through the roots and they becarne dandelion.

The next morning, a rabbit carne hopping across the meadow. "Good morning!" said the rabbit to the dandelion, "How would you like to become rabbit? You will have to allow yourself to be nibbled and chewed and swallowed. It hurts a little, but afterwards you will be able to jump and bounce and romp in the moonlight, wiggle your ears, and have lots of baby rabbits." The dandelion was not overly enthusiastic, but the idea of hopping around sounded like a lot more fun than being stuck in one piace. "Okay," said the dandelion with a sigh. It allowed itself to be munched and became rabbit.

Towards evening, a hunter carne by. "Good morning!" said the hunter to the rabbit (for it was an unusually polite hunter), "How would you like to become human? You must allow yourself to be shot dead, skinned, cooked in a stew, and eaten. This is not pleasant, I admit, but imagine, afterwards you will be able to play yo-yo, sing in the shower, and fly in a jet-piane." The rabbit was scared, but flying in a jet-piane seemed so exciting; the idea was irresistible. Sniffling a little and wiping away a tear, the rabbit mumbled, "O.K.," went through with that ordeal and became human.

But then, God carne along. "Hi!" God said. "How would you like to become...?"

Am I willing to pay the price T. S. Eliot spoke of - "A condition of complete simplicity / (Costing not less than everything)"? (Four Quartets, IV:V:253). Do I dare to move towards this goal along the trajectory of courage set up by amino acids, dandelion, and rabbit in the story? The process becomes more and more demanding, yet also more and more fulfilling. Through sensuous asceticism We learn to meet the demands with courage; we learn to see the fulfillment not as achievement, but as pure gift. Our ultimate courage is merely the brave trust to accept the ultimate gift: transformation into that which unawares we are.