back  A Listening Heart continue
Brother David Steindl-Rast

Mirror of the Heart

The Haiku is, paradoxically, a poem about silence. Its very core is silence. There is probably no shorter poetic form in world literature than the classical Haiku with its seventeen syllables and, yet, the masters put these seventeen syllables down with a gesture of apology, which makes it clear that the words merely serve the silence. All that matters is the silence. The Haiku is a scaffold of words; what is being constructed is a poem of silence; and when it is ready, the poet gives a little kick, as it were, to the scaffold. It tumbles, and silence alone stands.

Evening rain
The banana leaf
Speaks of it first.

We can almost hear the first big raindrops falling one by one. But this is already the moment after the decisive one; the moment after the one that held its breath in limitless anticipation. This is not a poem about rain, but about the silence before the rain. A strange poem, the Haiku! It zeroes in on the here and now which is nowhere. It celebrates the all-oneness of aloneness in all the bliss of its poignant pain. It stakes out territory for discovery precisely where life is most daily. And while setting up landmarks of adventure, it wipes out its own footprints. It denies itself. For it shoots words like arrows at the target of silence. Every word that hits the mark returns to the silence out of which it has come.

Does this sound paradoxical? It certainly is, yet, no more paradoxical than you are to yourself. For the Haiku merely mirrors the paradox of the "still point" - the

paradox of the human heart. In a masterly Haiku what it means to be human has been crystallized. Crystallized, not petrified. Not like rock, but lightly as in a snowflake that will melt and become a drop of water as soon as it touches you. Crystallized in the Haiku, the paradox is not dispelled. It is brought home; it is made bearable; you can stand under it and rejoice in it as children rejoice in snowflakes. And thus, standing for once under the paradox rather than over against it, you can understand; you can understand yourself.

Self-understanding attained at the "still point"; this is the core of the Peak Experience; the burden of T. S. Eliot's Four Quartets; the hidden source of Haiku poetry; the goal of the monk. Of course, the goal is the same for all of us, and monastic life is but one possible way of attaining this goal. But in its form, monastic life is paradigmatic, allowing us to trace the human paradox in a few broad strokes.

This is the reason why in today's identity crisis many turn with renewed interest toward monastic tradition. Those whose interest turns in this direction will hardly be able to find a more direct approach to understanding monastic life than the one attempted here. For as long as we try to find access to it from the outside, we won't get beyond highly complex socio-religious phenomena in history; we won't get beyond labels. But approached from within, along the lines suggested here, the monastic quest will be seen to be much more than a periodically recurring fringe phenomenon of organized religion. It will reveal itself as one possible way of realizing a basic human dimension, the exploration of inner space; something pursued by few but in behalf of all; something that concerns each one of us. And, in a measure, it can be understood by every human being.

... the moment in and out of time,
The distraction fit, lost in a shaft of sunlight,
The wild thyme unseen, or the winter lightning
Or the waterfall, or music heard so deeply
That it is not heard at all, but you are the music
While the music lasts.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

lf you have experienced, no matter how marginally, the painful bliss of it all, why not concede the possibility that others might attempt to center their whole life on this one goal:

...to apprehend.
The point of intersection of the timeless
With time…

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

(They may be eccentrics, granted. In fact, one might have to be eccentric in order to feel so strong a need for zeroing in on this center "at the still point." So what? A need is always the reverse side of a talent.)

And if you have experienced the rich aloneness that, though it be for one moment, only dissolves all limits to your oneness with the universe, why not concede the possibility that someone may choose to become a "loner" for the sake of becoming a "brother" to brother wolf and to brother sun, to sister water and to sister death? (After all, monachos means literally "loner," and yet, it is the monk whom everyone calls "brother.")

And, again, if you have seen in a flash that everything makes sense as soon as you go beyond reasoning, you will be ready to understand why some men and women should devote their whole life to the pursuit of this paradox. What they are seeking is:

…Not the intense moment
Isolated, with no before and after,
But a lifetime burning in every moment.

…But to apprehend
The point of intersection of the timeless
With time, is an occupation for the saint
No occupation either, but something given
And taken, in a lifetime's death in love,
Ardor and selflessness and self-surrender.
For most of us, this is the aim
Never here to be realized;
Who are only undefeated
Because we have gone on trying;
For us, there is only the trying.
The rest is not our business.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

The road of monks is but one of the possible roads of approach to the "still point," but it is an approach by which, for a long time, many have made their way. And while some basic experience of the human paradox is necessary to understand the forms of monastic tradition from within, the forms of life that the monks have cultivated may in turn aid us in our understanding of the human paradox.

As we have seen, the human paradox flares up in a sudden flash of self-understanding "at the still point" of the Peak Experience. It happens. No effort we could make would earn for us this experience. It is gratis: gratia gratis data - a gift, always. What, then, can we do towards it? We can prepare ourselves. And how? The monk's answer is: by training. An ascetic is one who trains. (The Greek word askein means "to exercise," and since this exercise is purposeful, we translate, "to train.") This is what asceticism is: goal-directed, systematic training. And the goal is to discover, again and again, "the still point."

No wonder, then, that some decisive strokes, characteristic for the ascetic tradition, should correspond to lines we have been able to trace in the Peak Experience. Thus, we shall encounter again the paradox of a here-and-now intensified beyond space and time. The particular form this paradox assumes in ascetic life is "detachment" (never to be confused with indifference). We shall also find again the paradox of solitude and togetherness, and its particular form will be ascetic "celibacy." And we shall meet again the "this-is-it" experience in all its paradoxical tension. The peculiar accentuation of this tension characteristic of ascetic life gives rise to a whole life-style marked by silence, mindfulness, prayer, celebration. What lies at the root of this life-style is "obedience" - in a much more comprehensive sense, obviously, than obedience has in everyday language

obedience as a constantly renewed listening to the meaning of each moment. All three - detachment, celibacy, and obedience - are directly related to the quest for the "still point."

We have said "detachment," but any connotation of indifference must be completely ruled out. Any resemblance between indifference and detachment is mere deception. For detachment is not a withdrawal from love, but an expansion of love beyond desire. Desire is entangled in time, nostalgic for the past, preoccupied with the future. Love expanding beyond desire is "liberation from the future as well as the past." What remains is the now "where past and future are gathered," the "still point."

In our own daily life we may experience the liberating expansion of love. In fact, we may come to find our own actions less and less important, yet - another paradox - even more significant, as the context in which they are seen expands. This is what happens along the way of monastic detachment: the here and now gains in significance precisely in proportion to the loss of its importance. "At the still point" here and now cease to matter and attain ultimate significance. A "secluded chapel,"

a "winter's afternoon" become "England and nowhere. Never and always" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot).

This implies that training in detachment must aim at cultivating its own awareness of space and time. Nothing short of this will do.

The various forms by which monks of different traditions cultivate the ascetic approach to space, for instance, may appear poles apart from one another. But once we have the clue, it is easy to see that the goal is the same. Forms as different from one another as the homelessness of the pilgrim monk and stability in the cloister are merely two ways to the same goal. A wayfaring monk on the roads of India, or a stylite who spends his life on a pillar; the Irish monks of the Middle Ages seafaring across the northern Atlantic, or the walled-in recluses in ancient Russia; and all those monks whose form of life falls somewhere between these extremes they all simply aim at this: being present where they are, truly, totally present.

...In order to arrive there,
To arrive where you are,
to get from where you are not,
You must go by a way wherein there is no ecstasy.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

"Ecstasy" literally denotes a "being beside oneself," put out of place, even deranged - the very opposite of that total centeredness, that full presence where you are, with both feet on the ground, in a given "instant." That the "ecstasy" should happen at the very "instant" is merely the linguistic reflection of the paradox with which we are here concerned. There is the ecstatic instant, but there is no instant ecstasy. Monastic training is unhurried and down to earth: sweeping, cooking, washing; serving at table or at the altar; reading books or filing library cards; digging, typing, haying, plumbing - but all of this with that affectionate detachment which makes the place where you are the navel of the universe.

To this monastic awareness of place belongs a distinctively monastic awareness of time.

The time of the seasons and the constellations
The time of milking and the time of harvest…

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

The time of "the sea bell's perpetual angelus" on the coast where

The tolling bell
Measures time not our time, rung by the unhurried
Ground swell, a time
Older than the time of chronometers, older
Than Urne counted…

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

And the "unhurried ground swell" becomes an image of that "love expanding beyond desire," detached but not indifferent, on the contrary, alert and responsible - for the time measured by the tolling bell is "not our time." We are called. We must respond.

And the ground swell,
that is and was from the beginning,
Clangs
The bell.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

The angelus bell and the gong, the clapper, the drum, the sounding board are so many ways of keeping time "not our time." This is the decisive point: that it is "not our time." The monks rise and go to sleep, work and celebrate, when "it is time." They are only "keeping" the time, not "setting" it. At the first sound of the bell, the monk is to let loose whatever he is engaged in, and turn to that for which it is time. What matters is the letting loose. It is liberation. Through it the time which was "not our time," all time, becomes ours because we give ourselves to it. Swinging with the living seasons you are "in tune with the world," and it is all yours.

This detachment from time and place through which everything becomes ours because we are fully present in the here and now, this is the seed fruit of monastic detachment, its ultimate accomplishment containing in seed everything.

A condition of complete simplicity
(Costing not less than everything.)

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

All other renunciation is included in the monk's affectionate detachment from the here and now. It points to that ultimate self-detachment in which our true Self is found.

In order to possess what you do not possess
You must go by the way of dispossession.
In order to arrive at what you are not
You must go through the way in which you are not.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

Detachment, understood in this truly catholic, i.e., all-embracing sense, leads us directly to monastic celibacy, because

Love is most nearly itself
When here and now cease to matter.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

Celibacy certainly belongs in the context of "expanding of love beyond desire, and so, liberation." (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot). Seen in this light, the accent switches from the aspect of dispossession, deprivation, renunciation to the aspect of expansion, liberation, fulfilment. In the context of the Peak Experience it makes sense to say that the monk is a celibate, a loner, because his oneness with all is expanding beyond desire. And it is equally true to say that he can embrace this oneness with all only because (and in so far as) he is truly alone. Celibacy is the daring attempt to sustain the "condition of extreme simplicity" in which solitude and togetherness merge so that aloneness becomes all-oneness.

This experience of concord with oneself and with all, a concord realized at the heart of the universe, at the still point - this experience is always granted gratis. But it is one thing to be surprised by it in a flash in the "moment of happiness ... the sudden illumination" and quite a different thing to sustain a life centered on this still point, to remain "still and still moving." For this we need the support of others embarked on the same venture. (Even the hermit needs this support, though less tangibly.) Monastic solitude must be supported by togetherness.

It is surprising how much togetherness one needs in order to save aloneness from deteriorating into loneliness. Here lies the root of monastic community. Solitude and togetherness make each other possible. Take away solitude, and togetherness becomes subhuman gregariousness; take away togetherness and solitude becomes desolation. Community can only exist in the tension between solitude and togetherness. The delicate balance between solitude and togetherness will determine what kind of community it shall be. In the togetherness community of which married life is the prototype, togetherness is the measure of solitude: each of the partners must have as much solitude as they need for rich and full togetherness. In the solitude community of monastic life, solitude is the measure of togetherness: here each partner must have just enough togetherness to enrich and support solitude. Monks in community help one another in love to cultivate and sustain genuine aloneness.

No one can do without this support. Even solitary explorers must still rely on the team that stands behind them. The stakes of this exploration are high. Celibate life means

...a trip that will be unpayable
For a haul that will not bear examination.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

Supported "at the still point," we must explore the togetherness dimension of solitude, the all-oneness of aloneness.

We must be still and still moving
Into another intensity
For a further union, a deeper communion
Through the dark cold and the empty desolation…

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

We shall "know," but to know in this way shall be "the haul that will not bear examination." It will be a kind of knowledge that goes beyond count, beyond measure; not a knowing of knowledge, but a knowing experience.

...There is, it seems to us,
At best, only a limited value
In the knowledge derived from experience.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)

What monks are after is not "knowledge derived," but immediate knowledge; not the knowledge we can grasp, of which we can take hold, but the meaning that speaks to us in the experience, hits us, "grabs" us, takes hold of us. And just as we saw that "time, not our time" gives itself to us as soon as we let loose in detachment and give ourselves over to its liberating power, so the meaning for which we are searching in life gives itself to us as soon as we renounce the effort to grasp it and begin to listen to it. Knowledge tries to grasp; wisdom listens. Listening wisdom: that is obedience.

Obviously, obedience here is taken in its most comprehensive sense. We must not restrict obedience to the notion of "doing someone else's will." This may be a somewhat conspicuous aspect of monastic training, yet submission is not an end in itself. It is a means, and only one of various means. The end is obedience in its full sense as a loving listening to the meaning that comes to us through everything and every person and every situation. lf obedience meant no more than doing someone else's will, it might merely replace my own whims by the whims of someone else, but monastic training is designed to liberate from whim altogether. The master helps the monk to become detached from self-will, but this is only the beginning. The real task is learning to listen. The very word obedience comes from ob-audire, which means to listen intently. Its opposite is to be utterly deaf, and the word for this is literally ab-surdus. Everything is absurd until we learn to listen to its meaning; until we become "all ears" in obedience.

In order to listen, you have to be silent. Silence, then, is another means towards the intent listening of obedience. We mean an inner silence, above all, but this implies an outward silence which expresses and supports the inner. Yet, monastic silence does not consist in the elimination of words, the elimination of noise. This process of elimination leads, at best, to the hush of a public library or of a morgue. Monastic silence is not dead silence; it is alive with the presence of mystery like the silence of a deep forest. It is like the silence of a forester totally mindful of the game he is stalking. And all this recollected silence is intent on one goal: "to apprehend the point of intersection of the timeless with time" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot) - the still point.

Monastic silence
is not
dead silence.
It is
silence alive
with mystery,
with presence.

Monastic mindfulness or recollection, like monastic silence, is directly related to obedience. It is not the grim Memento Mori as which it is sometimes seen. And yet, it is in a sense concerned with death, since death is precisely the ultimate point of intersection of the timeless with time. But the recollection of the monk is not a morbid preoccupation with one's last hour. It is mindfulness of the present hour, the here and now, the "intersection time," and it is in this sense that "the time of death is every moment" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot). At any moment in which you are truly present, your recollected consciousness may shatter the time barrier and burst into now. The moment of total presence, through recollection, is "the moment in and out of time" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot). Thus "history is a pattern of timeless moments" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot).

At any moment
the fully present mind
can shatter time
and burst into
Now.

Through recollected mindfulness, practiced throughout a lifetime, whatever the present moment contains becomes "a symbol, a symbol perfected in death" (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot). In monastic life everything becomes "a symbol" because we are learning to listen to its meaning.

Prayer is unlimited mindfulness. And this coincides with the most traditional notion of prayer while it broadens the concept immensely. For you have always known that you can "say your prayers" without really having prayed. And when we ask: "what is it, then, that makes prayers, prayer?" The answer is "recollection." (Mindfulness means the same and is a term less worn by use and abuse.) If you say your prayers mindfully, you really pray. Well then, what really matters is obviously mindfulness, recollection, openness. The gesture of the open hands, raised in prayer, is in typical contrast to the clenched grip that tries to hold on to things. Prayerful recollection is loving openness to receive the meaning conveyed by a given moment. Set times for prayer are certainly necessary to cultivate prayerfulness, but should we restrict prayer to set times? If we know what it means to say prayers mindfully, we ought to be able to do everything with the same mindfulness. And thus everything becomes prayer; everything becomes celebration. Everything becomes celebration as we learn to take things one by one, moment by moment; to single everything out for grateful consideration.

Seen in this light, prayer, too, is but another way of listening in obedience. Humility, silence, recollection, prayer, what holds all these ascetic practices together is obedience. Detachment makes the monk free for the "trip that will be unpayable." Celibacy is the way in which he sets sail. Obedience is the lifelong voyage of exploration.

Monastic life, in solitude community, is only one way, not the only one. We have said this before. A married man or woman might someday outline by similarly paradigmatic form how the self-finding in a self-losing, the paradox of oneness and aloneness, and the listening for the silent meaning of life express themselves in togetherness community. The points of resemblance with monastic life might turn out to be stunning. When you look at a circle of dancers from outside the circle, those nearest to you will appear to move in one direction, those farthest from you in the opposite one. Yet, contrary to appearance, all of them are moving in the same direction around the circle.

And the way up is the way down, the way
forward is the way back.

(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)