A Listening Heart ![]()
Brother David Steindl-Rast
Mirror of the Heart
I lose myself:
I find myself.
I am alone:
I am one with all.
I stop questioning:
I am the answer.
The thing or situation is simply a word or sign that embodies its significance. It is simply the shape of its meaning. This fragrance of wild thyme, this tone of a flute is simply one shape of Ultimate Reality. I cannot decide where to place the accent. All I am sure of is that "This IS it!"
I hope that you were able to check these aspects of a Peak Experience step by step against your own. Yet all this is still mere talk about experience, and I apologize. Poets don't talk about an experience. They let it come to word. That's quite a different way of approach, and this is where we come to Haiku.
Much must be presupposed here, and much may be presupposed, for excellent introductions to Haiku poetry are easily available in English. But through our reflections on the Peak Experience, we have gained access to Haiku from within, as it were. If you have become aware that you are most truly yourself when you forget yourself; that in truly being alone you are one with all; that everything makes sense as soon as you go beyond reasoning; you have discovered in your own experience the paradox in which Haiku has its roots.
A Haiku does not
talk about
an experience;
a Haiku
triggers
an experience
- your own.
Not that the Masters of Haiku would try to "capture" a Peak Experience (a Western poet might try to do this); what they are trying to do is not to capture the experience, but to set it free - to stimulate you just barely enough to bring back an experience of your own. A master of Haiku will make the reader his co-poet. "We had the experience but missed the meaning." Now, seen in the mirror of Haiku, "the hint half guessed, the gift half understood..." that had been granted to us at last yields its meaning. The poet offers you a mirror, but a mirror without light is empty and dark. The light that flashes in the crystal mirror of Haiku must be the light of your own experience.
But here we are already in the midst of paradox. Did we not say that you had "lost yourself" at the climax of your Peak Experience? Where were you when you were "swept off your feet"? Nowhere and everywhere. How then can the Haiku bring you back to the place that was no place? To that time that was out of time? It does so, paradoxically, by bringing you to a most specific place at a most specific time. (Here lies, incidentally, the importance of the so-called "season word" of classical Haiku.) Vagueness is incompatible with Haiku, because it is altogether incompatible with "the sudden illumination" of the Peak Experience. And the "season word," far from being a literary convention, aims at that bursting of space and time which, paradoxically, coincides with the ultimate clarity and precision of the here and now. It is a strange coincidence that the English word nowhere is a fusion of now and here. "You cannot face it steadily," but if, for one brief now you are truly here (wherever this may be), you are nowhere because you are everywhere.
Here, the intersection of the timeless moment,
Is England and nowhere. Never and always.!
(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)
How, then, can the Haiku help you recover "the point of intersection of the timeless with time"? The point where "all is always now"? How? Simply by Ieaving room. Not by what is said, but by what is left unsaid. This Haiku, for instance, takes shape just at the point where reflection returns, and l, re-entering the orbit of my little self, become aware that l had gone beyond.
The butterfly has disappeared
And now it comes back to me,
My wandering mind.
Who is to capture the moment in which you have lost yourself? The moment of which reflexive awareness can take hold is only the moment after, the moment of return - from where?
I can only say, there we have been:
but I cannot say where.
And I cannot say, how long, for that is to
place it in time.
(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)
And what is it that "comes back to you"? Is it the butterfly or your wandering mind? We are left in suspense. Who can tell in the end? Who needs to tell?
AlI this may have taken place in a flash. But in another Haiku, the poet suggests a losing of self in wonderment, sustained, maybe, for hours throughout a moonlit night.
The moon in the pines
Now I hang it up, now I take it off
And still I keep gazing.
Again that delicate suspense which here pivots on the little word "still." Is it in stillness that I am gazing? Am I still gazing on and on after "hanging" the moon on this branch or that? Or, and this to me is the most intriguing possibility, am I still gazing after having taken down the moon, gazing at nothing, and still gazing?
But just to make sure that moon and butterflies and the moods they evoke are not at all essential to the kind of experience typical for a Haiku let me give you a very different one, still in the context of losing oneself. Here the setting is refreshingly active: rows of farm workers hoeing fields on a distant hill, rhythmically swinging their mattocks.
Up they swing
And the mattocks glitter:
Fields in spring.
What a virile image of spring! That fraction of a moment in which the sun flashes on a shining blade, here and now sparks an explosion of power and joy, bursting your little self, catapulting you to that "still point" where "AlI is always now. " (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)
It takes only a slight shift of emphasis, and the point of aloneness in dynamic stillness becomes the point of consummate union. The butterfly, in whose flight I had lost myself, unified my vision, for by taking me out of myself, it made me one with all, and healed me of duality. And now that almost imperceptible shift of emphasis:
Down the barley rows
Stitching, stitching them together
The butterfly goes.
In a moment of celebration, this butterfly restores aloneness to all-oneness. As I am watching it, stitching the barley rows together, I lose myself and realize the profound paradox hinted at by the English word "alone" - "all-one." To be truly alone is not at all to be lonely, for the heart of my heart, that secret place where I am most intimately myself, is, paradoxically, the point where I am also the most intimately one with all other human beings, with all living beings, with the Source of being. To be truly alone is to be healed of duality, one with my true Self, and thus one with all.
To be alone in this sense is to have reached what T. S. Eliot calls "the still point of the turning world," the still point of the Great Dance, the peak "where past and future are gathered."
Neither movement from nor towards,
Neither ascent nor decline.
Except for the point, the still point,
There would be no dance, and there is
only the dance.
(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)
Let us look at another Haiku:
Five blue butterflies
Summer roadside festival
Dusty boots stand still.
Here, again, the meaning pivots on the ambiguity of the words "stand still." Is this an imperative? Is the poet saying, "For heaven's sake, here it is, the Great Dance? It doesn't take more than a handful of those commonest of all butterflies, the tiny blue ones rarely seen on flowers, but content to put on their summer festival in the ruts of dirt roads running through summer fields. Here it is, the still point of the Great Dance, and it is all yours if only you will stand still!" Or is this again a fully accomplished instance of self lost and Self found, the all-oneness of the solitary traveller whose dusty boots stand still, at long last, "at the still point of the turning world," "and there is only the Dance"?
The lake is lost
In the rain which is lost
In the lake.
They blossom, and then
We gaze, and then the blossoms
Scatter, and then. ...
The pain of blissful aloneness and the bliss of the pain that makes ali one keenly coincide in the peak of the Peak Experience, in the still point, in the Haiku.
The moments of happiness...
We had the experience but missed the meaning,
And approach to the meaning restores the experience
In a different form, beyond any meaning
We can assign to happiness.
(Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)
Pain and bliss are reconciled, all opposites are reconciled, and we are reconciled to the paradox that the opposites coincide. Duality is not eliminated but healed, overcome in solitude-togetherness. Without argument, without reasoning everything suddenly makes sense. We can say "Yes" to paradox.
But this is not a "Yes" of resignation. It is a "Yes" of triumph, an unlimited "Yes" to reality, to Ultimate Reality. It is a "Yes" pregnant with newness of discovery. Our ears are popping; our eyes pop open and see all the familiar things as if we had never seen them before:
Green fields of grain:
A sky-lark rises over there.
Comes down again.
As the spring rains fall,
Soaking in them, on the roof,
/s a child's rag ball.
This freshness of vision may rise to a crescendo of surprise at the most ordinary things. So in the wildest of all the Haiku I know: here the overabundance of cherry
blossoms so fills the poet with sober inebriation that he looks even at horses and birds as if it were for the first time in his life.
Cherry blossoms, more
And more now! birds have two legs!
Oh, horses have four!
The directness and immediacy that is so overpowering here is possibly the most striking characteristic both of the Peak Experience and of the Haiku.
No abstractions here!
They rolled out too far
From their leaf shelter, melons –
And how hot they are!
Truckloads of pumpkins
Swishing by. And in the dust
One busted pumpkin.
One melon, one pumpkin - we see it, we feel it, our whole being says "Yes, this is it," and we have said "Yes" to the whole universe. What is more marvellous, that the meaning of the whole universe gives itself to us in one pumpkin, or that one pumpkin can convey to us the meaning of the whole universe? We need not decide. The marvel lies in the coincidence of the two: that ultimate meaning should be so concrete and that this concrete thing should be so ultimately meaningful.
Between the lightning flash seen and the impact of its meaning perceived, there must not be the slightest crack or crevice into which reflexive thinking could insert itself. This would destroy the immediacy of the experience. This is the burden of Basho's famous statement: "When the lightning flashes, how admirable he who does not think: life is fleeting." To think it would mean to "over-stand" rather than "understand," grasp one aspect of the experience rather than being "grabbed" by its total impact. Understanding hinges on the directness of our insight, 'This IS it!"
It is with the meaning revealed in the Peak Experience that the Haiku is ultimately concerned. Not, of course - and this should be clear from all that we have said - as if the meaning could be separated from the word that gives it expression. The meaning is not another word behind the word. Meaning is silence. It comes to itself as it finds form. It finds form as it comes to word, but meaning, as such, is silent. And "Words, after speech, reach into silence." (Four Quartets, T.S. Eliot)